Roman History
(Incomplete)
Titus Livius
BOOK XXVII.
Cneius Fulvius, proconsul, defeated by Hannibal and slain;
the consul, Claudius Marcellus, engages him with better
success. Hannibal, raising his camp, retires; Marcellus
pursues, and forces him to an engagement. They fight twice; in
the first battle, Hannibal gains the advantage; in the second,
Marcellus. Tarentum betrayed to Fabius Maximus, the consul.
Scipio engages with Hasdrubal, the son of Hamilcar, at
Baetula, in Spain, and defeats him. Among other prisoners, a
youth of royal race and exquisite beauty is taken; Scipio sets
him free, and sends him, enriched with magnificent presents,
to his uncle Masinissa. Marcellus and Quintus Crispinus,
consuls, drawn into an ambuscade by Hannibal; Marcellus is
slain, Crispinus escapes. Operations by Publius Sulpicius,
praetor, against Philip and the Achaeans. A census held;
the number of citizens found to amount to one hundred and
thirty-seven thousand one hundred and eight: from which it
appears how great a loss they had sustained by the number
of unsuccessful battles they had of late been engaged in.
Hasdrubal, who had crossed the Alps with a reinforcement for
Hannibal, defeated by the consuls, Marcus Livius and Claudius
Nero, and slain; with him fell fifty-six thousand men.
1. Such was the state of affairs in Spain. In Italy, the consul Marcellus,
after regaining Salapia, which was betrayed into his hands, took Maronea
and Meles from the Samnites by force. As many as three thousand of the
soldiers of Hannibal, which were left as a garrison, were here surprised
and overpowered. The booty, and there was a considerable quantity of it,
was given up to the troops. Also, two hundred and forty thousand pecks
of wheat, with a hundred and ten thousand pecks of barley, were found here.
The joy, however, thus occasioned, was by no means so great as a disaster
sustained a few days afterwards, not far from the town Herdonea. Cneius
Fulvius, the consul, was lying encamped there, in the hope of regaining
Herdonea, which had revolted from the Romans after the defeat at Cannae,
his position being neither sufficiently secure from the nature of the place,
nor strengthened by guards. The natural negligence of the general was now
increased by the hope that their attachment to the Carthaginians was shaken
when they had heard that Hannibal, after the loss of Salapia, had retired
from that neighborhood into Bruttium. Intelligence of all these circumstances
being conveyed to Hannibal by secret messengers from Herdonea, at once
excited an anxious desire to retain possession of a city in alliance with
him, and inspired a hope of attacking the enemy when unprepared. With a
lightly equipped force he hastened to Herdonea by forced marches, so as
almost to anticipate the report of his approach and in order to strike
greater terror into the enemy, came up with his troops in battle-array.
The Roman, equal to him in courage, but inferior in strength, hastily drawing
out his troops, engaged him. The fifth legion and the left wing of the
allied infantry commenced the battle with spirit. But Hannibal ordered
his cavalry, on a signal given, to ride round as soon as the foot forces
had their eyes and thoughts occupied with the contest before them, and
one half of them to attack the camp of the enemy, the other half to fall
upon their rear, while busily engaged in fighting. He himself, sarcastically
alluding to the similarity of the name Fulvius, as he had defeated Cneius
Fulvius, the praetor, two years ago, in the same country, expressed his
confidence that the issue of the battle would be similar. Nor was this
expectation vain; for after many of the Romans had fallen in the close
contest, and in the engagement with the infantry, notwithstanding which
they still preserved their ranks and stood their ground; the alarm occasioned
by the cavalry on their rear, and the enemy shout, which was heard at the
same time from their camp, first put to flight the sixth legion, which
being posted in the second line, was first thrown into confusion by the
Numidians; and then the fifth legion, and those who were posted in the
van. Some fled precipitately, others were slain in the middle space, where
also Cneius Fulvius himself, with eleven military tribunes, fell. Who can
state with certainty how many thousands of the Romans and their allies
were slain in this battle, when I find in some accounts that thirteen,
in others that not more than seven, thousand were slain? The conquerors
got possession of the camp and the spoil. Finding that Herdonea would have
revolted to the Romans, and was not likely to continue faithful to him
if he departed thence, he removed all its inhabitants to Metapontum and
Thurium, and burnt it. He put to death the chief men who were found to
have held secret conferences with Fulvius. Such of the Romans as escaped
this dreadful carnage, fled half-armed, by different roads, into Samnium,
to the consul Marcellus.
2. Marcellus, who was not much discouraged at this so great a disaster,
sent a letter to the senate at Rome, with an account of the loss of the
general and army at Herdonea; observing, however, "that he who, after
the battle of Cannae, had humbled Hannibal when elated with victory, was
now marching against him, and that he would cause that his present joy
and exultation should not continue long." At Rome, indeed, the grief
occasioned by what had occurred, and the fears entertained for the future,
were excessive. The consul passing out of Samnium into Lucania, pitched
his camp at Numistro, on a plain within view of Hannibal, who occupied
a hill. He added also another demonstration of his confidence; for he was
the first to lead out his troops to battle, nor did Hannibal decline fighting
when he saw the standards carried out from the gates. However, they drew
up their forces so that the right wing of the Carthaginians was extended
up the hill, while the left wing of the Romans was contiguous to the town.
For a long time neither side had any advantage; but the battle having continued
from the third hour till night, and the first lines, which consisted, on
the part of the Romans, of the first legion and the right wing of the allied
infantry, on the part of Hannibal, of the Spanish soldiers, the Balearic
slingers, and the elephants, which were driven into the field after the
commencement of the battle, being fatigued with fighting, the first legion
was relieved by the third, and the right wing of allied infantry by the
left; while on the part of the enemy fresh troops took up the battle in
place of those who were tired. A new and desperate conflict suddenly arose,
instead of that which was so feebly maintained, their minds and bodies
being unimpaired by fatigue; but night separated the combatants while the
victory was undecided. The following day the Romans stood drawn up for
battle from sun-rise till late in the day; but none of the enemy coming
out against them, they gathered the spoils at their leisure, and collecting
the bodies of their own troops into a heap, burnt them. The following night
Hannibal decamped in silence, and moved on into Apulia. As soon as daylight
discovered the flight of the enemy, Marcellus, leaving his wounded under
the protection of a small garrison at Numistro, in command of which he
placed Lucius Furius Purpureo, a military tribune, commenced a close pursuit
of Hannibal, and overtook him at Venusia. Here, during several days, parties
of troops sallying from the outposts, battles took place between foot and
horses promiscuously, rather irregular than important, but which for the
most part were favorable to the Romans. The armies were marched thence
through Apulia without any engagement worth recording; for Hannibal marched
by night, seeking an opportunity for ambuscade, but Marcellus never followed
him except in broad daylight, and after having explored the country.
3. In the mean time, while Flaccus was detained at Capua in selling the
property of the nobles, and letting out the land which had been forfeited,
all of which he let for a rent to be paid in corn, lest occasions for exercising
severity toward the Campanians should be wanting, a new piece of inquiry
which had been ripening in secret, was brought out in evidence. He had
compelled his soldiers, withdrawn from the houses, to build for themselves
huts after the military manner, near the gates and walls; at once, that
the houses of the city might be let and occupied together with the land,
also through fear, lest the excessive luxury of the city should enervate
his troops as it had those of Hannibal. Now many of these were formed of
hurdles or boards, others of reeds interwoven, all being covered with straw,
as if combustible materials had been employed on purpose. A hundred and
seventy Campanians, headed by the Blosii who were fathers, had formed a
conspiracy to set fire to all these at a late hour of the night; but information
of the conspiracy having been given by one of the slaves of the Blosii,
the gates were suddenly closed by the command of the proconsul, and all
the soldiers had been assembled under arms, on a signal given all who were
implicated in the guilt were seized, and, after rigorous examination, were
condemned and executed, informers were rewarded with liberty and ten thousand
asses each. The people of Nuceria and Acerra, who complained that they had no where to dwell, Acerra being partly burnt, and Nuceria demolished, Fulvius sent to Rome to the senate. Permission was given to the people of Acerra to rebuild what had been destroyed by fire. The people of Nuceria were removed to Atella, as they preferred; the people of Atella being ordered to migrate to Calatia. Among the many and important events, sometimes prosperous, sometimes adverse, which occupied men's thoughts, not even the citadel of Tarentum was forgotten. Marcus Ogulnius and Publius Aquillius went into Etruria as commissioners to buy up corn to be conveyed to Tarentum; and one thousand men out of the city troops, an equal number of Romans and allies, were sent to the same place, together with the corn, for its protection.
4. The summer was now on the close, and the time for the election of consuls
drew nigh; but a letter from Marcellus, in which he stated, that it would
not be for the interest of the state that he should depart a single step
from Hannibal, whom he was severely pressing while retreating before him
and evading an engagement, had excited anxiety, lest they must either recall
the consul from the war at that time when he was most actively employed,
or consuls should not be appointed for the year. The best course appeared
to be to recall in preference the consul Valerius from Sicily, although
he was out of Italy. A letter was sent to him by Lucius Manlius, the city
praetor, by order of the senate, together with the letter of Marcus Marcellus,
the consul, that he might learn from it what reason the senate had for
recalling him from his province rather than his colleague. Much about this
time ambassadors came to Rome from king Syphax with accounts of the successful
battles which he had fought with the Carthaginians. They assured the senate
that there was no people to whom the king was more hostile than the Carthaginians,
and none to whom he was more friendly than the Romans. They said, that
"he had before sent ambassadors into Spain, to Cneius and Publius
Cornelius, the Roman generals, but that he was now desirous to solicit
the friendship of the Romans, as it were, from the fountain-head itself."
The senate not only returned a gracious answer to the ambassadors, but
also sent as ambassadors to the king, with presents, Lucius Genucius, Publius
Paetelius, and Publius Popillius. The presents they carried were a purple
gown and vest, an ivory chair, and a bowl formed out of five pounds of
gold. They received orders to proceed forthwith to other petty princes
of Africa carrying with them as presents for them gowns bordered with purple,
and golden bowls weighing three pounds each. Marcus Atilius and Manius
Acilius were also sent as ambassadors to Alexandria, to king Ptolemy and
queen Cleopatra, to revive and renew the treaty of friendship with them,
carrying with them as presents a gown and purple tunic, with an ivory chair
for the king, and an embroidered gown and a purple vest for the queen.
During the summer in which these transactions took place, many prodigies
were reported from the country and cities in the neighborhood; at Tusculum
it was said that a lamb was born with its dug full of milk; that the roof
of the temple of Jupiter was struck with lightning and almost stripped
of its entire covering. Much about the same time it was reported that the
ground in front of the gate at Anagnia was struck, and that it continued
burning for a day and a night without any thing to feed the fire; that
at Compitum in the territory of Anagnia, the birds had deserted the nests
in the trees in the grove of Diana; that snakes of amazing size had leaped
up, like fishes sporting, in the sea at Taracina not far from the port;
at Tarquinii, that a pig was produced with a human face; that in the territory
of Capena at the grove of Feronia, four statues had sweated blood profusely
for a day and a night. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the
greater kind, according to a decree of the pontiffs, and a supplication
was fixed to be performed for one day at Rome at all the shrines, and another
in the territory of Capena at the grove of Feronia.
5. Marcus Valerius, the consul, having been summoned by letter, gave the
command of the province and his army to Cincius the praetor, sent Marcus
Valerius Messala, commander of the fleet, with half of the ships to Africa,
at the same time to plunder the country and observe what the Carthaginians
were doing, and what preparations they were making, and then set out himself
with ten ships for Rome; where, having arrived in safety, he immediately
convened the senate. Here he made a recital of his services. That "after
hostilities had been carried on, and severe losses often sustained, both
by sea and land, through a period of almost sixty years, he had completely
terminated the business of the province. That there was not one Carthaginian
in Sicily, nor one Sicilian absent of those who through fear had been compelled
to go into exile and live abroad; that all of them were brought back to
their cities and fields, and were employed in ploughing and sowing; that
the land which was deserted was now again inhabited, not only yielding
its fruits to its cultivators, but forming a most certain resource for
the supply of provisions to the Roman people in peace and war." After
this, Mutines and such others as had rendered any services to the Roman
people were introduced into the senate, and all received honorary rewards
in fulfillment of the consul's engagement. Mutines was also made a Roman
citizen, a proposition to that effect having been made to the commons by
a plebeian tribune, on the authority of the senate. While these things
were going on at Rome, Marcus Valerius Messala, arriving on the coast of
Africa before daylight, made a sudden descent on the territory of Utica;
and after ravaging it to a great extent, and taking many prisoners, together
with booty of every kind, he returned to his ships and sailed over to Sicily.
He returned to Lilybaeum on the thirteenth day from the time he left it.
From the prisoners, on examination, the following facts were discovered,
and all communicated in writing to the consul Laevinus in order, so that
he might know in what state the affairs of Africa were. That "five
thousand Numidians, with Masinissa, the son of Gala, a youth of extraordinary
spirit, were at Carthage, and that other troops were hiring throughout
all Africa, to be passed over into Spain to Hasdrubal; in order that he
might, as soon as possible, pass over into Italy, with as large a force
as could be collected, and form a junction with Hannibal." That the
Carthaginians considered their success dependent on this measure. That
a very large fleet was also in preparation for the recovery of Sicily,
which they believed would sail thither in a short time. The recital of
these facts had such an effect upon the senate, that they resolved that
the consul ought not to wait for the election, but that a dictator should
be appointed to hold it, and that the consul should immediately return
to his province. A difference of opinion delayed this, for the consul declared
that he should nominate as dictator Marcus Valerius Messala, who then commanded
the fleet in Sicily; but the fathers denied that a person could be appointed
dictator who was not in the Roman territory, and this was limited by Italy.
Marcus Lucretius, a plebeian tribune, having taken the sense of the senate
upon the question, it was decreed, "that the consul before he quitted
the city, should put the question to the people, as to whom they wished
to be appointed dictator, and that he should nominate whomsoever they directed.
If the consul were unwilling that the praetor should put the question,
and if even he were unwilling to do it, that then the tribunes should make
the proposition to the commons." The consul refusing to submit to
the people what lay in his own power, and forbidding the praetor to do
so, the plebeian tribunes put the question, and the commons ordered that
Quintus Fulvius, who was then at Capua, should be nominated dictator. But
on the night preceding the day on which the assembly of the people was
to be held for that purpose, the consul went off privately into Sicily;
and the fathers, thus deserted, decreed that a letter should be sent to
Marcus Claudius, in order that he might come to the support of the state,
which had been abandoned by his colleague, and appoint him dictator whom
the commons had ordered. Thus Quintus Fulvius was appointed dictator by
Marcus Claudius, the consul, and in conformity with the same order of the
people, Publius Licinius Crassus, chief pontiff, was appointed master of
the horse by Quintus Fulvius, the dictator.
6. After the dictator had arrived at Rome, he sent Cneius Sempronius Blaesus, who had acted under him as lieutenant general at Capua, into the province of Etruria, to take the command of the army there, in the room of the praetor, Caius Calpurnius, whom he had summoned by letter to take the command of Capua and his own army. He fixed the first date he could for the election: which, however, could not be brought to a conclusion, in consequence of a dispute which arose between the tribunes and the dictator. The junior century of the Galerian tribe, to whose lot it fell to give the votes first, had named Quintus Fulvius and Quintus Fabius as consuls; and the other centuries, on being called upon to vote according to their course, would have inclined the same way, had not the plebeian tribunes, Caius and Lucius Arennius interposed. They said, "that it was hardly constitutional that a chief magistrate should be continued in office but that it was a precedent still more shocking, that the very person who held the election should be appointed. Then therefore, if the dictator should allow his own name to appear they would interpose against the election; but if the names of any other persons besides himself were put up, they should not impede it." The dictator defended the election by the authority of the fathers, the order of the commons, and precedents. For, "in the consulate of Cneius Servilius, when the other consul, Caius Flaminius, had fallen at Trasimenus, it was proposed to the people on the authority of the fathers, and the people had ordered, that as long as the war continued in Italy, it should be lawful for the people to elect to the consulship whomsoever they pleased, out of those persons who had been consuls, and as often as they pleased. That he had a precedent of ancient date, which was to the point, in the case of Lucius Posthumius Megellus, who, while he was interrex, had been created consul with Caius Junius Bubulcus, at an election over which he himself presided; and a precedent of recent date, in Quintus Fabius, who certainly would never have allowed himself to be re-elected, had it not been for the good of the state." After the contest had been continued for a long time, by arguments of this kind, at length the tribunes and the dictator came to an agreement, that they should abide by what the senate should decide. The fathers were of opinion, that such was then the condition of the state, that it was necessary that its affairs should be conducted by old and experienced generals, who were skilled in the art of war; and, therefore, that no delay should take place in the election. The tribunes then withdrew their opposition, and the election was held. Quintus Fabius Maximus was declared consul for the fifth time, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus for the fourth. The praetors were then created; Lucius Veturius Philo, Titus Quintus Crispinus, Caius Hostilius Tubulus, and Caius Aurunculeius. The magistrates for the year being appointed, Quintus Fulvius resigned the dictatorship. At the end of this summer, a Carthaginian fleet of forty ships, under the command of Hamilcar, passed over to Sardinia. At first it laid waste the territory of Olbia, and then Publius Manlius Vulso, with his army, making his appearance, it sailed round thence to the other side of the island, and devastating the territory of Caralis, returned to Africa with booty of every kind. Several Roman priests died this year, and others were substituted. Caius Servilius was appointed pontiff, in the place of Titus Otacilius Crassus. Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Tiberius, was appointed as augur, in the place of Titus Otacilius Crassus; and Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Tiberius, was appointed decemvir for the performance of sacred rites, in the room of Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Caius. Marcus Marcius, king of the sacred rites, and Marcus Aemilius Papus, chief curio, died; but no priests were appointed to succeed them this year. The censors this year were Lucius Veturius Philo, and Publius Licinius Crassus chief pontiff. Licinius Crassus had neither been consul nor praetor before he was appointed censor, he stepped from the aedileship to the censorship. These censors neither chose the senate, nor transacted any public business, the death of Lucius Veturius prevented it; on this Licinius also gave up his office. The curule aediles, Lucius Veturius and Publius Licinius Varus, repeated the Roman games during one day. The plebeian aediles, Quintus Catius and Lucius Porcius Licinius, furnished brazen statues for the temple of Ceres, out of the money arising from fines, and exhibited games with great pomp and splendor, considering the circumstances of the times.
7. At the close of this year, Caius Laelius, the lieutenant general
of Scipio, came to Rome on the thirty-fourth day after he set out from
Tarraco, and entering the city accompanied by a train of captives,
drew together a great concourse of people. The next day, on being
brought into the senate, he stated that Carthage, the capital of
Spain, had been captured in one day, that several cities which had
revolted were regained, and that fresh ones had been received into
alliance. From the prisoners, information was gained, corresponding
for the most part with what was contained in the letter of Marcus
Valerius Messala. What produced the greatest effect upon the fathers,
was the march of Hasdrubal into Italy, which was with difficulty
resisting Hannibal and his forces. Laelius also, who was brought
before the general assembly, gave a particular statement of the same
things. The senate decreed a supplication for one day, on account of
the successes of Publius Scipio, and ordered Caius Laelius to return
as soon as possible to Spain, with the ships he had brought with him.
I have laid the taking of Carthage in this year, on the authority of
many writers, although aware that some have stated that it was taken
the following year, because it appeared to me hardly probable that
Scipio should have spent an entire year in Spain in doing nothing.
Quintus Fabius Maximus for the fifth time, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus
for the fourth having entered on their offices of consuls on the ides
of March, on the same day, Italy was decreed as the province of both,
their command, however, was distributed to separate districts. Fabius
was appointed to carry on the war at Tarentum; Fulvius in Lucania and
Bruttium. Marcus Claudius was continued in command for the year. The
praetors then cast lots for their provinces. Caius Hostilius Tubulus
obtained the city jurisdiction; Lucius Veturius Philo the foreign,
with Gaul; Titus Quinctius Crispinus, Capua; Caius Aurunculeius,
Sardinia. The troops were thus distributed through the provinces:
Fulvius received the two legions which Marcus Valerius Laevinus had in
Sicily; Quintus Fabius, those which Caius Calpurnius had commanded
in Etruria. The city troops were to succeed those in Etruria; Caius
Calpurnius commanding the same province and the army. Titus Quinctius
was to take the command of Capua, and the army which had served under
Quintus Fulvius there. Lucius Veturius was to succeed Caius Laetorius,
propraetor, in his province and the command of the army, which was
then at Ariminum. Marcus Marcellus had the legions with which he had
been successful when consul. To Marcus Valerius together with Lucius
Cincius, for these also were continued in command in Sicily, the
troops which had fought at Cannae were given, with orders to recruit
them out of the surviving soldiers of the legions of Cneius Fulvius.
These were collected and sent by the consuls into Sicily, and the same
ignominious condition of service was added, under which the troops
which had fought at Cannae served, and to those troops belonging to
the army of Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, which had been sent thither
by the senate through displeasure occasioned by a similar flight.
Caius Aurunculeius was appointed to command, in Sardinia, the same
legions with which Publius Manlius Vulso had occupied that province.
Publius Sulpicius was continued in command for the year, with orders
to hold Macedonia with the same legion and fleet. Orders were given
to send thirty quinqueremes from Sicily to Tarentum, to the consul
Fabius. With the rest of the ships, orders were given that Marcus
Valerius Laevinus should either pass over himself into Africa to
ravage the country, or send either Lucius Cincius or Marcus Valerius
Messala. With regard to Spain, no alteration was made, except that
Scipio and Silanus were continued in command, not for the year, but
until they should be recalled by the senate. In such manner were the
provinces and the commands of the armies distributed for this year.
8. Amid concerns of greater importance, an old dispute was revived at
the election of a chief curio, when a priest was appointed to succeed
Marcus Aemilius; the patricians denying that Caius Mamilius Vitulus,
who was a plebeian candidate, ought to be allowed to stand, because no
one before his time had held that priesthood who was not a patrician.
The tribunes, on being appealed to, referred the matter to the senate.
The senate left it to the decision of the people. Thus Caius Mamilius
Vitulus was the first plebeian created chief curio. Publius Licinius,
chief pontiff, compelled Caius Valerius Flaccus to be inaugurated
flamen of Jupiter, against his will. Caius Valerius Laetorius was
created decemvir for the performance of sacred rites, in the room of
Quintus Mucius Scaevola, deceased. I should willingly have passed over
in silence the reason of a flamen's being compelled to be inaugurated,
had he not become a good, from having been a bad character. In
consequence of having spent his youth in idleness and debauchery,
vices for which he had incurred the displeasure of his own brother,
Lucius Flaccus, and the rest of his kinsmen, Caius Flaccus was chosen
flamen by Publius Licinius, chief pontiff. As soon as his mind became
occupied with the care of the sacred rites and ceremonies, he soon so
completely divested himself of his former habits, that no one among
all the youth was more esteemed, or enjoyed in a greater degree the
approbation of the chief of the patricians, whether relations or
aliens. Being raised by this generally good character to a proper
confidence in himself, he claimed to be admitted into the senate; a
thing intermitted for many years, on account of the worthlessness of
former flamens. On entering the senate, Lucius Licinius, the praetor,
led him out; on which the flamen appealed to the tribunes of the
people. He demanded back the ancient privilege of his priesthood,
which was given, together with the purple-bordered robe, and the
curule chair, to the office of flamen. The praetor wished the question
to rest not on the precedents contained in the annals, which were
obsolete from their antiquity, but on the usual practice in all the
cases of most recent date; urging, that no flamen of Jupiter, in
the memory of their fathers or their grandfathers, had taken up that
privilege. The tribunes giving it as their opinion, that justice
required, that as the obliteration of the privilege was occasioned by
the negligence of the flamens, the consequences ought to fall upon the
flamens themselves, and not upon the office, led the flamen into the
senate, with the general approbation of the fathers, and without any
opposition, even from the praetor himself; while all were of opinion
that the flamen had obtained his object more from the purity of his
life, than any right appertaining to the priesthood. The consuls,
before they departed to their provinces, raised two legions for the
city, and as many soldiers as were necessary to make up the numbers
of the other armies. The consul Fulvius appointed his brother, Caius
Fulvius Flaccus, lieutenant-general, to march the old city army into
Etruria, and to bring to Rome the legions which were in Etruria. And
the consul Fabius ordered his son, Quintus Fabius Maximus, to lead the
remains of the army of Fulvius, which had been collected, amounting
to three thousand three hundred and thirty-six, into Sicily to Marcus
Valerius, the proconsul, and to receive from him two legions and
thirty quinqueremes. The withdrawing of these legions from the island
did not at all diminish the force employed for the protection of that
province, either in effect or appearance; for though, in addition to
two veteran legions which were most effectively reinforced, he had
a great number of Numidian deserters, both horse and foot, he raised
also a body of Sicilian troops, consisting of men who had served in
the armies of Epicydes and the Carthaginians, and were experienced
in war. Having added these foreign auxiliaries to each of the Roman
legions, he preserved the appearance of two armies. With one he
ordered Lucius Cinctius to protect that portion of the island which
had formed the kingdom of Hiero, with the other he himself guarded the
rest of the island, which was formerly divided by the boundary of the
Roman and Carthaginian dominions. He divided also the fleet of seventy
ships, in order that it might protect the sea-coast, through the
entire extent of its shores. He himself went through the island with
the cavalry of Mutines to inspect the lands, observe those which were
cultivated and those which were not, and, accordingly, either praise
or reprove the owners. By this diligence so large a quantity of corn
was produced, that he both sent some to Rome, and collected at Catana
corn which might serve as a supply for the army, which was about to
pass the summer at Tarentum.
9. But the transportation of the soldiers into Sicily, and they
consisted chiefly of Latins and allies, had very nearly caused a
serious commotion; from such trifling circumstances do events of great
importance frequently arise. A murmuring arose among the Latins and
allies at their meetings. They said, that "they had been drained by
levies and contributions for ten years. That almost every year they
fought with the most disastrous consequences. That some of them
were slain in the field, others were carried off by disease. That a
countryman of theirs who was enlisted by the Romans was more lost to
them than one who was taken prisoner by the Carthaginians; for the
latter was sent back to his country by the enemy without ransom, while
the former was sent beyond the limits of Italy, into exile rather than
military service. That the troops which fought at Cannae were growing
old there, for eight years, and would die there before the enemy,
who was now more than ever flourishing and vigorous would depart from
Italy. If the old soldiers did not return to their country, and fresh
ones were enlisted, that in a short time there would be no one left.
That, therefore, they must refuse to the Roman people, before they
came to utter desolation and want, what shortly their very condition
would refuse. If the Romans saw their allies unanimous on this
point that they would then certainly think of making peace with the
Carthaginians; otherwise, Italy would never be without war while
Hannibal was alive." Thus they discoursed in their meetings. The Roman
people had at that time thirty colonies. Twelve of these, for they all
had embassies in Rome, told the consuls that they had not whence to
furnish either men or money. The twelve were Ardea, Nepete Sutrium,
Alba, Carseoli, Cora, Suessa, Cerceii, Setia, Cales Narnia, Interamna.
The consuls, astonished at this new proceeding, were desirous to deter
them from so hateful a measure and, considering that they could effect
this better by censure and remonstrance than by mild means, said that
"they had dared to say to the consuls what the consuls could not bring
their minds to declare in the senate; for that this was not refusal to
perform military service, but an open defection from the Roman people.
They desired, therefore, that they would return to their colonies
speedily, and that, considering the subject as untouched, as they had
only spoken of, but not attempted, so impious a business, they would
consult with their countrymen. That they would warn them that they
were not Campanians or Tarentines, but Romans; that from thence they
derived their origin, and thence were sent out into colonies and lands
captured from the enemy, for the purpose of increasing the population.
That they owed to the Romans what children owed to parents, if they
possessed any natural affection, or any gratitude towards their mother
country. That they should, therefore, consider the matter afresh; for
that certainly what they then so rashly meditated, was the betraying
the Roman empire, and putting the victory in the hands of Hannibal."
The consuls having spent a long time in exchanging arguments of this
kind, the ambassadors, who were not at all moved by what they said,
declared, that "they had nothing which they could carry home, nor
had their senate any thing fresh to devise, having neither men to be
enlisted, nor money to be furnished for pay." The consuls, seeing that
they were inflexible, laid the matter before the senate; where the
alarm excited in the minds of all was so great, that "the greater
part declared it was all over with the empire; that the rest of the
colonies would take the same course, and that all the allies had
conspired to betray the city of Rome to Hannibal."
10. The consuls endeavored to encourage and console the senate, telling
them that "the other colonies would maintain their allegiance, and
continue in their former state of dutiful obedience, and that those very
colonies who had renounced their allegiance, would be inspired with respect
for the empire, if ambassadors were sent round to them to reprove and not
entreat them." The senate having given them permission to do and to
act as they might conceive best for the state; after sounding the intentions
of the other colonies, the consuls summoned their ambassadors, and asked
them whether they had their soldiers ready according to the roll? Marcus
Sextilius of Fregellae replied, in behalf of the eighteen colonies, that
"they both had their soldiers ready according to the roll, and if
more were wanting would furnish more, and would perform with all diligence
whatever else the Roman people commanded and wished; that to do this they
wanted not means, and of inclination they had more than enough." The
consuls, having first told them that any praises bestowed by themselves
alone seemed too little for their deserts, unless the whole body of the
fathers should thank them in the senate-house, led them before the senate.
The senate, having voted an address to them conceived in the most honorable
terms, charged the consuls to take them before the assembly of the people;
and, among the many other distinguished services rendered to themselves
and their ancestors, to make mention also of this recent obligation conferred
upon the state. Nor even at the present day, after the lapse of so many
ages let their names be passed over in silence, nor let them be defrauded
of the praise due to them. They were the people of Signia, Norba, Saticulum,
Brundusium, Fregellae, Lucerium Venusia, Adria, Firma, Ariminum; on the
other sea, Pontius Paestum, and Cosa; and in the inland parts Beneventum,
Aesernia, Spoletum, Placentia, and Cremona. By the support of these colonies
the empire of the Roman people then stood; and the thanks both of the senate
and the people were given to them. As to the twelve other colonies which
refused obedience, the fathers forbade that their names should be mentioned,
that their ambassadors should either be dismissed or retained, to be addressed
by the consuls. Such a tacit reproof appears most consistent with the dignity
of the Roman people. While the consuls were getting in readiness all the
other things which were necessary for the war, it was resolved that the
vicesimary gold, which was preserved in the most sacred part of the treasury
as a resource in cases of extreme exigencies should be drawn out. There
were drawn out as many as four thousand pounds of gold, from which five
hundred pounds each were given to the consuls, to Marcus Marcellus and
Publius Sulpicius, proconsuls, and Lucius Veturius, the praetor, who had
by lot obtained Gaul as his province; and in addition, one hundred pounds
of gold were given to the consul Fabius, as an extraordinary grant to be
carried into the citadel of Tarentum. The rest they employed in contracts,
for ready money, for clothing for the army which was carrying on the war
in Spain, to their own and their general glory.
11. It was resolved also, that the prodigies should be expiated before the consuls set out from the city. In the Alban mount, the statue of Jupiter and a tree near the temple were struck by lightning; at Ostia, a grove; at Capua, a wall and the temple of Fortune; at Sinuessa, a wall and a gate. Some also asserted, that water at Alba had flowed tinged with blood. That at Rome, within the cell of Fors Fortuna, an image, which was in the crown of the goddess, had fallen spontaneously from her head into her hands. At Privernum, it was satisfactorily established that an ox spoke, and that a vulture flew down into a shop, while the forum was crowded. And that a child was born at Sinuessa, of ambiguous sex, between a male and female, such as are commonly called Androgynes, a term derived from the Greek language, which is better adapted, as for most other purposes, so for the composition of words; also that it rained milk, and that a boy was born with the head of an elephant. These prodigies were then expiated with victims of the larger kind, and a supplication at every shrine and an offering up of prayers, was proclaimed for one day. It was also decreed, that Caius Hostilius, the praetor, should vow and perform the games in honor of Apollo as they had of late years been vowed and performed. During the same time, Quintus Fulvius, the consul, held an election for the creation of censors. Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, both of whom had not yet been consuls, were created censors. The question was put to the people on the authority of the fathers, and the people ordered that these censors should let to farm the Campanian lands. The choosing of the senate was delayed by a dispute which arose between the censors about the selection of a chief of the senate. The choice belonged to Sempronius; but Cornelius contended that the custom handed down by their fathers must be followed, which was, that they should choose him as chief of the senate who was first censor of those who were then alive; this was Titus Manlius Torquatus. Sempronius rejoined, that to whom the gods had given the lot of choosing, to him the same gods had given the right of exercising his discretion freely. That he would act in this affair according to his own free will, and would choose Quintus Fabius Maximus, whom he would prove to be the first man in the Roman state, even in the judgment of Hannibal. After a long verbal dispute, his colleague giving up the point, Quintus Fabius Maximus, the consul, was chosen, by Sempronius, chief of the senate. Another senate was then chosen, and eight names were passed over; among which was that of Lucius Caecilius Metellus, disrespected as the adviser of the abandonment of Italy, after the defeat at Cannae. In censuring those of the equestrian order, the same ground was acted upon, but there were very few to whom that disgrace belonged. All of the equestrian order belonging to the legions who had fought at Cannae, and were then in Sicily, were deprived of their horses. To this severe punishment they added another relating to time, which was, that the past campaign which they had served on horses furnished at the public expense should not be reckoned to them, but that they should serve ten campaigns on horses furnished at their own expense. They also searched for, and discovered, a great number of those who ought to have served in the cavalry; and all those who were seventeen years old at the beginning of the war and had not served, they disfranchised. They then contracted for the restoration of the seven shops, the shamble and the royal palace, situated round the forum, and which had been consumed by fire.
12. Having finished every thing which was to be done in Rome, the consuls
set out for the war. Fulvius first went advance to Capua; in a few days
Fabius followed. He implored his colleague in person, and Marcellus by
a letter use the most vigorous measures to detain Hannibal, while he was
making an attack upon Tarentum. That when that city was taken from the
enemy, who had been repulsed on all sides and had no place where he might
make a stand or look back up as a safe retreat, he would not then have
even a pretext for remaining in Italy. He also sent a messenger to Rhegium,
the praefect of the garrison, which had been placed there the consul Laevinus,
against the Bruttians, and consisted eight thousand men, the greater part
of whom had been brought from Agathyrna in Sicily, as has been before mentioned,
and were men who had been accustomed to live by rapine. To these were added
fugitives of the Bruttians natives of that country, equal to them in daring,
and under an equal necessity of braving every thing. This band ordered
to be marched, first, to lay waste the Bruttian territory, and then to
attack the city Caulonia. After having executed the order, not only with
alacrity, but avidity, and having pillaged and put to flight the cultivators
of the land they attacked the city with the utmost vigor. Marcellus incited
by the letter of the consul, and because he had made up his mind that no
Roman general was so good a match for Hannibal as himself, set out from
his winter quarters as soon as there was plenty of forage in the fields,
and met Hannibal at Canusium. The Carthaginian was then endeavoring to
induce the Canusians to revolt, but as soon as he heard that Marcellus
was approaching, he decamped thence. The country was open, without any
covers adapted for an ambuscade; he therefore began to retire thence into
woody districts. Marcellus closely pursued him, pitched his camp close
to his, and when he had completed his works, led out his troops into the
field. Hannibal engaged in slight skirmishes, and sent out single troops
of horse and the spearmen from his infantry, not considering it necessary
to hazard a general battle. He was, however, drawn on to a contest of that
kind which he was avoiding. Hannibal had decamped by night, but was overtaken
by Marcellus in a plain and open country. Then, while encamping, Marcellus,
by attacking the workmen on all hands, prevented the completion of his
works. Thus a pitched battle ensued, and all their forces were brought
into action; but night coming on, they retired from an equal contest. They
then hastily fortified their camps, which were a small space apart, before
night. The next day, as soon as it was light, Marcellus led out his troops
into the field; nor did Hannibal decline the challenge, but exhorted his
soldiers at great length, desiring them "to remember Trasimenus and
Cannae, and thus quell the proud spirit of their enemies." He said,
"the enemy pressed upon him, and trod upon their heels; that he did
not allow them to pass unmolested, pitch their camp, or even take breath
and look around them; that every day, the rising sun and the Roman troops
in battle-array were to be seen together on the plains. But if in one battle
he should retire from the field, not without loss of blood, he would then
prosecute the war more steadily and quietly." Fired by these exhortations,
and at the same time wearied with the presumption of the enemy, who daily
pressed upon them and provoked them to an engagement, they commenced the
battle with spirit. The battle continued for more than two hours, when
the right wing of the allies and the chosen band began to give way on the
part of the Romans; which Marcellus perceiving, led the eighteenth legion
to the front. While some were retiring in confusion, and others were coming
up reluctantly, the whole line was thrown into disorder, and afterwards
completely routed; while their fears getting the better of their sense
of shame, they turned their backs. In the battle and in the flight there
fell as many as two thousand seven hundred of the citizens and allies;
among which were four Roman centurions and two military tribunes, Marcus
Licinius and Marcus Helvius. Four military standards were lost by the wing
which first fled, and two belonging to the legion which came up in place
of the retiring allies.
13. Marcellus, on his return to the camp, delivered an address to
his soldiers so severe and acrimonious, that the words of their
exasperated general were more painful to them than what they had
suffered in the unsuccessful battle during the whole day. "I praise
and thank the immortal gods," said he "that in such an affair the
victorious enemy did not assail our very camp, when you were hurrying
into the rampart and the gates with such consternation. There can be
no doubt but you would have abandoned the camp with the same cowardice
with which you gave up the battle. What panic was this? What terror?
What sudden forgetfulness of who you are, and who the persons with
whom you were fighting, took possession of your minds? Surely these
are the same enemies in conquering and pursuing whom when conquered
you spent the preceding summer; whom latterly you have been closely
pursuing while they fled before you night and day; whom you have
wearied by partial battles; whom yesterday you would not allow either
to march or encamp. I pass over those things in which you might be
allowed to glory; I will mention a circumstance which of itself ought
to fill you with shame and remorse. Yesterday you separated from the
enemy on equal terms. What alteration has last night, what on this
day, produced? Have your forces been diminished by them, or theirs
increased? I verily do not seem to be talking to my own troops, or
to Roman soldiers. The bodies and the arms are the same. Had you
possessed the same spirit, would the enemy have seen your backs? Would
they have carried off a standard from any company or cohort? Hitherto
he was wont to boast of having cut to pieces the Roman legions, but
yesterday you gave him the glory, for the first time, of having put
to flight an army." On this many soldiers began to call upon him to
pardon them for that day, and entreat that he would now, whenever he
pleased, make trial of the courage of his soldiers. "I will indeed
make trial of you," said he, "and to-morrow I will lead you into the
field, that in the character of conquerors, rather than conquered men,
you may obtain the pardon you seek." To the cohorts which had
lost their standards, he ordered that barley should be given. The
centurions of the Campanians, whose standards were lost, he left to
stand without their girdles and with their swords drawn; and gave
orders that all, both horse and foot, should be ready under arms
on the following day. Thus the assembly was dismissed; the soldiers
confessing that they had been justly and deservedly rebuked; and that
there was no one in the whole Roman army who had acquitted himself
like a man, except the general, to whom they were bound to make
atonement, either by their death or a glorious victory. The next
day they appeared in readiness, according to the order, armed and
equipped. The general praised them, and gave out, that "he should
lead into the first line those who had commenced the flight on the
preceding day, and those cohorts which had lost their standards. He
now charged them all to fight and conquer, and exert every effort, one
and all, that the intelligence of yesterday's flight might not arrive
at Rome before that of this day's victory." They were then ordered
to refresh themselves with food, in order that, if the fight should
continue longer than might be expected, their strength might not fail.
After every thing had been done and said, by which the courage of the
soldiers might be roused, they advanced into the field.
14. Hannibal, on receiving intelligence of this, said, "surely the
enemy we have to do with can neither bear good nor bad fortune. If he is
victorious, he fiercely pursues the vanquished. If conquered, he renews
the contest with the victors." He then ordered the signal to be given,
and led out his forces. The battle was fought on both sides with much more
spirit than the day before. The Carthaginians exerting themselves to the
utmost, to keep the glory they had acquired yesterday; the Romans, to remove
their disgrace. On the side of the Romans, the left wing, and the cohorts
which had lost their standards, fought in the first line, and the twentieth
legion was drawn up on the right wing. Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Caius
Claudius Nero, lieutenant-generals, commanded the wings, Marcellus gave
vigor to the center by his presence, as an encourager and a witness. On
the part of Hannibal, the Spaniards, who were the flower of his whole army,
occupied the front line. After the battle had continued doubtful for a
long time, Hannibal ordered the elephants to be advanced into the front
line, if by that means any confusion or panic could be created. At first,
they threw the troops into confusion and broke their ranks, and treading
some under foot, and dispersing others who were round them by the alarm
they created, had made an opening in one part of the Roman line; and the
flight would have spread more widely had not Caius Decimus Flavius, a military
tribune seizing the standard of the first maniple of the spearmen ordered
that maniple to follow him. He led them to the spot where the elephants,
collected in a body, were creating the greatest confusion, and ordered
them to discharge their javelins at them. As there was no difficulty in
hitting such bulky bodies at a short distance, and where so many were crowded
together, all their javelins stuck in them. But they were not all wounded,
so those in whose hides the javelins stuck, as that race of animals is
not to be depended on, by taking themselves to flight, drove away those
also which were untouched. At that moment not only one maniple, but all
the soldiers who could but overtake the body of retreating elephants, threw
their javelins at them, each man exerting himself to his utmost. With so
much greater impetuosity did the animals rush upon their own men, and so
much greater carnage did they make amongst them than they had made amongst
their enemies, in proportion as the violence with which they are impelled,
and the consternation produced by them when under the influence of fear,
is greater than when they are ruled by their masters seated on their backs.
The Roman infantry bore their standards against the line of the enemy when
thrown into disorder by the elephants which had crossed over to them, and,
thus scattered and confused, led them to flight without any great opposition.
Marcellus sent his cavalry after them as they fled; nor did they desist
from the pursuit till they were driven in consternation to their camp.
For in addition to the other causes which occasioned terror and dismay,
two elephants had fallen just by the gate, and the soldiers were compelled
to rush into the camp over the ditch and rampart. Here the greatest slaughter
of the enemy occurred. There fell as many as eight thousand men and five
elephants. Nor did the Romans gain a bloodless victory; about seventeen
hundred of the two legions, and thirteen hundred of the allies were slain;
a great number of the Romans and allies were wounded. The following night
Hannibal decamped. The great number of the wounded prevented Marcellus
from following him, as he desired.
15. The spies who were sent to watch his movements brought word back the
next day that Hannibal was making for Bruttium. Much about the same time
the Hirpinians, Lucanians, and Volcentes surrendered themselves to the
consul, Quintus Fulvius, delivering up the garrisons of Hannibal which
they had in their cities. They were mildly received by the consul, with
only a verbal reproof for their past error. To the Bruttians also similar
hopes of pardon were held out, when two brothers, Vibius and Pactius, by
far the most illustrious persons of that nation, came from them to solicit
the same terms of surrender which had been given to the Lucanians. Quintus
Fabius, the consul, took by storm Manduria, a town in the territory of
Sallentum, where as many as four thousand men were made prisoners, and
much booty taken besides. Proceeding thence to Tarentum, he pitched his
camp in the very mouth of the harbor: of the ships which Livius had employed
for protecting convoys, some he loaded with engines and implements for
attacking walls, others he furnished with machines for discharging missiles,
and with stones and missiles of every kind; not only those which were impelled
with oars, but the storeships also, in order that some might carry the
engines and ladders to the walls, while others might wound the defenders
of the walls by discharging missiles from the ships at a distance. These
ships were fitted up and prepared to attack the town from the open sea;
and the sea was free from the Carthaginian fleet, which had crossed over
to Corcyra on account of Philip's preparing to attack the Aetolians. Meanwhile,
those who were attacking Caulon, in the territory of Bruttium, fearful
lest they should be overpowered, had retired on the approach of Hannibal
to an eminence, secure from an immediate attack. While Fabius was besieging
Tarentum, he received assistance in the accomplishment of that great object
by a circumstance which in the mere mention, is unimportant. Tarentum was
occupied by a garrison of Bruttians, given them by Hannibal and the commander
of that garrison was desperately in love with a girl, whose brother was
in the army of the consul Fabius. Being informed, by a letter from his
sister, of the new acquaintance she had formed with a wealthy stranger
and one so honored among his countrymen, and conceiving a hope that the
lover, by means of his sister, might be induced to any thing she pleased,
he acquainted the consul with the hope he had formed. His reasoning appeared
not altogether unfounded, and he was desired to go to Tarentum as a deserter
and having gained the confidence of the praefect by means of his sister,
he began by sounding his disposition in a covert manner, and then, having
sufficiently ascertained his weakness, induced him, by the aid of female
fascinations, to the betrayal of that custody of the place to which he
was appointed. After the method to be pursued and the time for putting
the plan into effect had been agreed upon, a soldier, who was sent out
of the city by night clandestinely, through the intervals between the guards,
related to the consul what had been done, and what had been agreed upon
to be done. At the first watch, Fabius, on a signal given to those who
were in the citadel, and those who had the custody of the harbor went himself
round the harbor, and took up a position of concealment, on the side of
the city which faced the east. Then the trumpets began to sound at once
from the citadel, the harbor, and the ships which had been brought to the
shore from the open sea, and a shout was purposely raised, accompanied
with the greatest confusion, in whatever quarter there was the least danger.
Meanwhile, the consul kept the men in silence. Democrates, therefore, who
had formerly commanded the fleet, and happened to be in command in the
quarter, seeing that all was quiet around him, while other parts of the
city resounded with such a din that sometimes shout like that of a captured
city was raised, and fearing loss while he hesitated, the consul should
make some attack and advance his standards, led his party over to the citadel,
from which the most alarming noise proceeded. Fabius, concluding that the
guard was withdrawn, both from the time which had elapsed and from the
silence which prevailed, for not a voice met the ear from a quarter where
a little while ago the noise and bustle of men resounded, rousing and calling
each other to arms, ordered the ladders to be carried to that part of the
wall where the person who had contrived the plot for betraying the city,
had informed him that the Bruttian cohort kept guard. The wall was first
captured in that quarter, the Bruttians aiding and receiving the Romans;
and here they got over into the city: after which the nearest gate was
broken open in order that the troops might enter in a large body. Then
raising a shout, they proceeded to the forum, where they arrived much about
daybreak, without meeting a single armed man; and drew upon themselves
the attention of all the troops in every quarter, which were fighting at
the citadel and at the harbor.
16. A battle was fought in the entrance of the forum, with greater impetuosity than perseverance. The Tarentines were not equal to the Romans in spirit, in their arms, in tactics, in activity or strength of body. Accordingly, having just discharged their javelins, they turned their backs almost before they had joined battle, and escaped in different directions through the streets of the city, with which they were acquainted, to their own houses and those of their friends. Two of their leaders, Nico and Democrates, fell while fighting bravely. Philomenus, who was the author of the plot for betraying the city to Hannibal, rode away from the battle at full speed. Shortly after, his horse, which was loose and straying through the city, was recognized, but his body could not be found any where. It was generally believed that he had pitched headlong from his horse into an open well. Carthalo, the praefect of the Carthaginian garrison, while coming to the consul unarmed, to put him in mind of a connection of hospitality which subsisted between their fathers, was put to death by a soldier who met him. The rest were put to the sword on all hands, armed and unarmed indiscriminately, Carthaginians and Tarentines without distinction. Many of the Bruttians also were slain either by mistake or on account of an old grudge entertained against them, or else with a view to the report that the city was betrayed; in order that Tarentum might rather appear to have been captured by force of arms. The troops then ran off in all directions from the slaughter, to plunder the city. Thirty thousand slaves are said to have been captured; an immense quantity of silver, wrought and coined; eighty-three thousand pounds of gold; of statues and pictures so many that they almost equalled the decorations of Syracuse. But Fabius, with more magnanimity than Marcellus, abstained from booty of that kind. When his secretary asked him what he wished to be done with the statues of their gods, which are of immense size and represented as fighting, each having his peculiar habit, he gave orders that their angry gods should be left in the possession of the Tarentines. After this, the wall which separated the city from the citadel was razed and demolished. While things were going on thus at Tarentum, Hannibal, to whom the troops engaged in the siege of Caulonia had surrendered themselves, hearing of the siege of Tarentum, marched with the greatest expedition both night and day; but hearing that the city was taken, as he was hastening to bring assistance to it, he exclaimed, "the Romans too have their Hannibal. We have lost Tarentum by the same arts by which we took it." However, that he might not appear to have turned his army in the manner of a fugitive, he encamped where he had halted, about five miles from the city. After staying there a few days, he retired to Metapontum, from which place he sent two Metapontines with letters from the principal men in the state to Fabius at Tarentum, to the effect, that they would accept of his promise that their past conduct should be unpunished, on condition of their betraying Metapontum together with the Carthaginian garrison into his hands. Fabius, who supposed that the communication they brought was genuine, appointed a day on which he would go to Metapontum, and gave the letters to the nobles, which were put into the hands of Hannibal. He, forsooth, delighted at the success of his stratagem, which showed that not even Fabius was proof against his cunning, planted an ambuscade not far from Metapontum. But when Fabius was taking the auspices, before he took his departure from Tarentum, the birds more than once refused approval. Also, on consulting the gods after sacrificing a victim, the aruspex forewarned him to be on his guard against hostile treachery and ambuscade. After the day fixed for his arrival had passed without his coming, the Metapontines were sent again to encourage him, delaying, but they were instantly seized, and, from apprehension of a severer mode of examination, disclosed the plot.
17. In the beginning of the summer during which these events occurred,
after Publius Scipio had employed the whole of the winter in Spain in
regaining the affections of the barbarians, partly by presents, and
partly by sending home their hostages and prisoners, Edesco, a man
distinguished among the Spanish commanders, came to him. His wife and
children were in the hands of the Romans; but besides this motive,
he was influenced by that apparently fortuitous turn in the state of
feeling which had converted the whole of Spain from the Carthaginian
to the Roman cause. The same motive induced Indibilis and Mandonius,
who were undoubtedly the principal men in all Spain, to desert
Hasdrubal and withdraw with the whole body of their countrymen to the
eminences which overhung his camp, from which they had a safe retreat
along a chain of hills to the Romans. Hasdrubal, perceiving that the
strength of the enemy was increasing by such large accessions, while
his own was diminishing, and that events would continue to flow in the
same course they had taken, unless by a bold effort he effected some
alteration, resolved to come to an engagement as soon as possible.
Scipio was still more eager for a battle, as well from hope which
the success attending his operations had increased, as because he
preferred, before the junction of the enemy's forces, to fight with
one general and one army, rather than with their united troops.
However, in case he should be obliged to fight with more armies than
one at the same time, he had with some ingenuity augmented his forces;
for seeing that there was no necessity for ships, as the whole coast
of Spain was clear of Carthaginian fleets, he hauled his ships on
shore at Tarraco and added his mariners to his land forces. He
had plenty of arms for them, both those which had been captured at
Carthage, and those which he had caused to be made after its capture,
so large a number of workmen having been employed. With these forces,
setting out from Tarraco at the commencement of the spring, for
Laelius had now returned from Rome, without whom he wished nothing
of very great importance to be attempted, Scipio marched against the
enemy. Indibilis and Mandonius, with their forces, met him while on
his march; passing through every place Without molestation, his
allies receiving him courteously, and escorting him as he passed the
boundaries of each district. Indibilis, who spoke for both, addressed
him by no means stupidly and imprudently like a barbarian, but with a
modest gravity, rather excusing the change as necessary, than glorying
that the present opportunity had been eagerly seized as the first
which had occurred. "For he well knew," he said, "that the name of
a deserter was an object of execration to former allies, and of
suspicion to new ones; nor did he blame the conduct of mankind in
this respect, provided, however, that the cause, and not the name,
occasioned the twofold hatred." He then recounted the services they
had rendered the Carthaginian generals, and on the other hand their
rapacity and insolence, together with the injuries of every kind
committed against themselves and their countrymen. "On this account,"
he said, "his person only up to that time had been with them, his
heart had long since been on that side where he believed that
right and justice were respected. That people sought for refuge,
as suppliants, even with the gods when they could not endure the
oppression and injustice of men. What he had to entreat of Scipio
was, that their passing over to him might neither be the occasion of
a charge of fraud nor a ground for respect, but that he would estimate
their services according to what sort of men he should find them to be
from experience from that day." The Roman replied, that "he would do
so in every particular; nor would he consider those men as deserters
who did not look upon an alliance as binding where no law, divine or
human, was unviolated." Their wives and children were then brought
before them and restored to them; on which occasion they wept for joy.
On that day they were conducted to a lodging; on the following they
were received as allies, by a treaty, after which they were sent to
bring up their forces. From that time they had their tents in the same
camp with the Romans, until under their guidance they had reached the
enemy.
18. The army of Hasdrubal, which was the nearest of the Carthaginian armies,
lay near the city Baecula. Before his camp he had outposts of cavalry.
On these the light-armed, those who fought before the standards and those
who composed the vanguard, as they came up from their march, and before
they chose the ground for their camp, commenced an attack in so contemptuous
a manner, that it was perfectly evident what degree of spirit each party
possessed. The cavalry were driven into their camp in disorderly flight,
and the Roman standards were advanced almost within their very gates. Their
minds on that day having only been excited to a contest, the Romans pitched
their camp. At night Hasdrubal withdrew his forces to an eminence, on the
summit of which extended a level plain. There was a river on the rear,
in front and on either side a kind of steep bank completely surrounded
its extremity. Beneath this and lower down was another plain of gentle
declivity, which was also surrounded by a similar ridge equally difficult
of ascent. Into this lower plain Hasdrubal, the next day, when he saw the
troops of the enemy drawn up before their camp, sent his Numidian cavalry
and light-armed Baleares. Scipio riding out to the companies and battalions,
pointed out to them, that "the enemy having abandoned, beforehand,
all hope of being able to withstand them on level ground, had resorted
to hills: where they stood in view, relying on the strength of their position,
and not on their valor and arms." But the walls of Carthage, which
the Roman soldiers had scaled, were still higher. That neither hills, nor
a citadel, nor even the sea itself, had formed an impediment to their arms.
That the heights which the enemy had occupied would only have the effect
of making it necessary for them to leap down crags and precipices in their
flight, but he would even cut off that kind of retreat. He accordingly
gave orders to two cohorts, that one of them should occupy the entrance
of the valley down which the river ran, and that the other should block
up the road which led from the city into the country, over the side of
the hill. He himself led the light troops, which the day before had driven
in the advanced guard of the enemy, against the light-armed troops which
were stationed on the lower ridge. At first they marched through rugged
ground, impeded by nothing except the road; afterwards, when they came
within reach of the darts, an immense quantity of weapons of every description
was showered upon them; while on their part, not only the soldiers, but
a multitude of servants mingled with the troops, threw stones furnished
by the place, which were spread about in every part, and for the most part
convenient as missiles. But though the ascent was difficult, and they were
almost overwhelmed with stones and darts, yet from their practice in approaching
walls and their inflexibility of mind, the foremost succeeded in getting
up. These, as soon as they got upon some level ground and could stand with
firm footing, compelled the enemy, who were light-armed troops adapted
for skirmishing, and could defend themselves at a distance, where an elusive
kind of fight is carried on by the discharge of missiles, but yet wanted
steadiness for a close action, to fly from their position; and, killing
a great many, drove them to the troops which stood above them on the higher
eminence. Upon this Scipio, having ordered the victorious troops to mount
up and attack the center of the enemy, divided the rest of his forces with
Laelius; whom he directed to go round the hill to the right till he could
find a way of easier ascent, while he himself, making a small circuit to
the left, charged the enemy in flank. In consequence of this their line
was first thrown into confusion, while they endeavoured to wheel round
and face about their ranks towards the shouts which resounded from every
quarter around them. During this confusion Laelius also came up, and while
the enemy were retreating, that they might not be exposed to wounds from
behind, their front line became disjoined, and a space was left for the
Roman center to mount up; who, from the disadvantage of the ground, never
could have done so had their ranks stood unbroken with the elephants stationed
in front. While the troops of the enemy were being slain on all sides,
Scipio, who with his left wing had charged the right of the enemy, was
chiefly employed in attacking their naked flank. And now there was not
even room to fly; for parties of the Roman troops had blocked up the roads
on both sides, right and left, and the gate of the camp was closed by the
flight of the general and principal officers; added to which was the fright
of the elephants, who, when in consternation, were as much feared by them
as the enemy were. There were, therefore, slain as many as eight thousand
men.
19. Hasdrubal, having seized upon the treasure before he engaged, now sent
the elephants in advance, and collecting as many of the flying troops as
he could, directed his course along the river Tagus to the Pyrenees. Scipio,
having got possession of the enemy's camp, and giving up all the booty
to the soldiers, except the persons of free condition, found, on counting
the prisoners, ten thousand foot and two thousand horse. Of these, all
who were Spaniards he sent home without ransom; the Africans he ordered
the quaestor to sell. After this, a multitude of Spaniards, consisting
of those who had surrendered to him before and those whom he had captured
the preceding day, crowding around, one and all saluted him as king; when
Scipio, after the herald had obtained silence, declared that "in his
estimation the most honorable title was that of general, which his soldiers
had conferred upon him. That the name of king, which was in other countries
revered, could not be endured at Rome. That they might tacitly consider
his spirit as kingly, if they thought that the highest excellence which
could be attributed to the human mind, but that they must abstain from
the use of the term." Even barbarians were sensible of the greatness
of mind which could from such an elevation despise a name, at the greatness
of which the rest of mankind were overawed. Presents were then distributed
to the petty princes and leading men of the Spaniards, and out of the great
quantity of horses which were captured, he desired Indibilis to select
those he liked best to the number of three hundred. While the quaestor
was selling the Africans, according to the command of the general, he found
among them a full-grown youth remarkably handsome; and hearing that he
was of royal blood, he sent him to Scipio. On being asked by Scipio "who
he was, of what country, and why at that age he was in the camp?"
he replied, "that he was a Numidian, that his countrymen called him
Massiva; that being left an orphan by his father, he was educated by his
maternal grandfather, Gala, the king of the Numidians. That he had passed
over into Spain with his uncle Masinissa, who had lately come with a body
of cavalry to assist the Carthaginians. That having been prohibited by
Masinissa on account of his youth, he had never before been in battle.
That the day on which the battle took place with the Romans, he had clandestinely
taken a horse and arms, and, without the knowledge of his uncle, gone out
into the field, where his horse falling forward, he was thrown headlong,
and taken prisoner by the Romans." Scipio, having ordered that the
Numidian should be taken care of, completed the business which remained
to be done on the tribunal, and returning to his pavilion, asked him, when
he had been called to him, whether he wished to return to Masinissa? Upon
his replying, with tears of joy, that he did indeed desire it, he presented
the youth with a gold ring, a vest with a broad purple border, a Spanish
cloak with a gold clasp, and a horse completely caparisoned, and then dismissed
him, ordering a party of horse to escort him as far as he chose.
20. A council was then held respecting the war; when some advised that
he should endeavor to overtake Hasdrubal forthwith. But thinking that hazardous,
lest Mago and the other Hasdrubal should unite their forces with his, he
sent a body of troops to occupy the pass of the Pyrenees, and employed
the remainder of the summer in receiving the states of Spain into his alliance.
A few days after the battle of Baecula, when Scipio on his return to Tarraco
had now cleared the pass of Castulo, the generals, Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo,
and Mago came from the farther Spain and joined Hasdrubal; a late assistance
after the defeat he had sustained, though their arrival was somewhat seasonable,
for counsel with respect to the further prosecution of the war. They then
consulted together as to what was the feeling of the Spaniards in the quarters
where their several provinces were situated, when Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo,
alone gave it as his opinion, that the remotest tract of Spain which borders
on the ocean and Gades, was, as yet, unacquainted with the Romans, and
might therefore be somewhat friendly to the Carthaginians. Between the
other Hasdrubal and Mago it was agreed, that "Scipio by his good offices
had gained the affections of all, both publicly and privately; and that
there would be no end of desertions till all the Spanish soldiers were
removed to the remotest parts of Spain, or were marched over into Gaul.
That, therefore, though the Carthaginian senate had not decreed it, Hasdrubal
must, nevertheless, march into Italy, the principal seat and object of
the war; and thus at the same time lead away all the Spanish soldiers out
of Spain far from the name of Scipio. That the army, which had been diminished
by desertions and defeats, should be recruited by Spanish soldiers. That
Mago, having delivered over his army to Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, should
himself pass over to the Baleares with a large sum of money to hire auxiliaries;
that Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, should retire with the army into the remotest
part of Lusitania, and avoid an encounter with the Romans. That a body
of three thousand horse should be made up for Masinissa, the flower of
the whole cavalry; and that he, shifting about from place to place throughout
hither Spain should succor their allies and commit depredations on the
towns and lands of their enemies." Having adopted these resolutions,
the generals departed to put in execution what they had resolved on. Such
were the transactions in Spain of this year. At Rome the reputation of
Scipio increased daily. The capture of Tarentum, though effected by artifice
more than valor, was considered honorable to Fabius. The fame of Fulvius
was on the wane. Marcellus was even under an ill report, not only because
he had failed in his first battle, but further, because while Hannibal
was going wherever he pleased throughout Italy, he had led his troops to
Venusia in the midst of summer to lodge in houses. Caius Publicius Bibulus,
a tribune of the people, was hostile to him. This man, ever since the time
of his first battle which had failed, had in constant harangues made Claudius
obnoxious and odious to the people; and now his object was to deprive him
of his command. The connections of Marcellus, however, then obtained leave
that Marcellus, leaving a lieutenant-general at Venusia, should return
to Rome to clear himself of the charges which his enemies were urging,
and that the question of depriving him of his command should not be agitated
during his absence. It happened that nearly at the same time, Marcellus,
and Quintius Fulvius the consul, came to Rome, the former to exonerate
himself from ignominy, the latter on account of the elections.
21. The question touching Marcellus's command was debated in the Flaminian
circus, in the presence of an immense concourse of plebeians and persons
of every rank. The plebeian tribune accused, not only Marcellus, but the
nobility generally. "It was owing," he said, "to their dishonesty
and dilatory conduct, that Hannibal occupied Italy, as though it were his
province, for now ten years; that he had passed more of his life there
than at Carthage. That the Roman people were enjoying the fruits of the
prolonged command of Marcellus; that his army, after having been twice
defeated, was now spending the summer at Venusia lodged in houses."
Marcellus so completely destroyed the effect of this harangue of the tribune,
by the recital of the services he had rendered, that not only the bill
for depriving him of his command was thrown out, but the following day
he was created consul by the votes of all the centuries with wonderful
unanimity. Titus Quinctius Crispinus, who was then praetor, was joined
with him as his colleague. The next day Publius Licinius Crassus Dives,
then chief pontiff, Publius Licinius Varus, Sextus Julius Caesar, and Quintus
Claudius Flamen were created praetors. At the very time of the election,
the public were thrown into a state of anxiety relative to the defection
of Etruria. Caius Calpurnius, who held that province as propraetor, had
written word that the Arretians had originated such a scheme. Accordingly
Marcellus, consul elect, was immediately sent thither to look into the
affair, and if it should appear to him of sufficient consequence, to send
for his army and transfer the war from Apulia to Etruria. The Tuscans,
checked by the alarm thus occasioned, desisted. To the ambassadors of Tarentum,
who solicited a treaty of peace securing to them their liberty and the
enjoyment of their own laws, the senate answered, that they might return
when the consul Fabius came to Rome. The Roman and plebeian games were
this year repeated each for one day. The curule aediles were, Lucius Cornelius
Caudinus and Servius Sulpicius Galba; the plebeian aediles, Caius Servilius
and Quintus Caecilius Metellus. It was asserted that Servilius was not
qualified to be plebeian tribune or aedile, because it was satisfactorily
established that his father, who, for ten years, was supposed to have been
killed by the Boii in the neighborhood of Mutina, when acting as triumvir
for the distribution of lands, was alive and in the hands of the enemy.
22. In the eleventh year of the Punic war, Marcus Marcellus, for the fifth time, reckoning in the consulate in which he did not act in consequence of an informality in his creation, and Titus Quinctius Crispinus entered upon the office of consuls. To both the consuls the province of Italy was decreed, with both the consular armies of the former year; (the third was then at Venusia, being that which Marcus Marcellus had commanded.) That out of the three armies the consuls might, choose whichever two they liked, and that the third should be delivered to him to whose lot the province of Tarentum and the territory of Sallentum fell. The other provinces were thus distributed among the praetors: Publius Licinius Varus had the city jurisdiction, Publius Licinius Crassus, chief pontiff, the foreign, and wherever the senate though proper. Sextus Julius Caesar had Sicily, and Quintus Claudius Flamen, Tarentum. Quintus Fulvius Flaccus was to continue in command for a year, and hold the province of Capua, which had been held by Titus Quinctius, with one legion. Caius Hostilius Tubulus was also continued in command, with orders to go into Etruria, in the capacity of propraetor, and succeed Caius Calpurnius in the command of the two legions there. Lucius Veturius Philo was also continued in command, to hold in the capacity of propraetor the same province of Gaul with the same two legions with which he had held it as praetor. The senate decreed the same with respect to Caius Aurunculeius, who, as praetor, had held the province of Sardinia with two legions, which it did in the case of Lucius Veturius, and the question of the continuation of his command was proposed to the people. He had in addition, for the protection of the province, fifty ships which Publius Scipio had sent from Spain. To Publius Scipio and Marcus Silanus, their present province of Spain and their present armies were assigned. Of the eighty ships which he had with him, some taken from Italy and others captured at Carthage, Scipio was ordered to send fifty to Sardinia, in consequence of a report that great naval preparations were making at Carthage that year; and that the intention of the Carthaginians was to blockade the whole coasts of Italy, Sicily, and Sardinia with two hundred ships. In Sicily also the following distribution was made: to Sextus Caesar the troops of Cannae were assigned; Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who was also continued in command, was to have the fleet of seventy ships which was at Sicily, adding to it the thirty ships which the preceding year were stationed at Tarentum. With this fleet of a hundred ships he was ordered to pass over into Africa, if he thought proper, and collect booty. Publius Sulpicius was also continued in command for a year, to hold the province of Macedonia and Greece, with the same fleet. No alteration was made with regard to the two legions which were at Rome. Permission was given to the consuls to enlist as many troops as were necessary to complete the numbers. This year the Roman empire was defended by twenty-one legions. Publius Licinius Varus, the city praetor, was also commissioned to repair the thirty old men of war which lay at Ostia, and to man twenty new ones with full complements, in order that he might defend the sea-coast in the neighborhood hood of Rome with a fleet of fifty ships. Caius Calpurnius was ordered not to move his army from Arretium till his successor had arrived. Both he and Tubulus were ordered to be particularly careful, lest any new plots should be formed in that quarter.
23. The praetors set out for their provinces. The consul were detained by religious affairs; for receiving intelligence of several prodigies, they could not easily obtain a favorable appearance from the victims. It was reported from Campania, that two temples, those of Fortune and Mars, and several sepulchers, had been struck by lightning. From Cumae, so does superstition connect the deities with the most trifling circumstances, that mice had gnawed some gold in the temple of Jupiter. That an immense swarm of bees had settled in the forum at Casinum. That at Ostia a wall and gate had been struck by lightning. At Caere, that a vulture had flown into the temple of Jupiter. That blood had flowed from a lake at Volsinii. On account of these prodigies, a supplication was performed for one day. For several days, victims of the larger kind were sacrificed without any favorable appearance, and for a long time the good will of the gods could not be obtained. The fatal event indicated by these portents pointed to the persons of the consuls, the state being unaffected. The Apollinarian games were first celebrated by Publius Cornelius Sulla, the city praetor, in the consulate of Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius; from that time all the city praetors in succession had performed them; but they vowed them for one year only, and fixed no day for their performance. This year a grievous pestilence attacked the city and the country; it showed itself, however, in protracted rather than fatal diseases. On account of this pestilence supplication was performed in every street throughout the city; and Publius Licinius Varus, the city praetor, was ordered to propose to the people a law to the effect, that a vow should be made to perform these games on a stated day for ever. He himself was the first who vowed them in this manner, and he celebrated them on the third day of the nones of July, a day which was henceforth kept sacred.
24. The reports respecting the people of Arretium became daily more
serious, and the anxiety of the fathers increased. A letter was
therefore written to Caius Hostilius, directing him not to delay
taking hostages from that people; and Caius Terentius Varro was sent,
with a command, to receive from him the hostages and convey them to
Rome. On his arrival, Hostilius immediately ordered one legion, which
was encamped before the city, to march into it; and having posted
guards in suitable places, he summoned the senate into the forum and
demanded hostages of them. On the senate's requesting a delay of two
days to consider the matter, he declared that they must themselves
give them forthwith, or he would the next day take all the children of
the senators. After this the military tribunes, the praefects of the
allies, and the centurions, were ordered to keep watch at the gates,
that no one might go out by night. This duty was not performed with
sufficient care and attention, for seven of the principal senators,
with their children, escaped before night, and before the guards were
posted at the gates. The next day, as soon as it was light, the senate
began to be summoned into the forum, when they were missed and their
goods were sold. From the rest of the senators one hundred and twenty
hostages, consisting of their own children, were taken and delivered
over to Caius Terentius to be conveyed to Rome. Before the senate he
made every thing more suspected than before. Considering, therefore,
that there was imminent danger of a commotion in Tuscany, they ordered
Caius Terentius himself to lead one of the city legions to Arretium,
and to employ it for the protection of the city. It was also resolved,
that Caius Hostilius, with the other army, should traverse the whole
province, and use precautions, that no opportunity might be afforded
to those who were desirous of altering the state of things. On his
arrival at Arretium with the legion, Terentius asked the magistrates
for the keys of the gates, when they declared they could not be found;
but he, believing that they had been put out of the way with some bad
intention rather than lost through negligence, took upon himself to
have fresh locks put upon all the gates, and used diligent care to
keep every thing in his own power. He earnestly cautioned Hostilius
to rest his hope in this; that the Tuscans would remain quiet, if he
should take care that not a step could be taken.
25. The case of the Tarentines was then warmly debated in the senate, Fabius
being present, and himself defending those whom he had subdued by force
of arms, while others entertained an angry feeling towards them; the greater
part comparing them with the Campanians in guilt and punishment. A decree
of the senate was passed conformably to the opinion of Manius Acilius,
that the town should be guarded by a garrison, and that all the Tarentines
should be kept within their walls; and further, that the question touching
their conduct should be hereafter laid before the senate afresh when the
state of Italy should be more tranquil. The case of Marcus Livius, praefect
of the citadel of Tarentum, was also debated with no less warmth; some
proposing a vote of censure against the praefect on the ground that Tarentum
was betrayed to the enemy through his negligence, others proposing rewards
for having defended the citadel for five years, and because Tarentum had
been recovered chiefly by his single efforts; while some, adopting an intermediate
course, declared that it appertained to the censors, and not to the senate,
to take cognizance of his case; and of this latter opinion was Fabius,
who added, however, "that he admitted that the recovery of Tarentum
was owing to the efforts of Livius, as his friends openly boasted in the
senate, but that there would have been no necessity for its recovery, had
it not been lost." One of the consuls, Titus Quinctius Crispinus,
set out for Lucania, with some troops to make up the numbers, to take the
command of the army which had served under Quintus Fulvius Flaccus. Marcellus
was detained by a succession of religious scruples, which presented themselves
to his mind. One of which was, that when in the Gallic war at Clastidium
he had vowed a temple to Honor and Valor, its dedication was impeded by
the pontiffs, who said, that one shrine could not with propriety be dedicated
to two deities; because if it should be struck with lightning or any kind
of portent should happen in it, the expiation would be attended with difficulty
as it could not be ascertained to which deity sacrifice ought to be made;
nor could one victim be lawfully offered to two deities, unless in particular
cases. Accordingly another temple to Virtue was erected with all speed.
Nevertheless, these temples were not dedicated by Marcellus himself. Then
at length he set out, with the troops raised to fill up the numbers, to
the army he had left the preceding year at Venusia. Crispinus, who endeavoured
to reduce Locri in Bruttium by a siege, because he considered that the
affair of Tarentum had added greatly to the fame of Fabius, had sent for
every kind of engine and machine from Sicily; he also sent for ships from
the same place to attack that part of the city which lay towards the sea.
But this siege was raised by Hannibal's bringing his forces to Lacinium,
and in consequence of a report, that his colleague, with whom he wished
to effect a junction, had now led his army from Venusia. He therefore returned
from Bruttium into Apulia, and the consuls took up a position in two separate
camps, distant from each other less than three miles, between Venusia and
Bantia. Hannibal, after diverting the war from Locri, returned also into
the same quarter. Here the consuls, who were both of sanguine temperament,
almost daily went out and drew up their troops for action, confidently
hoping, that if the enemy would hazard an engagement with two consular
armies united, they might put an end to the war.
26. As Hannibal, who gained one and lost the other of the two battles which he fought the preceding year with Marcellus, would have equal grounds for hope and fear, should he encounter the same general again; so was he far from thinking himself a match for the two consuls together. Directing his attention, therefore, wholly to his own peculiar arts, he looked out for an opportunity for planting an ambuscade. Slight battles, however, were fought between the two camps with varying success. But the consuls, thinking it probable that the summer would be spun out in engagements of this kind, and being of opinion that the siege of Locri might be going on notwithstanding, wrote to Lucius Cincius to pass over to Locri with his fleet from Sicily. And that the walls might be besieged by land also, they ordered one half of the army, which formed the garrison of Tarentum, to be marched thither. Hannibal having found from certain Thurians that these things would be done, sent a body of troops to lie in ambush on the road leading from Tarentum. There, under the hill of Petelia, three thousand cavalry and two thousand foot were placed in concealment. The Romans, who proceeded without exploring their way, having fallen into the ambuscade, as many as two thousand soldiers were slain, and about twelve hundred made prisoners. The others, who were scattered in flight through the fields and forests, returned to Tarentum. There was a rising ground covered with wood situated between the Punic and Roman camps, which was occupied at first by neither party, because the Romans were unacquainted with its nature on that side which faced the enemy's camp, while Hannibal had supposed it better adapted for an ambuscade than a camp. Accordingly, he had sent thither, by night, several troops of Numidians, concealing them in the midst of the wood. Not one of them stirred from his position by day, lest their arms or themselves should be observed from a distance. There was a general murmur in the Roman camp, that this eminence ought to be occupied and secured by a fort, lest if it should be seized by Hannibal they should have the enemy, as it were, immediately over their heads. Marcellus was moved by this consideration, and observed to his colleague, "Why not go ourselves with a few horsemen and reconnoiter? The matter being examined with our own eyes, will make our measures more certain." Crispinus consenting, they set out with two hundred and twenty horsemen, of which forty were Fregellans, the rest Tuscans. Marcus Marcellus, the consul's son, and Aulus Manlius, military tribunes, together with two prefects of the allies, Lucius Arennius and Manius Aulius, accompanied them. Some historians have recorded, that Marcellus had offered sacrifices on that day, and that in the first victim slain, the liver was found without its head; in the second, that all the usual parts were present, and that there was also an excrescence in the head. That the aruspex was not, indeed, pleased that the entrails should first have appeared mutilated and foul, and then too exuberant.
27. But the consul Marcellus was influenced by so ardent a desire of engaging
with Hannibal, that he never thought their camps close enough. At that
time also, as he quitted the rampart, he gave orders that the troops should
be ready when occasion required, in order that if the hill, which they
were going to examine, were thought convenient, they might collect their
baggage and follow them. Before the camp there was a small plain; the road
thence to the hill was open and exposed to view on all sides. A watchman
who was stationed, not under the expectation of so important an event,
but in order that they might be able to intercept any stragglers who had
gone too far from the camp in search of wood or forage, gave a signal to
the Numidians to rise simultaneously one and all from their concealment.
Those who were to rise from the very summit of the hill, and meet the enemy,
did not show themselves until those whose business it was to intercept
their passage in the rear, had gone round. Then they all sprang up from
every side, and, raising a shout, commenced an attack. Although the consuls
were in such a position in the valley that they could neither make good
their way up the hill, which was occupied by the enemy, nor retreat as
they were intercepted in the rear, yet the contest might have been continued
longer had not a retreat, commenced by the Tuscans, dismayed the rest of
the troops. The Fregellans, however, did not give over fighting, though
deserted by the Tuscans, while the consuls, uninjured, kept up the battle
by encouraging their men and fighting themselves. But when they saw both
the consuls wounded, and Marcellus transfixed with a lance and falling
lifeless from his horse, then they too, and but a very few survived, betook
themselves to flight, together with Crispinus the consul, who had received
two javelin wounds, and young Marcellus, who was himself also wounded.
Aulus Manlius, a military tribune, was slain, and of the two praefects
of allies, Manius Aulius was slain, Lucius Arennius made prisoner. Five
of the consul's lictors fell into the enemy's hands alive, the rest were
either slain or fled with the consul. Forty-three horsemen fell in the
battle or in the flight, and eighteen were taken alive. An alarm had been
excited in the camp, and the troops were hastening to go and succor the
consuls, when they saw one of the consuls and the son of the other wounded,
and the scanty remains of this unfortunate expedition returning to the
camp. The death of Marcellus was an event to be deplored, as well from
other circumstances which attended it, as because that in a manner unbecoming
his years, for he was then more than sixty, and inconsistently with the
prudence of a veteran general, he had so improvidently plunged into ruin
himself, his colleague, and almost the whole commonwealth. I should launch
out into too many digressions for a single event, were I to relate all
the various accounts which authors give respecting the death of Marcellus.
To pass over others, Lucius Caelius gives three narratives ranged under
different heads; one as it is handed down by tradition; a second, written
in the panegyric of his son, who was engaged in the affair; a third, which
he himself vouched for, being the result of his own investigation. The
accounts, however, though varying in other points, agree for the most part
in the fact, that he went out of the camp for the purpose of viewing the
ground; and all state that he was cut off by an ambuscade.
28. Hannibal, concluding that the enemy were greatly dismayed by one of
their consuls being slain and the other wounded, that he might not be wanting
on any opportunity presenting itself, immediately transferred his camp
to the eminence on which the battle had been fought. Here he found the
body of Marcellus, and interred it. Crispinus, disheartened by the death
of his colleague and his own wound, set out during the silence of the following
night, and encamped upon the nearest mountains he could reach, in a position
elevated and secured on all sides. Here the two generals exerted their
sagacity, the one in effecting, the other in guarding against, a deception.
Hannibal got possession of the ring of Marcellus, together with his body.
Crispinus, fearing lest any artifice should be practiced by the Carthaginian's
employing this signet as the means of deception, had sent round messengers
to the neighboring states, informing them, that "his colleague had
been slain, and that the enemy were in possession of his seal, and that
they must not give credit to any letters written in the name of Marcellus."
This message of the consul arrived at Salapia a little before a letter
was brought from Hannibal, written in the name of Marcellus, to the effect,
that "he should come to Salapia on the night which followed that day;
that the soldiers in the garrison should hold themselves in readiness,
in case he might want to employ them on any service." The Salapians
were aware of the fraud, and concluding that an opportunity for punishing
them was sought by Hannibal, from resentment, not only on account of their
defection, but also because they slew his horsemen, sent his messenger,
who was a deserter from the Romans, back again, in order that the soldiers
might do what was thought necessary, without his being privy to it, and
then placed the townsmen in parties to keep guard along the walls, and
in convenient parts of the city. The guards and watches they formed with
extraordinary care for that night, and on each side of the gate at which
they supposed the enemy would come, they opposed to them the choicest of
the troops in the garrison. About the fourth watch, Hannibal approached
the city. His vanguard was composed of Roman deserters, with Roman arms.
These, all of whom spoke the Latin language, when they reached the gate,
called up the guards, and ordered the gate to be opened, for the consul
had arrived. The guards, as if awakened at their call, began to be in a
hurry and bustle, and exert themselves in opening the gate, which was closed
by letting down the portcullis; some raised this with levers, others drew
it up with ropes to such a height that the men could come in without stooping.
The opening was scarcely wide enough, when the deserters eagerly rushed
through the gate, and after about six hundred had got in, the rope being
let go by which it was suspended, the portcullis fell with a loud noise.
Some of the Salapians fell upon the deserters, who were carrying their
arms carelessly suspended upon their shoulders, as is customary after a
march, as if among friends; others frightened away the enemy by discharging
stones, pikes, and javelins from the tower adjoining the gate and from
the walls. Thus Hannibal withdrew, having been caught by his own stratagem,
and proceeded to raise the siege of Locri, which Cincius was carrying on
with the greatest vigor, with works and engines of every kind, which were
brought from Sicily. Mago, who by that time almost despaired of retaining
and defending the town, derived his first gleam of hope on the death of
Marcellus being reported. This was followed by a message, that Hannibal
had dispatched his Numidian cavalry in advance, and was himself following
them with all possible speed with a body of infantry. As soon, therefore,
as he was informed, by a signal displayed from the watch-towers, that the
Numidians were drawing near, suddenly throwing open the gate he sallied
out boldly upon the enemy, and at first, more because he had done it unexpectedly
than from the equality of his strength, the contest was doubtful; but afterwards,
when the Numidians came up, the Romans were so dismayed that they fled
on all hands to the sea and their ships, leaving their works and the engines
with which they battered the walls. Thus the siege of Locri was raised
by the approach of Hannibal.
29. When Crispinus found that Hannibal had gone into Bruttium, he ordered
Marcus Marcellus, a military tribune, to march the army, which his colleague
had commanded, to Venusia. Having set out himself with his own legions
for Capua, though scarcely able to endure the motion of the litter, from
the severity of his wounds, he sent a letter to Rome stating the death
of his colleague, and in how great danger he himself was. He said, "it
was impossible for him to go to Rome to hold the election, both because
he did not think he could bear the fatigue of the journey, and because
he was anxious about Tarentum, lest Hannibal should direct his course thither
from Bruttium. That it was expedient that commissioners should be sent
to him, men of sound judgment, with whom he might communicate, when he
pleased, respecting the commonwealth." The reading of this letter
excited great grief for the death of one of the consuls, and apprehension
for the safety of the other. They therefore sent Quintus Fabius the younger
to Venusia to the army; and to the consul three commissioners, Sextus Julius
Caesar, Lucius Licinius Pollio, and Lucius Cincius Alimentus, though but
a few days before he had returned from Sicily. These were directed to convey
a message to the consul, to the effect, that if he could not himself go
to Rome to hold the election, he should nominate a dictator within the
Roman territory for that purpose. If the consul should have gone to Tarentum,
that it was the pleasure of the senate that Marcus Claudius, the praetor,
should march off his legions to that quarter in which he could protect
the greatest number of the cities of the allies. The same summer Marcus
Valerius crossed over from Sicily into Africa with a fleet of a hundred
ships, and making a descent near the city Clupea, devastated the country
to a wide extent, scarcely meeting with a single person in arms. Afterwards
the troops employed in making these depredations were hastily led back
to their ships, and a report had suddenly reached them that a Carthaginian
fleet was drawing near. It consisted of eighty-three ships. With these
the Romans fought successfully, not far from the city Clupea, and after
taking eighteen and putting the rest to flight, returned to Lilybaeum with
a great deal of booty gained both by land and sea. The same summer also
Philip gave assistance to the suppliant Achaeans. They were harassed by
Machanidas, tyrant of the Lacedaemonians, with a war in their immediate
neighborhood; and the Aetolians, having passed over an army in ships through
the strait which runs between Naupactus and Patrae, called by the neighboring
people Rhion, had devastated their country. It was reported also, that
Attalus, king of Asia, would pass over into Europe, because the Aetolians,
in their last council, had offered to him the office of chief magistrate
of their nation.
30. Philip, when marching down into Greece, for these reasons, was met
at the city Lamia by the Aetolians, under the command of Pyrrhias, who
had been created praetor that year jointly with Attalus, who was absent.
They had with them also auxiliaries from Attalus, and about a thousand
men sent from the Roman fleet by Publius Sulpicius. Against this general
and these forces, Philip fought twice successfully, and slew full a thousand
of his enemies in each battle. Whence, as the Aetolians were compelled
by fear to keep themselves under the walls of Lamia, Philip led back his
army to Phalara. This place is situated in the Malian bay, and was formerly
thickly inhabited on account of its excellent harbor, the safe anchorage
in its neighborhood, and other conveniences of sea and land. Hither came
ambassadors from Ptolemy, king of Egypt, the Rhodians, Athenians, and Chians,
to put a stop to hostilities between the Aetolians and Philip. The Aetolians
also called in one of their neighbors as a mediator, Amynander, king of
the Athamanians. But all these were less concerned for the Aetolians, whose
arrogance of disposition exceeded that of any other nation of Greece, than
lest Philip and his empire, which was likely to prove injurious to the
cause of liberty, should be intermixed with the affairs of Greece. The
deliberations concerning a peace were put off, to a council of the Achaeans,
for which a place and certain day were fixed upon; for the mean time a
truce of thirty days was obtained. The king, setting out thence, went through
Thessaly and Boeotia to Chalcis in Euboea, to prevent Attalus, who he heard
was about to come to Euboea with a fleet, from entering the harbors and
approaching the coasts. Leaving a force to oppose Attalus, in case he should
cross over in the mean time, he set out thence with a small body of cavalry
and light-armed troops, and came to Argos. Here the superintendence of
the Heraean and Nemaean games having been conferred upon him by the suffrages
of the people, because the kings of the Macedonians trace their origin
from that state, after completing the Heraean games, he set out directly
after the celebration for Aegium, to the council of allies, fixed some
time before. Here measures were proposed for putting an end to the Aetolian
war, in order that neither the Romans nor Attalus might have a pretext
for entering Greece; but they were all upset by the Aetolians, before the
period of the truce had scarcely expired, after they heard that Attalus
had arrived at Aegina, and that a Roman fleet was stationed at Naupactus.
For when called into the council of the Achaeans, where the same embassies
were present which had negotiated for peace at Phalara, they at first complained
of some trifling acts committed during the period of the truce, contrary
to the faith of the convention; but at last they asserted, that it was
impossible the war could be terminated unless the Achaeans gave back Pylus
to the Messenians, unless Atintania was restored to the Romans, and Ardyaea
to Scerdilaedus and Pleuratus. But Philip, conceiving it an indignity that
the vanquished should presumptuously dictate terms to him the victor, said,
"that he did not before either listen to proposals for peace, or agree
to a truce, from any hope he entertained that the Aetolians would remain
quiet, but in order that he might have all the allies as witnesses that
he was desirous of peace, and that they were the occasion of this war."
Thus, without effecting a peace, he dismissed the council; and leaving
four thousand troops for the protection of the Achaeans, and receiving
five men of war, with which, if he could have joined them to the fleet
of the Carthaginians lately sent to him, and the ships which were coming
from Bithynia, from king Prusias, he had resolved to challenge the Romans,
who had long been masters of the sea in that quarter, to a naval battle,
the king himself went back from the congress to Argos; for now the time
for celebrating the Nemaean games was approaching, which he wished to be
celebrated in his presence.
31. While the king was occupied with the exhibition of the games, and was indulging himself during the days devoted to festivity with more freedom than in time of war, Publius Sulpicius, setting out from Naupactus, brought his fleet to the shore, between Sicyon and Corinth, and devastated without restraint a country of the most renowned fertility. Intelligence of this proceeding called Philip away from the games. He set out hastily with his cavalry, ordering his infantry to follow him closely; and attacking the Romans as they were scattered through the fields and loaded with booty, like men who feared nothing of the kind, drove them to their ships. The Roman fleet returned to Naupactus by no means pleased with their booty. The fame of a victory gained by Philip over the Romans, of whatever magnitude, increased the celebrity of the remaining part of the games. The festival was celebrated with extraordinary mirth, the more so as the king, in order to please the people, took the diadem off his head, and laid aside his purple robe with the other royal apparel, and placed himself, with regard to appearance, on an equality with the rest, than which nothing is more gratifying to free states. By this conduct he would have afforded the strongest hopes of the enjoyment of liberty, had he not debased and marred all by his intolerable lust; for he ranged night and day through the houses of married people with one or two companions, and in proportion as he was less conspicuous by lowering his dignity to a private level, the less restraint he felt; thus converting that empty show of liberty, which he had made to others, into a cover for the gratification of his own unbounded desires. For neither did he obtain his object in all cases by money or seductive arts, but he also employed violence in the accomplishment of his flagitious purposes; and it was dangerous both to husbands and parents to have presented any impediment to the gratification of royal lust, by an unseasonable strictness. From one man, Aratus, of the highest rank among the Achaeans, his wife, named Polycratia, was taken away and conveyed into Macedonia under the hope of a matrimonial connection with royalty. After passing the time appointed for the celebration of the Nemaean games, and a few days more, in the commission of these profligate acts, he set out for Dymae to expel the garrison of the Aetolians, which had been invited by the Eleans, and received into the town. Cycliadas, who had the chief direction of affairs, met the king at Dymae, together with the Achaeans, who were inflamed with hatred against the Eleans, because they had disunited themselves from the rest of the Achaeans, and were incensed against the Aetolians, because they considered that they had stirred up a Roman war against them. Setting out from Dymae, and uniting their forces, they passed the river Larissus, which separates the Elean from the Dymaean territory.
32. The first day on which they entered upon the enemy's confines, they
employed in plundering. The following day they approached the city in battle-array,
having sent their cavalry in advance, in order that, by riding up to the
gates, they might provoke the Aetolians to make a sally, a measure to which
they were naturally inclined. They were not aware that Sulpicius had passed
over from Naupactus to Cyllene with fifteen ships, and landing four thousand
armed men, had entered Elis during the dead of night, that his troops might
not be seen. Accordingly, when they recognized the Roman standards and
arms among the Aetolians, so unexpected an event occasioned the greatest
terror; and at first the king had wished to withdraw his troops; but afterwards,
an engagement having taken place between the Aetolians and Trallians, a
tribe of Illyrians, when he saw his men hard pressed, the king himself
with his cavalry charged a Roman cohort. Here his horse being pierced with
a javelin threw the king, who fell over his head; when a conflict ensued,
which was desperate on both sides; the Romans making a furious attack upon
the king, and the royal party protecting him. His own conduct was highly
meritorious, when though on foot he was obliged to fight among horsemen.
Afterwards, when the contest was unequal, many were falling and being wounded
around him, he was snatched away by his soldiers, and, being placed upon
another horse, fled from the field. On that day he pitched his camp five
miles from the city of the Eleans, and the next day led out all his forces
to a fort called Pyrgus, whither he had heard that a multitude of rustics
had resorted through fear of being plundered. This unorganized and unarmed
multitude he took immediately on his approach, from the first effects of
alarm; and by this capture compensated for the disgrace sustained at Elis.
While engaged in distributing the spoil and captives, and there were four
thousand men and as many as twenty thousand head of cattle of every kind,
intelligence reached him from Macedonia that one Eropus had gained possession
of Lychnidus by bribing the praefect of the citadel and garrison; that
he held also certain towns of the Dassaretians, and that he was endeavoring
to incite the Dardanians to arms. Desisting from the Achaean war, therefore,
but still leaving two thousand five hundred armed troops of every description
under the generals Menippus and Polyphantas for the protection of his allies,
he set out from Dymae, and passing through Achaea, Boeotia, and Euboea,
arrived on the tenth day at Demetrias in Thessaly.
33. Here he was met by other messengers with intelligence of still greater commotions; that the Dardanians, having poured into Macedonia, were in possession of Orestis, and had descended into the Argestaean plain; and that there was a general report among the barbarians that Philip was slain. In that expedition in which he fought with the plundering party near Sicyon, being carried by the fury of his horse against a tree, he broke off the extremity of one of the horns of his helmet against a projecting branch; which being found by a certain Aetolian and carried into Aetolia to Scerdilaedus, who knew it to be the ornament of his helmet, spread the report that the king was killed. After the king had departed from Achaea, Sulpicius, going to Aegina with his fleet, formed a junction with Attalus. The Achaeans fought successfully with the Aetolians and Eleans not far from Messene. King Attalus and Publius Sulpicius wintered at Aegina. In the close of this year Titus Quinctius Crispinus, the consul, after having nominated Titus Manlius Torquatus dictator for the purpose of holding the election and celebrating the games, died of his wound. Some say that he died at Tarentum, others in Campania. The death of the two consuls, who were slain without having fought any memorable battle, a coincidence which had never occurred in any former war, had left the commonwealth in a manner orphan. The dictator, Manlius, appointed as his master of the horse Caius Servilius, then curule aedile. On the first day of its meeting the senate ordered the dictator to celebrate the great games which Marcus Aemilius, the city praetor, had celebrated in the consulship of Caius Flaminius and Cneius Servilius, and had vowed to be repeated after five years. The dictator then both performed the games and vowed them for the following lustrum. But as the two consular armies without commanders were so near the enemy, disregarding every thing else, one especial care engrossed the fathers and the people, that of creating the consuls as soon as possible; and that they might create those in preference whose valor was least in danger from Carthaginian treachery; since, through the whole period of the war, the precipitate and hot tempers of their generals had been detrimental, and this very year the consuls had fallen into a snare for which they were not prepared, in consequence of their excessive eagerness to engage the enemy, but the immortal gods, in pity to the Roman name, had spared the unoffending armies, and doomed the consuls to expiate their temerity with their own lives.
34. On the fathers' looking round to see whom they should appoint as consuls, Caius Claudius Nero appeared pre-eminently. They then looked out for a colleague for him, and although they considered him a man of the highest talents, they also were of opinion that he was of a more forward and vehement disposition than the circumstances of the war, or the enemy, Hannibal, required, they resolved that it would be right to qualify the impetuosity of his temper by uniting with him a cool and prudent colleague. The person fixed upon was Marcus Livius, who, many years ago, was, on the expiration of his consulship, condemned in a trial before the people; a disgrace which he took so much to heart, that he retired into the country, and for many years absented himself from the city, and avoided all public assemblies. Much about the eighth year after his condemnation, Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the consuls, had brought him back into the city; but he appeared in a squalid dress, his hair and beard allowed to grow, and exhibiting in his countenance and attire the deep impression of the disgrace he had sustained. Lucius Veturius and Publius Licinius, the censors, compelled him to have his beard and hair trimmed, to lay aside his squalid garb, to come into the senate, and discharge other public duties. But even then he either gave his assent by a single word, or signified his vote by walking to one side of the house, till the trial of Marcus Livius Macatus, a kinsman of his, whose character was at stake, obliged him to deliver his sentiments in the senate upon his legs. On being heard in the senate on this occasion, after so long an interval, he drew the eyes of all upon him, and gave occasion to conversations to the following effect: "That the people had injuriously disgraced a man who was undeserving of it and that it had been greatly detrimental to the state that, in so important a war, it had not had the benefit of the service and counsels of such a man. That neither Quintus Fabius nor Marcus Valerius Laevinus could be given to Caius Nero as colleagues, because it was not allowed for two patricians to be elected. That the same cause precluded Titus Manlius, besides that he had refused a consulship when offered to him, and would refuse it. That they would have two most distinguished consuls if they should add Marcus Livius as a colleague to Caius Claudius." Nor did the people despise a proposal, the mention of which originated with the fathers. The only person in the state who objected to the measure was the man to whom the honor was offered, who accused his countrymen of inconstancy, saying, "that, having withheld their pity from him when arrayed in a mourning garment and a criminal, they now forced upon him the white gown against his will; that honors and punishments were heaped upon the same person. If they esteemed him a good man, why had they thus passed a sentence of condemnation upon him as a wicked and guilty one? If they had proved him a guilty man, why should they thus trust him with a second consulate after having improperly committed to him the first?" While thus remonstrating and complaining, the fathers rebuked him, putting him in mind, that "Marcus Furius too, being recalled from exile, had reinstated his country when shaken from her very base. That we ought to soothe the anger of our country as we would that of parents, by patience and resignation." All exerting themselves to the utmost, they succeeded in uniting Marcus Livius in the consulate with Caius Claudius.
35. The third day afterwards the election of praetors was held. The
praetors created were, Lucius Porcius Licinus, Caius Mamilius, Aulus
Hostilius Cato, and Caius Hostilius Cato. The election completed, and
the games celebrated, the dictator and master of the horse abdicated
their offices. Caius Terentius Varro was sent as propraetor into
Etruria, in order that Caius Hostilius might quit that province and
go to Tarentum to that army which Titus Quinctius, the consul, had
commanded, and that Lucius Manlius might go as ambassador across the
sea, and observe what was going on there; and at the same time, as
the games at Olympia, which were attended by the greatest concourse
of persons of any solemnity in Greece, were about to take place that
summer, that if he could without danger from the enemy, he might go to
that assembly, in order that any Sicilians who might be there, having
been driven away by the war, or any Tarentine citizens banished by
Hannibal, might return to their homes, and be informed that the Roman
people would restore to them every thing which they had possessed
before the war. As a year of the most dangerous character seemed to
threaten them, and there were no consuls to direct the government, all
men fixed their attention on the consuls elect, wishing them to
draw lots for their provinces, as soon as possible, and determine
beforehand what province and what enemy each should have. The senate
also took measures, at the instance of Quintus Fabius Maximus, to
effect a reconciliation between them. For the enmity between them was
notorious; and in the case of Livius his misfortunes rendered it more
inveterate and acrimonious, as he considered that in that situation
he had been treated with contempt. He was, therefore, the more
inexorable, and said, "that there was no need of a reconciliation, for
that they would use greater diligence and activity in every thing they
did for fear lest they should give their colleague, who was an enemy,
an opportunity of advancing himself at their expense." However, the
authority of the senate prevailed; and, laying aside their private
differences, they conducted the affairs of the state in friendship
and unanimity. Their provinces were not districts bordering upon
each other, as in former years, but quite separate, in the remotest
confines of Italy. To one was decreed Bruttium and Lucania, to act
against Hannibal; to the other Gaul, to act against Hasdrubal, who, it
was reported, was now approaching the Alps; and that he to whose lot
Gaul fell should choose whichever he pleased of the two armies, one of
which was in Gaul, the other in Etruria, and receive the city legions
in addition; and that he to whose lot Bruttium fell, should, after
enlisting fresh legions for the city, take the army of whichever
of the consuls of the former year he pleased. That Quintus Fulvius,
proconsul, should take the army which was left by the consul, and that
his command should last for a year. To Caius Hostilius, to whom they
had given the province of Tarentum in exchange for Etruria, they gave
Capua instead of Tarentum, with one legion which Fulvius had commanded
the preceding year.
36. The anxiety respecting the approach of Hasdrubal to Italy increased
daily. At first, ambassadors from the Massilians had brought word that
he had passed over into Gaul and that the expectations of the Gauls were
raised by his coming, as he was reported to have brought a large quantity
of gold for the purpose of hiring auxiliaries. Afterwards, Sextus Antistius
and Marcus Raecius, who were sent from Rome, together with these persons,
as ambassadors, to look into the affair, had brought word back that they
had sent persons with Massilian guides, who, through the medium of Gallic
chieftains connected with them by hospitality, might bring back all ascertained
particulars; that they found that Hasdrubal, who had already collected
an immense army, would cross the Alps the ensuing spring; and that the
only cause which delayed him there was, that the passage of the Alps was
closed by winter. Publius Aelius Paetus was created and inaugurated in
the office of augur in the room of Marcus Marcellus and Cneius Cornelius
Dolabella was inaugurated king of the sacred rites in the room of Marcus
Marcius, who had died two years before. This same year, for the first time
since Hannibal came into Italy, the lustrum was closed by the censors Publius
Sempronius Tuditanus and Marcus Cornelius Cethegus. The citizens numbered
in the census were one hundred and thirty-seven thousand one hundred and
eight, a number considerably smaller than before the war. This year it
is recorded that the Comitium was covered, and that the Roman games were
repeated once by the curule aediles, Quintus Metellus and Caius Servilius;
and that the plebeian games were repeated twice by Quintus Mamilius and
Marcus Caecilius Metellus, plebeian aediles. The same persons also gave
three statues for the temple of Ceres, and there was a feast in honor of
Jupiter on occasion of the games. After this Caius Claudius Nero and Marcus
Livius a second time entered upon their consulate; and as they had already,
while consuls elect, drawn lots for their provinces, they ordered the praetors
to draw lots for theirs. Caius Hostilius had the city jurisdiction, to
which the foreign was added, in order that three praetors might go out
to the provinces. Aulus Hostilius had Sardinia, Caius Mamilius, Sicily,
Lucius Porcius, Gaul. The total amount of legions employed in the provinces
was twenty-three, which were so distributed that the consuls might have
two each; Spain, four; the three praetors in Sicily, Sardinia, and Gaul,
two each; Caius Terentius, two in Etruria; Quintus Fulvius, two in Bruttium;
Quintus Claudius two in the neighborhood of Tarentum and the territory
of Sallentum; Caius Hostilius Tubulus, one at Capua; and two were ordered
to be enlisted for the city. For the first four legions the people elected
tribunes, the consuls sent those for the rest.
37. Before the consuls set out, the nine days' sacred rite was performed,
as a shower of stones had fallen from the sky at Veii. After the mention
of one prodigy, others also were reported, as usual. At Minturnae, that
the temple of Jupiter and the grove of Marica, and at Atella also that
a wall and gate, had been struck by lightning. The people of Minturnae
added what was more alarming, that a stream of blood had flowed at their
gate. At Capua, a wolf, which had entered at the gate by night, had torn
a watchman. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the larger kind,
and a supplication for one day was made, according to a decree of the pontiffs.
The nine days' sacred rite was then performed again, because a shower of
stones had been seen to fall in the armilustrum. After the people's minds
had been freed from superstitious fears, they were again disturbed by intelligence
that an infant had been born at Frusino as large as a child of four years
old, and not so much an object of wonder from its size, as that it was
born without any certain mark of distinction whether it was male or female,
which was the case two years before at Sinuessa. Aruspices, called in from
Etruria, declared this to be indeed a foul and ill-omened prodigy, which
ought to be removed out of the Roman territory, and, being kept far from
coming in contact with the earth, to be plunged into the deep. They shut
it up alive in a chest, and carrying it away, threw it into the sea. The
pontiffs also decreed, that thrice nine virgins should go through the city
singing a hymn. While in the temple of Jupiter Stator they were learning
this hymn, which was composed by the poet Livius, the temple of Juno Regina,
on the Aventine, was struck by lightning; and the aruspices, on being consulted,
having replied that that prodigy appertained to the matrons, and that the
goddess must be appeased by a present, such of the matrons as dwelt within
the city and within the tenth milestone from it, were summoned to the Capitol
by an edict of the curule aediles; when they themselves chose twenty-five
out of their own body, to whom they paid a contribution out of their dowries,
from which a golden basin was made, as a present, and carried to the Aventine,
where a sacrifice was performed by the matrons in a pure and chaste manner.
Immediately a day was given out by the decemviri for another sacrifice
to the same goddess, which was performed in the following order: two white
heifers were led from the temple of Apollo into the city through the Carmental
gate; after these, two cypress images of Juno Regina were carried; after
these went seven and twenty virgins, arrayed in white vestments, and singing
in honor of Juno Regina a hymn, which to the uncultivated minds of that
time might appear to have merit, but if repeated now would seem inelegant
and uncouth. The train of virgins was followed by the decemvirs, crowned
with laurel, and in purple-bordered robes. From the gate they proceeded
by the Jugarian street into the forum: in the forum the procession stopped,
and the virgins, linked together by a cord passed through their hands,
moved on, beating time with their feet to the music of their voices. They
then proceeded by the Tuscan street and the Velabrum, through the cattle
market, up the Publician hill, and to the temple of Juno Regina; where
two victims were immolated by the decemviri, and the cypress images carried
into the temple.
38. After the deities were appeased in due form, the consuls made the
levy with greater diligence and strictness than any one remembered
it to have been made in former years; for the war was now doubly
formidable, in consequence of the advance of a new enemy into Italy,
while the number of the youth from which they could enlist soldiers
was diminished. They therefore resolved to compel the settlers upon
the sea-coast, who were said to possess an exemption from service
solemnly granted, to furnish soldiers; and on their refusing to do
so, appointed that they should severally lay before the senate, on
a certain day, the grounds on which they claimed exemption. On the
appointed day the following people came to the senate: the people
of Ostia, Alsia, Antium, Anxur, Minturnae, and Sinuessa, and, on
the upper sea, Sena. After each people had stated their grounds of
exemption, the exemption of none was allowed, as the enemy was in
Italy, except those of Antium and Ostia, and of these colonies the
young men were bound by oath that they would not lodge without the
walls of their colony, while the enemy was in Italy, more than thirty
days. Although it was the opinion of all that the consuls ought to
proceed to the war as soon as possible, (for Hasdrubal ought to be met
on his descent from the Alps, lest he might seduce the Cisalpine Gauls
and Etruria, which was anxiously looking forward to a revolution;
while it was necessary to occupy Hannibal with a war in his own
quarters, lest he should emerge from Bruttium, and advance to meet his
brother;) yet Livius delayed, not having sufficient confidence in
the armies destined for his provinces. He said his colleague had his
option to take which he pleased out of two excellent consular armies,
and a third which Quintus Claudius commanded at Tarentum. He also
made mention of recalling the volunteer slaves to their standards.
The senate gave the consuls unrestricted liberty of filling up their
numbers from what source they pleased, of selecting out of all the
armies such as they liked, and of exchanging and removing from one
province to another, as they thought conducive to the good of the
state. In all these affairs the consuls acted with the most perfect
harmony. The volunteer slaves were enlisted into the nineteenth and
twentieth legions. Some authors state that very efficient auxiliaries
were sent out of Spain also to Marcus Livius by Publius Scipio;
namely, eight thousand Spaniards and Gauls, two thousand legionary
soldiers, a thousand horse of Numidians and Spaniards together.
That Marcus Lucretius brought these forces in ships, and that Caius
Mamilius sent as many as four thousand bowmen and slingers out of
Sicily.
39. A letter which was brought out of Gaul from Lucius Porcius, the
praetor, increased the alarm at Rome. It stated that Hasdrubal had
quitted his winter quarters, and was now crossing the Alps; that eight
thousand Ligurians had been enlisted and armed, which would join him
when he had crossed over into Italy, unless some general were sent
into Liguria to engage them with a war. That he would himself advance
as far as he thought it safe with his small forces. This letter
obliged the consuls hastily to conclude the levy, and go earlier than
they had determined into their provinces, with the intention that each
should keep his enemy in his own province, and not allow them to form
a junction or concentrate their forces. This object was much aided by
an opinion possessed by Hannibal; for although he felt assured that
his brother would cross over into Italy that summer, yet when he
recollected what difficulties he had himself experienced through a
period of five months, first in crossing the Rhone, then the Alps,
contending against men, and the nature of the ground, he was far from
expecting that his transit would be so easy and expeditious, and this
was the cause of his moving more slowly from his winter quarters. But
all things were done by Hasdrubal with less delay and trouble than he
himself or any others expected. For the Arverni, and after them the
other Gallic and Alpine nations in succession, not only gave him a
friendly reception, but followed him to the war; and not only had
roads been formed during the passage of his brother in most of the
countries through which he marched, and which were before impassable,
but also as the Alps had been passable for a period of twelve years,
he marched through tribes of less ferocious dispositions. For
before that time, being never visited by foreigners, nor accustomed,
themselves, to see a stranger in their country, they were unsociable
to the whole human race. And at first, not knowing whither the
Carthaginian was going, they had imagined that their own rocks and
forts, and the plunder of their cattle and people, were his objects;
but afterwards, the report of the Punic war with which Italy was being
desolated for now ten years, had convinced them that the Alps were
only a passage, and that two very powerful nations, separated from
each other by a vast tract of sea and land, were contending for empire
and power. These were the causes which opened the Alps to Hasdrubal.
But the advantage which he gained by the celerity of his march he
lost by his delay at Placentia, while he carried on a fruitless siege,
rather than an assault. He had supposed that it would be easy to take
by storm a town situated on a plain; and the celebrity of the colony
induced him to believe that by destroying it he should strike great
terror into the rest. This siege not only impeded his own progress,
but had the effect of restraining Hannibal, who was just on the point
of quitting his winter quarters, after hearing of his passage, which
was so much quicker than he expected; for he not only revolved in his
mind how tedious was the siege of towns, but also how ineffectual was
his attempt upon that same colony, when returning victorious from the
Trebia.
40. The consuls, on departing from the city in different directions,
had drawn the attention of the public, as it were, to two wars at
once, while they called to mind the disasters which Hannibal's first
coming had brought upon Italy, and at the same time, tortured with
anxiety, asked themselves what deities would be so propitious to the
city and empire as that the commonwealth should be victorious in both
quarters at once. Hitherto they had been enabled to hold out to the
present time by compensating for their misfortunes by their successes.
When the Roman power was laid prostrate at the Trasimenus and at
Cannae in Italy, their successes in Spain had raised it up from its
fallen condition. Afterwards, when in Spain one disaster after another
had in a great measure destroyed two armies, with the loss of two
distinguished generals, the many successes in Italy and Sicily had,
as it were, afforded a haven for the shattered state; and the mere
interval of space, as one war was going on in the remotest quarter
of the world, gave them time to recover their breath. Whereas now two
wars were received into Italy; two generals of the highest renown were
besetting the Roman city; while the whole weight of the danger and
the entire burden pressed upon one point. Whichever of these generals
should be first victorious, he would in a few days unite his camp
with the other. The preceding year also, saddened by the deaths of two
consuls, filled them with alarm. Such were the anxious feelings with
which the people escorted the consuls on their departure to their
provinces. It is recorded that Marcus Livius, still teeming with
resentment against his countrymen, when setting out to the war,
replied to Fabius, who warned him not rashly to come to an action till
he had made himself acquainted with the character of his enemy, that
as soon as ever he had got sight of the troops of the enemy he would
engage them. When asked what was his reason for such haste, he said,
"I shall either obtain the highest glory from conquering the enemy,
or the greatest joy from the defeat of my countrymen, a joy which
they have deserved, though it would not become me." Before the consul
Claudius arrived in his province, Caius Hostilius Tubulus, attacking
Hannibal with his light cohorts while marching his army through the
extreme borders of the territory of Larinum into that of Sallentum,
caused terrible confusion in his unmarshalled troops; he killed as
many as four thousand, and captured nine military standards. Quintus
Claudius, who had his camps distributed through the towns of the
Sallentine territory, had quitted his winter quarters on hearing of
the enemy; and Hannibal, fearing on that account lest he should have
to engage with two armies at once, decamped by night, and retired from
the Tarentine to the Bruttian territory. Claudius turned his army
to the Sallentine territory. Hostilius, on his way to Capua, met
the consul Claudius at Venusia. Here forty thousand infantry and two
thousand five hundred horse were selected from both armies, with which
the consul might carry on the war against Hannibal. The rest of the
troops Hostilius was directed to march to Capua to deliver them over
to Quintus Fulvius, proconsul.
41. Hannibal, having drawn together his forces from all quarters, both
those which he had in winter quarters, and those which he had in the
garrisons of the Bruttian territory, came to Grumentum in Lucania,
with the hope of regaining the towns which through fear had revolted
to the Romans. To the same place the Roman consul proceeded from
Venusia, exploring the way as he went, and pitched his camp about
fifteen hundred paces from the enemy. The rampart of the Carthaginians
seemed almost united with the walls of Grumentum, though five hundred
paces intervened. Between the Carthaginian and Roman camps lay a
plain; and overhanging the left wing of the Carthaginians and the
right of the Romans were some naked hills, which were not objects
of suspicion to either party, as they had no wood upon them, nor any
hiding-places for an ambuscade. In the plain which lay between them
skirmishes hardly worth mentioning took place between parties sallying
from the outposts. It was evident that what the Roman aimed at was to
prevent the enemy from going off, while Hannibal, who was desirous of
escaping thence, came down with all his forces, and formed in order
of battle. Upon this the consul, imitating the crafty character of his
enemy, ordered five cohorts, with the addition of five maniples, to
pass the summit by night and sit down in the valleys on the opposite
side; a measure to which he was prompted the more strongly in
proportion as he felt that there could exist no suspicion of an
ambuscade in hills so uncovered. Of the time for rising up from their
retreat and of falling upon the enemy he informed Tiberius Claudius
Asellus, a military tribune, and Publius Claudius, praefect of the
allies, whom he sent with them. The general himself, at break of day,
drew out all his forces, both foot and horse, for battle. Shortly
after, the signal for battle was given out by Hannibal, and a noise
was raised in the camp, from the troops running hastily to arms; then
both horse and foot eagerly rushed through the gates, and spreading
themselves over the plain, hastened to the enemy. The consul
perceiving them thus disordered, gave orders to Caius Aurunculeius, a
military tribune of the third legion, to send out the cavalry of the
legion to charge the enemy with all possible vehemence, for that the
enemy had spread themselves like cattle in such disorder throughout
the whole plain, that they might be knocked down and trampled under
foot before they could be formed.
42. Hannibal had not yet gone out of the camp, when he heard the shout
of his troops engaged; and thus roused by the alarm, he hastily led his
forces against the enemy. Already had the Roman horse spread terror through
the Carthaginian van; the first legion also of the infantry and the right
wing were commencing the action, while the troops of the Carthaginians,
in disorder, engaged just as chance threw each in the way of horse or foot.
The battle became more general by reinforcements, and the number of those
who ran out to the combat. Hannibal, amid the terror and confusion, would
have drawn up his troops while fighting, (which would not have been an
easy task unless to a veteran general with veteran soldiers,) had not the
shouts of the cohorts and maniples, running down from the hills, which
was heard in their rear, created an alarm lest they should be cut off from
their camp. After this they were seized with a panic, and a flight commenced
in every part; but the number slain was less, because the nearness of the
camp offered to the terrified troops a shorter distance to fly. For the
cavalry hung upon their rear, and the cohorts, running down the declivities
of the hills by an unobstructed and easy path, charged them transversely
in flank. However, above eight thousand men were slain, above seven hundred
made prisoners, and eight military standards taken. Of the elephants also,
which had been of no use in such a sudden and irregular action, four were
killed and two captured. The conquerors lost about five hundred Romans
and allies. The following day the Carthaginian remained quiet. The Roman
having led out his troops into the field, when he saw that no one came
out to meet him, gave orders that the spoils of those of the enemy who
were slain should be collected, and that the bodies of his own men should
be gathered into one place and buried. After this, for several days following
in succession, he came up so near the enemy's gates that he almost seemed
to be carrying in his standards. But at length Hannibal at the third watch,
leaving a number of fires and tents in that part of the camp which faced
the enemy, and also a few Numidians who might show themselves in the rampart
and the gates, decamped and proceeded towards Apulia. As soon as it dawned,
the Roman army came up to the trenches, and the Numidians, according to
the plan concerted, took care to show themselves for a little time on the
rampart and in the gates; and having deceived the enemy for some time,
rode off at full speed, and overtook their friends on their march. The
consul, when all was silence in the camp, and he could now no where see
even the few who at break of day had walked up and down, sent two horsemen
in advance to reconnoiter; and after he had ascertained that all was safe
enough, ordered his troops to march in; and after staying there only while
his men distributed themselves for plunder, sounded a retreat and led back
his forces long before night. The next day he set out as soon as it was
light, and following the rumor and the track of the enemy by forced marches,
came up with them not far from Venusia. Here also an irregular battle took
place, in which two thousand of the Carthaginians were slain. The Carthaginian
quitting this place made for Metapontum, marching by night and over mountainous
districts in order to avoid a battle. Thence Hanno, who commanded the garrison
of that place, was sent into Bruttium with a small party to raise a fresh
army. Hannibal, after adding his forces to his own, went back to Venusia
by the same route by which he came, and proceeded thence to Canusium. Nero
had never quitted the enemy's steps, and when he himself went to Metapontum,
had sent for Quintus Fulvius into Lucania, lest that region should be left
without protection.
43. Meanwhile four Gallic horsemen and two Numidians, who were sent to
Hannibal with a letter from Hasdrubal, after he had retired from the
siege of Placentia, having traversed nearly the whole length of Italy
through the midst of enemies, while following Hannibal as he was
retiring to Metapontum, were taken to Tarentum by mistaking the roads;
where they were seized by some Roman foragers, who were straggling
through the fields, and brought before the proprietor, Caius Claudius.
At first they endeavoured to baffle him by evasive answers, but
threats of applying torture being held out to them, they were
compelled to confess the truth; when they fully admitted that they
were the bearers of a letter from Hasdrubal to Hannibal. They were
delivered into the custody of Lucius Virginius, a military tribune,
together with the letter sealed as it was, to be conveyed to the
consul Claudius. At the same time two troops of Samnites were sent
with them as an escort. Having made their way to the consul, the
letter was read by means of an interpreter, and the captives were
interrogated; when Claudius, coming to the conclusion that the
predicament of the state was not such as that her generals should
carry on the war, each within the limits of his own province, and with
his own troops, according to the customary plans of warfare, and with
an enemy marked out for him by the senate, but that some unlooked
for and unexpected enterprise must be attempted, which, in its
commencement, might cause no less dread among their countrymen than
their enemies, but which, when accomplished, might convert their
great fear into great joy, sent the letter of Hasdrubal to Rome to the
senate; and at the same time informed the conscript fathers what his
intentions were; and recommended that, as Hasdrubal had written to his
brother that he should meet him in Umbria, they should send for the
legion from Capua to Rome, enlist troops at Rome, and oppose the city
forces to the enemy at Narnia. Such was his letter to the senate.
Messengers were sent in advance through the territory of Larinum,
Marrucia, Frentana, and Praetutia, where he was about to march his
army, with orders that they should all bring down from their farms and
towns to the road-side provisions ready dressed for the soldiers to
eat; and that they should bring out horses and other beasts of burden,
so that those who were tired might have plenty of conveyances. He then
selected the choicest troops out of the whole army of the Romans and
allies, to the amount of six thousand infantry and one thousand horse;
and gave out that he intended to seize on the nearest town in Lucania
and the Carthaginian garrison in it, and that they should all be
in readiness to march. Setting out by night he turned off towards
Picenum, and making his marches as long as possible, led his troops to
join his colleague, having left Quintus Catius, lieutenant-general, in
command of the camp.
44. At Rome the alarm and consternation were not less than they had been
two years before, when the Carthaginian camp was pitched over against the
Roman walls and gates; nor could people make up their minds whether they
should commend, or censure, this so bold march of the consul. It was evident
that the light in which it would be viewed would depend upon its success;
than which nothing can be more unfair. They said, "that the camp was
left near to the enemy, Hannibal, without a general, and with an army from
which all the flower and vigor had been withdrawn; and that the consul
had pretended an expedition into Lucania, when he was in reality going
to Picenum and Gaul, leaving his camp secured only by the ignorance of
the enemy, who were not aware that the general and part of his army were
away. What would be the consequence if that should be discovered, and Hannibal
should think proper either to pursue Nero with his whole army, who had
gone off with only six thousand armed men, or to assault the camp, which
was left as a prey for him, without strength, without command, without
auspices?" The disasters already experienced in the war, the deaths
of two consuls the preceding year, augmented their fears. Besides, all
these events had occurred "when there was only one general and one
army of the enemy in Italy; whereas now they had two Punic wars, two immense
armies, and in a manner two Hannibals in Italy, inasmuch as Hasdrubal was
descended from the same father, Hamilcar, was a general equally enterprising,
having been trained in a Roman war during so many years in Spain, and rendered
famous by a double victory, having annihilated two armies with two most
renowned generals. For he could glory even more than Hannibal himself,
on account of the celerity with which he had effected his passage out of
Spain, and his success in stirring up the Gallic nations to arms, inasmuch
as he had collected an army in those very regions in which Hannibal lost
the major part of his soldiers by famine and cold, the most miserable modes
of death." Those who were experienced in the events which had occurred
in Spain, added, that "he would not have to engage with Caius Nero,
the general, as an unknown person, whom, when accidentally caught in a
difficult defile, he had eluded and baffled like a little child, by drawing
up fallacious terms of peace." Under the dictation of fear, which
always puts the worst construction upon things, they magnified all the
advantages which the enemy possessed, and undervalued their own.
45. When Nero had got such a distance from the enemy that his plan might
be disclosed without danger, he briefly addressed his soldiers, observing,
that "there never was a measure adopted by any general which was in
appearance more daring than this, but in reality more safe. That he was
leading them on to certain victory. For as his colleague had not set out
to prosecute the war which he conducted, until forces both of horse and
foot had been assigned to him by the senate to his own satisfaction, and
those greater and better equipped than if he had been going against Hannibal
himself, that they would, by joining him, however small the quantity of
force which they might add, completely turn the scale. That when it was
only heard in the field of battle (and he would take care that it should
not be heard before) that another consul and another army had arrived,
it would insure the victory. That rumor decided war; and that the most
inconsiderable incidents had power to excite hope and fear in the mind.
That they would themselves reap almost the entire glory which would be
obtained if they succeeded, for it was invariably the case that the last
addition which is made is supposed to have effected the whole. That they
themselves saw with what multitudes, what admiration, and what good wishes
of men their march was attended." And, by Hercules, they marched amid
vows, prayers, and commendations, all the roads being lined with ranks
of men and women, who had flocked there from all parts of the country.
They called them the safeguards of the state, the protectors of the city
and empire of Rome. They said that the safety and liberty of themselves
and their children were treasured up in their arms and right hands. They
prayed to all the gods and goddesses to grant them a prosperous march,
a successful battle, and a speedy victory over their enemies; and that
they might be bound to pay the vows which they had undertaken in their
behalf; so that as now they attended them off with anxiety, go after a
few days' interval they might joyfully go out to meet them exulting in
victory. Then they severally and earnestly invited them to accept, offered
them, and wearied them with entreaties, to take from them in preference
to another, whatever might be requisite for themselves or their cattle.
They generously gave them every thing in abundance, while the soldiers
vied with each other in moderation, taking care not to accept any thing
beyond what was necessary for use. They did not make any delay nor quit
their ranks when taking food; they continued the march day and night, scarcely
giving as much to rest as was necessary to the requirements of the body.
Messengers were also dispatched in advance to his colleague, to inform
him of his approach, and to ask whether he wished that he should come secretly
or openly, by day or night, whether they should lodge in the same or different
camps. It appeared most advisable that they should come into the camp secretly
by night.
46. A private signal was sent through the camp by the consul
Livius, that each tribune should receive a tribune, each centurion a
centurion, each horseman a horseman, each foot-soldier a foot-soldier;
for it was not expedient that the camp should be enlarged, lest the
enemy should discover the arrival of the other consul, while the
crowding together of several persons, who would have their tents in a
confined place, would be attended with less inconvenience, because the
army of Claudius had brought with them on their expedition scarcely
any thing except their arms. Claudius, on the very march, had
augmented his numbers by volunteers; for not only veteran soldiers,
who had completed their period of service, but young men also offered
themselves without solicitation; and, as they vied with each other in
giving in their names, he had enlisted those whose personal appearance
and bodily strength seemed fit for military service. The camp of the
other consul was near Sena, and Hasdrubal's position was about five
hundred paces from it. Nero, therefore, when he was now drawing near,
halted under cover of the mountains, in order that he might not enter
the camp before night. Having entered when all was still, they
were severally conducted into their tents by the men of their own
description, where they were hospitably entertained with the utmost
joy on the part of all. The next day a council was held, at which
Lucius Porcius Licinus, the praetor, was present. He had his camp
joined to that of the consuls, and before their arrival, by leading
his army along the heights, sometimes occupying narrow defiles that he
might intercept his passage, at other times harassing his troops while
marching by attacking their flank or rear, he had baffled the enemy by
all the arts of war. This man was, on the present occasion, one of
the council. Many inclined to the opinion that an engagement should
be deferred till Nero had recruited his soldiers, who were weary with
marching and watching, and had employed a few days in acquiring a
knowledge of his enemy. Nero urged, not only by persuasion, but with
the most earnest entreaties, "that they would not render rash by delay
that measure of his which despatch had made safe. That Hannibal, who
lay in a state of torpid inactivity in consequence of a delusion which
would not continue long, had neither attacked his camp, left as it was
without a leader, nor had directed his course in pursuit of him. That
the army of Hasdrubal might be annihilated, and he might retire into
Apulia before he stirred a step. The man who by delay gave time to the
enemy both betrayed the camp to Hannibal, and opened a way to him
into Gaul, so that he might effect a junction with Hasdrubal at his
leisure, and when he pleased. That they ought to give the signal for
battle instantly, and march out into the field, and take advantage of
the delusion of their enemies present and absent, while neither those
were aware that they had fewer, nor these that they had more and
stronger forces to encounter." On the breaking up of the council the
signal for battle was displayed, and the troops immediately led into
the field.
47. The Carthaginians were already standing before their camp in
battle-array. This circumstance delayed the battle: Hasdrubal, who
had advanced before the line with a few horsemen, remarked some old
shields among the enemy, which he had not seen before, and some horses
leaner than the rest their numbers also appeared greater than usual.
Suspecting therefore, what was really the case, he hastily sounded
a retreat, and sent a party to the river from which they got their
water, where some of them might be intercepted, and notice taken
whether there were perchance any there whose complexions were more
than ordinarily sun-burnt, as from a recent march. At the same time he
ordered a party to ride round the camp at a distance, and note whether
the rampart was extended in any part, and also observe whether the
signal sounded once or twice. Having received a report of all these
particulars, the fact of the camp's not being enlarged led him into
error. There were now two camps, as there were before the other consul
arrived, one belonging to Marcus Livius, the other to Lucius Porcius,
and to neither of them had any addition been made to give more room
for the tents. But the veteran general, who was accustomed to a Roman
enemy, was much struck by their reporting that the signal sounded once
in the praetor's camp, and twice in the consul's; there must therefore
be two consuls, and felt the most painful anxiety as to the manner
in which the other had got away from Hannibal. Least of all could he
suspect, what was really the case, that he had got away from Hannibal
by deceiving him to such an extent, as that he knew not where the
general was, and where the army whose camp stood opposite to his own.
Surely, he concluded, deterred by a defeat of no ordinary kind, he has
not dared to pursue him; and he began to entertain the most serious
fears that he had himself come too late with assistance, now that
affairs were desperate, and lest the same good fortune attended the
Roman arms in Italy which they had experienced in Spain. Sometimes
he imagined that his letter could not have reached him, and that, it
having been intercepted, the consul had hastened to overpower him.
Thus anxious and perplexed, having put out the fires, he issued a
signal at the first watch to collect the baggage in silence, and gave
orders to march. In the hurry and confusion occasioned by a march
by night, their guides were not watched with sufficient care and
attention. One of them stopped in a place of concealment which he had
beforehand fixed upon in his mind, the other swam across the river
Metaurus, at a ford with which he was acquainted. The troops, thus
deserted by their guides, at first wandered up and down through the
fields; and some of them, overpowered with sleep, and fatigued with,
watching, stretched themselves on the ground here and there, leaving
their standards thinly attended. Hasdrubal gave orders to march along
the bank of the river until the light should discover the road; but,
pursuing a circuitous and uncertain course along the turnings and
windings of that tortuous river, with the intention of crossing it
as soon as the first light should discover a place convenient for
the purpose he made but little progress; but wasting the day in a
fruitless attempt to discover a ford, for the further he went from the
sea the higher he found the banks which kept the river in its course,
he gave the enemy time to overtake him.
48. First Nero arrived with the whole body of his cavalry, then Porcius came up with him, with the light infantry. And while these were harassing his weary troops on every side, and charging them, and the Carthaginian, stopping his march, which resembled a flight, was desirous of encamping on an eminence, on the bank of the river, Livius came up with all his foot forces, not after the manner of troops on march, but armed and marshalled for immediate action. When they had united all their forces, and the line was drawn out, Claudius took the direction of the battle in the right wing, Livius in the left; the management of the center was given to the praetor. Hasdrubal, when he saw that an engagement was inevitable, giving over the fortification of a camp, placed his elephants in the front line, before the standards; on either side these he placed in the left wing the Gauls to oppose Claudius, not so much from any confidence he reposed in them, as because he believed them to be dreaded by the enemy; the right wing he took to himself against M. Livius, together with the Spaniards, in whom, as being veteran troops, he placed his greatest hopes. Behind the elephants, in the center, the Ligurians were posted; but his line was rather long than deep. The Gauls were covered by a hill, which extended in front. That part of the line which was occupied by the Spaniards, engaged the left wing of the Romans, the whole of whose right wing, extending beyond the line of battle, was unengaged. The hill before them prevented their making an attack either in front or flank. Between Livius and Hasdrubal a furious contest arose, and the slaughter on both sides was dreadful. Here were both generals, here the major part of the Roman horse and infantry, here the Spaniards, veteran troops, and experienced in the Roman manner of fighting, and the Ligurians, a nation inured to war. The elephants were also driven to the same place which, on the first onset, disordered the van, and had made even dislodged the standards; but afterwards, the contest growing hotter, and the shout increasing, they became less submissive to their riders, and ranged to and fro between the two lines, as if not knowing to which side they belonged, like ships floating about without rudders. Claudius, when he had striven in vain to advance up the hill, repeatedly calling out to his soldiers, "To what purpose then have we performed so long a march with such expedition?" when he found it impossible to make his way to the enemy in that quarter, withdrawing several cohorts from the right wing, where he saw they would occupy an inactive station, rather than join in the fight, led them round the rear of the line, and, to the surprise not only of the enemy but his own party, charged their right flank; and such was their rapidity, that after showing themselves on their flank, they almost immediately made an attack on their rear. Thus on all sides, in front, flank, and rear, the Spaniards and Ligurians were cut to pieces; and now the carnage had even reached the Gauls. Here the least opposition was found; for a great number of them had quitted their standards, having slunk off during the night, and laid themselves down to sleep up and down the fields, while even those who were present, being tired with marching and watching, for their bodies are most intolerant of fatigue, could scarcely carry their arms upon their shoulders. And now it was mid-day, and thirst and heat gave them over to the enemy to be killed or captured in multitudes.
49. More elephants were killed by their guides than by the enemy. They
used to have with them a workman's knife, with a mallet. When these beasts
began to grow furious, and attack their own party, the rider, placing this
knife between the ears, just on the joint by which the neck is connected
with the head, used to drive it in, striking it with all the force he could.
This was found to be the most expeditious mode of putting these bulky animals
to death, when they had destroyed all hope of governing them. This method
was first practiced by Hasdrubal, a general whose conduct both frequently
on other occasions, and especially in this battle, deserved to be recorded.
By encouraging the men when fighting, and sharing equally in every danger,
he kept up the battle. Sometimes by entreating, at other times by rebuking,
the troops, when tired and indisposed to fight from weariness and over-exertion,
he rekindled their spirits. He called back the flying, and restored the
battle in many places when it had been given up. At length, when fortune
decidedly declared for the Romans, lest he should survive so great an army
which had been collected under the influence of his name, he put spurs
to his horse and rushed upon a Roman cohort, where he fell fighting, as
was worthy of the son of Hamilcar and the brother of Hannibal. At no time
during that war were so many of the enemy slain in one battle; so that
a defeat equal to that sustained at Cannae, whether in respect of the loss
of the general or the troops, was considered to have been retorted upon
him. Fifty-six thousand of the enemy were slain, five thousand four hundred
captured. The other booty was great, both of every other kind, and also
of gold and silver. In addition to the rest, there were recovered above
four thousand Roman citizens, who had been taken by the enemy, which formed
some consolation for the soldiers lost in that battle. For the victory
was by no means bloodless. Much about eight thousand of the Romans and
the allies were slain; and so completely were even the victors satiated
with blood and slaughter, that the next day, when Livius the consul received
intelligence that the Cisalpine Gauls and Ligurians, who had either not
been present at the battle or had made their escape from the carnage, were
marching off in one body without a certain leader, without standards, without
any discipline or subordination; that if one squadron of horse were sent
against them they might be all destroyed, he replied, "Let some survive
to bear the news of the enemy's losses and of our valor."
50. Nero set out on the night following the battle, and marching at a more rapid rate than when he came, arrived at his camp before the enemy on the sixth day. As he was not preceded by a messenger, fewer people attended him on the march; but the joy felt was so great, that they were almost insane with delight. Neither state of feeling at Rome can be well described or told, whether that in which the citizens were when in doubtful expectation of the issue, or when they received the intelligence of victory. Every day, from the time that news arrived that the consul Claudius had set out, from sun-rise to sun-set, none of the senators ever quitted the senate-house, or did the people depart from the forum. The matrons, as they had themselves no means of affording assistance, had recourse to prayers and entreaties, and going about to all the temples, wearied the gods with vows and supplications. While the city was in this state of solicitude and suspense, a vague report first arrived that two Narnian horsemen had come from the field of battle into the camp which stood as a defense in the entrance to Umbria, with intelligence that the enemy were cut to pieces. At first they rather heard than credited this news, as being too great and too joyful for the mind to take in, or obtain a firm belief. Even the very rapidity with which it had arrived formed an obstacle to its reception; for it was stated that the battle took place two days before. After this a letter was brought which had been sent by Lucius Manlius Acidinus, from his camp, on the subject of the arrival of the Narnian horsemen. This letter being conveyed through the forum to the tribunal of the praetor, drew the senators out of the senate-house; and with such eagerness and hurry did the people crowd to the doors of the senate-house, that the messenger could not approach, but was dragged off by persons who asked him questions, and demanded vociferously that the letter should be read on the rostrum before it was read in the senate. At length they were put back and restrained by the magistrates; and thus the joy was gradually dispensed to their overpowered spirits. The letter was read first in the senate, and then in the assembly of the people. The effect was various, according to the difference in the cast of men's minds, some thinking that there were already sure grounds for rejoicing, while others would place no confidence in the news, till they listened to ambassadors, or a letter from the consuls.
51. After this, news came that the ambassadors themselves were on the point
of arriving. Then, indeed, people of all ages ran to meet them, each man
being eager to be the first to receive an assurance of such joyful tidings,
by the evidence of his eyes and ears. One continued train extended as far
as the Mulvian bridge. The ambassadors, Lucius Veturius Philo, Publius
Licinius Varus, and Quintus Caecilius Metellus, made their way into the
forum, surrounded by a crowd of persons of every description; when some
asked the ambassadors themselves, others their attendants, what had been
done; and, as soon as each had heard that the army and general of the enemy
had been cut off, that the Roman legions were safe, and the consuls unhurt,
he immediately imparted the joyful intelligence to others, imparting to
them the joy he felt himself. Having with difficulty made their way into
the senate-house, and the crowd with still more difficulty being removed,
that they might not mix with the fathers, the letter was read in the senate;
after which the ambassadors were brought into the general assembly. Lucius
Veturius Philo, after reading the letter himself, gave a more explicit
account of all that had occurred, amidst great approbation, and at last
of general shouting from the assembly, while their minds could scarcely
contain their joy. They then ran off in various directions, some to the
different temples of the gods, to return thanks, others to their homes,
to impart the joyful intelligence to their wives and children. The senate
decreed a supplication for three days, because Marcus Livius and Caius
Claudius, the consuls, had cut off the general and legions of the enemy,
their own army being safe. This supplication Caius Hostilius, the praetor,
proclaimed in the assembly, and was celebrated both by men and women. During
the whole three days all the temples were uniformly crowded, whilst the
matrons, dressed in their richest robes, and accompanied by their children,
just as though the war had been brought to a conclusion, and free from
every apprehension, offered thanksgivings to the immortal gods. This victory
produced an alteration also in the condition of the state, so that immediately
from this event, just as though it had been a time of peace, men were not
afraid to do business with each other, buying, selling, lending, and paying
borrowed money. Caius Claudius, the consul, on his return to his camp,
ordered the head of Hasdrubal, which he had carefully kept and brought
with him, to be thrown before the advanced guards of the enemy, and the
African prisoners to be shown to them bound just as they were. Two of these
also he unbound, and bid them go to Hannibal and tell him what had occurred.
Hannibal, smitten by such severe distress, at once public and domestic,
is said to have declared that he recognized the destiny of Carthage; and
decamping thence with the intention of drawing together into Bruttium,
the remotest corner of Italy, all his auxiliaries which he could not protect
when widely scattered, removed into Bruttium the whole state of the Metapontines,
summoned away from their former habitations, and also such of the Lucanians
as were under his authority.
BOOK XXVIII.
Successful operations against the Carthaginians in Spain,
under Silanus, Scipio's lieutenant, and L. Scipio, his
brother; of Sulpicius and Attalus, against Philip, king of
Macedonia. Scipio finally vanquishes the Carthaginians in
Spain, and reduces that whole country; passes over into
Africa, forms an alliance with Syphax, king of Numidia;
represses and punishes a mutiny of a part of his army;
concludes a treaty of friendship with Masinissa; returns to
Rome, and is elected consul; solicits Africa for his province,
which is opposed by Quintus Fabius Maximus; is appointed
governor of Sicily, with permission to pass over into Africa.
1. At the time when Spain appeared to be relieved in proportion to the
degree in which the weight of the war was removed into Italy, by the passage
of Hasdrubal, another war sprang up there equal in magnitude to the former.
At this juncture, the Romans and Carthaginians thus occupied Spain: Hasdrubal,
son of Gisgo, had retired quite to the ocean and Gades; the coast of our
sea, and almost the whole of that part of Spain which lies eastward, was
subject to Scipio and the Romans. The new general, Hanno, who had passed
over from Africa, to supply the place of the Barcine Hasdrubal, with a
new army, and formed a junction with Mago, having in a short time armed
a large number of men in Celtiberia, which lies in the midway between the
two seas, Scipio sent Marcus Silanus against him, with no more than ten
thousand infantry and five hundred horse. Silanus, by marching with all
the haste he could, (though the ruggedness of the roads, and narrow defiles
obstructed with thick woods, which are very frequent in Spain, impeded
him,) yet being guided by deserters from Celtiberia, natives of that place,
reached the enemy, anticipating not only messengers but even all rumor
of his coming. From the same source he ascertained, when they were about
ten thousand paces from the enemy, that they had two camps, one on each
side of the road in which they were marching; that the Celtiberians, a
newly-raised army, in number above nine thousand, were on the left, and
that the Carthaginian camp was stationed on the right. The latter was secured
and protected by outposts, watches, and every kind of regular military
guard, while the former was disorderly and neglected, as belonging to barbarians,
who were raw soldiers, and were under the less apprehension, because they
were in their own country. Silanus, concluding that this was the camp to
be attacked first, ordered the troops to march as much as possible towards
the left, lest he should be observed from any point by the Carthaginian
outposts, and sending scouts in advance, pushed on towards the enemy at
a rapid pace.
2. He was now about three thousand paces from the enemy, when as yet none
of them had perceived him. The ground was covered with craggy places, and
hills overgrown with bushes. Here in a hollow valley, and on that account
unexposed to the view, he ordered his men to sit down and take refreshment.
In the mean time the scouts returned, confirming the statements of the
deserters. Then the Romans, collecting their baggage in the center, took
arms, and marched to battle in regular array. They were a thousand paces
off when they were descried by the enemy, when suddenly all began to be
in a state of hurry and confusion. At the first shout and tumult, Mago
quitted the camp and rode up at full speed. As there were in the Celtiberian
army four thousand targeteers and two hundred horsemen, this regular legion,
as it formed the flower of his troops, he stationed in the first line;
the rest, composed of light-armed, he posted in reserve. While he was leading
them out of the camp thus marshalled, the Romans discharged their javelins
at them before they had scarcely cleared the rampart. The Spaniards stooped
down to avoid the javelins thrown at them by the enemy, and then rose up
to discharge their own in turn; which the Romans having received according
to their custom in close array, with their shields firmly united, they
then engaged foot to foot, and began to fight with their swords. But the
ruggedness of the ground, while it rendered ineffectual the agility of
the Celtiberians who were accustomed to a skirmishing kind of battle, was
at the same time not unfavorable to the Romans, who were accustomed to
a steady kind of fight, except that the narrow passes and the bushes, which
grew here and there, broke their ranks, and they were compelled to engage
one against one and two against two, as if matched together. The same circumstance
which obstructed the enemy's flight, delivered them up, as it were, bound
for slaughter. And now when almost all the targeteers had been slain, the
light-armed and the Carthaginians, who had come up to their assistance
from the other camp, having been thrown into confusion, were put to the
sword. Not more than two thousand of the infantry, and all the cavalry,
fled from the field with Mago before the battle was well begun. The other
general, Hanno, was taken alive, together with those who came up when the
battle was now decided. Almost the whole of the cavalry and the veteran
infantry, following Mago in his flight, came to Hasdrubal on the tenth
day in the province of Gades. The newly-raised Celtiberian troops, stealing
off to the neighboring woods, fled thence to their homes. By this very
seasonable victory, a stop was put to a war which was not by any means
so considerable as that to which it would have grown, had the enemy been
allowed, after having prevailed upon the Celtiberians to join them, to
solicit other nations also to take up arms. Scipio, therefore, having liberally
bestowed the highest commendations on Silanus, and entertaining a hope
that he might bring the war to a termination, if he did not impede it by
a want of activity on his own part, proceeded into the remotest part of
Spain against Hasdrubal. The Carthaginian, who then happened to be encamped
in Baetica, in order to prevent his allies from wavering in their allegiance,
retired quite to the ocean and Gades, in a manner much more resembling
a flight than a march. He was afraid, however; that while he kept his forces
together, he should form the principal object of attack. Before he crossed
the strait to Gades he sent them into different cities, that they might
both provide for their own safety by the help of walls, and for that of
the town by their arms.
3. Scipio, seeing the enemy's forces thus distributed, and that to
carry about his forces to each of the several cities would be rather
tedious than important, marched his army back. Not to leave all that
country, however, to the Carthaginians, he sent his brother, Lucius
Scipio, at the head of ten thousand foot and one thousand horse,
to besiege the most important city of that quarter, called by the
barbarians Orinx, and situated on the borders of the Milesians, a
nation of Spain so called. The soil is fertile, and even silver is
dug out of it by the inhabitants. This place served as a fort to
Hasdrubal, from which he might make incursions on the inland states.
Scipio encamped near the city. Before he formed his lines round it, he
sent to the gates to sound the inclinations of the inhabitants, by a
direct interview, and persuade them to make trial of the friendship of
the Romans rather than of their power. As they answered nothing of a
friendly nature, he threw a double trench and rampart round the place,
dividing his army into three parts, in order that one division might
assault it while the other two rested. The first of these beginning
the attack, a furious and doubtful contest ensued. It was by no means
easy to approach and bring the ladders to the walls, on account of the
weapons which fell upon them; and even of those persons who had raised
them, some were thrown down with forks made for the purpose, others
were in danger of being laid hold of by iron grapples, and dragged
up hanging to the wall. Scipio, seeing that the contest was equalized
owing to the fewness of his party, and that the enemy, fighting from
the wall, were superior to him, called off the first division and
attacked them with the two others together. This so terrified the
besieged, who were already fatigued with fighting with the former,
that not only the townsmen forsook the walls in sudden flight, but the
Carthaginian garrison, fearing that the town had been betrayed, also
quitted their posts and collected themselves into a body. Upon this
the inhabitants began to be alarmed, lest if the enemy broke into the
town they should kill all they met indiscriminately, Carthaginian or
Spaniard. They therefore suddenly threw open the gates and rushed
out of the town, holding their shields before them, lest any weapons
should be cast at them from a distance, and stretching out to view
their bare right hands, that it might be seen they had thrown away
their swords. Whether this was not observed, in consequence of the
distance, or whether some deception was suspected, is not known; but
an attack was made on the deserters, and they were put to death as a
hostile force. Through this gate the enemy marched into the city in
battle-array. The other gates were cut through and broken down with
axes and sledges; and as each horseman entered, he galloped off to
seize the forum, as had been ordered. A body of veteran troops were
also added to the horse to support them. The legionary troops spread
themselves in every part of the city, but neither killed nor
plundered any, except such as defended themselves with arms. All the
Carthaginians were put under guard, with more than three hundred of
the inhabitants, who had shut the gates. The rest had the town put
into their hands, and their property restored. About two thousand of
the enemy fell in the assault on this city, and not more than ninety
of the Romans.
4. As the taking of this town was a source of great joy to those who
effected it, as well as to the general and the rest of the army, so
their approach to their camp also presented a splendid spectacle,
on account of the immense crowd of captives they drove before
them. Scipio, having bestowed high commendations upon his brother,
representing the capture of Orinx as equal in importance to the
capture of Carthage by himself, led his forces back into hither
Spain. He could not make an attempt on Gades, or pursue the army
of Hasdrubal, now dispersed through all parts of the province, in
consequence of the approach of winter. He therefore dismissed the
legions into winter quarters, and sent his brother Lucius Scipio with
Hanno, the enemy's general, and other distinguished prisoners, to
Rome, while he retired himself to Tarraco. During the same year, the
Roman fleet under Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the proconsul, sailing
over from Sicily into Africa, devastated to a wide extent the fields
about Utica and Carthage. They carried off plunder from the remotest
borders of the Carthaginian territory around the very walls of Utica.
On their return to Sicily they were met by a Carthaginian fleet of
seventy ships of war, of which seventeen were taken and four sunk; the
rest were dispersed and compelled to fly. The Romans, victorious both
by land and sea, returned to Lilybaeum with immense booty of every
kind. The ships of the enemy having thus been driven from the whole
sea, large supplies of corn were conveyed to Rome.
5. In the beginning of the summer in which these events occurred, Publius
Sulpicius, proconsul, and king Attalus, having passed the winter at Aegina,
as before observed, united their fleets, consisting of twenty-three Roman
quinqueremes and thirty-five belonging to the king, and proceeded to Lemnos.
Philip also, that he might be prepared for every kind of measure, whether
it should be necessary to meet the enemy on land or sea, came down to the
coast of Demetrias and appointed to his army a day on which to meet him
at Larissa. On the news of the king's arrival, ambassadors from his allies
came to Demetrias from all sides. For the Aetolians, inspirited both by
their alliance with the Romans and the approach of king Attalus, were ravaging
the neighboring states; not only the Acarnanians, Boeotians, and Euboeans
were very much alarmed, but the Achaeans also were kept in a state of terror,
both by the hostile proceedings of the Aetolians, and also by Machanidas,
tyrant of Lacedaemon, who had encamped at a short distance from the borders
of the Argives. All of these stating the dangers which threatened their
possessions, both by land and sea, entreated succor from the king. Philip
received accounts even from his own kingdom, that things were not in a
state of tranquillity; that both Scerdilaedus and Pleuratus were in motion,
and that some of the Thracians, and particularly the Maedians, would certainly
make incursions on the contiguous provinces of Macedonia, should the king
be occupied with a distant war. The Boeotians, indeed, and the people inhabiting
the inland parts of Greece, told him that the Aetolians had obstructed
by a ditch and rampart the straits of Thermopylae, where the road is very
narrow and confined, in order to prevent their passing to the assistance
of the allied states. So many disturbances arising on all hands were sufficient
to awaken an inactive general. He dismissed the ambassadors, promising
to assist them all according as opportunity and circumstances allowed.
For the present, he sent to Peparethus a body of troops to garrison the
city, for this was the most urgent business, as information had been received
thence that Attalus, crossing over to Lemnos, was devastating all the neighboring
country. He sent Polyphantas with a small detachment to Boeotia, and also
Menippus, one of his guards, with one thousand targeteers (the target is
not unlike the ordinary buckler) to Chalcis. Five hundred Agrianians were
added, that every part of the island might be secured. He went himself
to Scotussa, and ordered the Macedonian soldiers to be removed thither
from Larissa. Here he heard that the Aetolians had been summoned to an
assembly at Heraclea, and that king Attalus was to come and advise with
them as to the conduct of the war. Determining to interrupt this meeting
by his sudden approach, he led his troops by forced marches to Heraclea,
where he arrived just after the assembly had broken up. However, he destroyed
the crops, which were nearly ripe, particularly those round the Aenian
bay. He then marched back to Scotussa, and leaving there the main army,
retired to Demetrias with the royal guards. In order to be prepared against
every attempt of the enemy, he sent persons hence to Phocis, Euboea, and
Peparethus, to select elevated situations, from which fires lighted upon
them might be seen from a distance. He fixed a watch-tower on Tisaeum,
a mountain whose summit is prodigiously high, in order that when the enemy
made any attempt he might instantly receive intimation of it by means of
fires lighted up at a distance. The Roman general and king Attalus then
passed over from Peparethus to Nicaea, and thence sailed to Orcus, the
first city of Euboea, on the left as you proceed to Chalcis and the Euripus
from the bay of Demetrias. It was agreed upon between Attalus and Sulpicius,
that the Romans should attack the town on the side next the sea, and the
king's forces on the land side.
6. Four days after the fleet arrived, they attacked the city. That time had been employed in private conferences with Plator, whom Philip had put in command of the place. The city has two citadels, one overhanging the coasts, the other in the middle of the town, from which there is a subterraneous passage to the ocean, whose entrance next the sea is defended by a strong fortification, a tower five stories high. Here the affair commenced with a most furious contest, the tower being furnished with all kinds of weapons, and engines and machines of every kind for the purpose of the assault having been landed from the ships. While the eyes and attention of all were turned to that quarter, Plator opened one of the gates and received the Romans into the citadel next the sea, which they instantly became masters of. The inhabitants, driven thence, fled to the other citadel in the middle of the city; but there had been troops posted there to shut the gates against them; so that, being thus excluded, they were surrounded and either slain or made prisoners. Meanwhile the Macedonian garrison stood under the wall of the citadel, formed into a compact body, neither confusedly attempting a retreat, nor obstinately engaging in a contest. These men Plator, after obtaining permission from Sulpicius, put on board ships and landed them at Demetrias in Phthiotis; he himself withdrew to Attalus. Sulpicius, elated with the success at Oreum, gained with so much ease, proceeded to Chalcis with his victorious fleet, where the issue by no means answered his expectations. The sea, which is wide on both sides, being here contracted into a narrow strait, might perhaps, at first view, exhibit the appearance of two harbors facing the two entrances of the Euripus. It would be difficult to find a station more dangerous for shipping; for not only do the winds come down with great violence from the high mountains on each side, but the strait itself of the Euripus does not ebb and flow seven times a day at stated times, as is reported, but the current changing irregularly, like the wind, now this way now that, is hurried along like a torrent rolling headlong down a steep mountain, so that no quiet is given to vessels there day or night. But not only did so perilous a station receive his ships, but the town was strong and impregnable, covered on one side by the sea, and very well fortified on the other towards the land, secured by a strong garrison, and above all, by the fidelity of the praefects and principal men, which was wavering and unsettled at Oreum. Though the business had been rashly undertaken, the Roman still acted with prudence, in so far as he speedily gave up the attempt, after he had seen all the difficulties which surrounded him, that he might not waste time, and passed his fleet over from thence to Cynus in Locris, the port of the town of Opus, which is one mile distant from the sea.
7. Philip had received notice of this from Oreum, by the signal fires;
but through the treachery of Plator they were raised from the watch-tower
at a later period. As he was not a match for the enemy's forces at sea,
it was difficult for him to approach the island; and thus, by delay, the
opportunity was lost. He moved with promptness to the assistance of Chalcis
as soon as he received the signal. For although Chalcis is a city of the
same island, yet it is separated from the continent by so narrow a strait,
that they communicate by means of a bridge, and the approach to it is easier
by land than by water. Philip therefore, going from Demetrias to Scotussa,
and setting out thence at the third watch, dislodged the guard, put to
flight the Aetolians who kept the pass of Thermopylae, and drove the enemy
in confusion to Heraclea, marching in one day to Elatia in Phocis, a distance
of above sixty miles. Almost on the same day the town of Opus was taken
and plundered by Attalus. Sulpicius had given it up to the king because
Oreum had been plundered a few days before by the Roman soldiers, the royal
soldiers not having shared the booty. The Roman fleet having retired thither,
Attalus, who was not aware of Philip's approach, wasted time in levying
contributions from the principal inhabitants, and so sudden was his coming,
that had he not been descried by some Cretans, who happened to go farther
from the town than usual in quest of forage, he might have been surprised.
He fled hastily to the sea and his ships, without arms, and in the greatest
disorder. Just as they were putting off from the land Philip arrived, and
even from the shore created much alarm among the mariners. He returned
thence to Opus, accusing both gods and men, because he had lost an opportunity
of so great importance, almost snatched from his hands. He also reproached
the Opuntians with the like anger, because they had, immediately on sight
of the enemy, made almost a voluntary surrender, though they might have
prolonged the siege till his arrival. Having settled affairs at Opus, he
proceeded thence to Thronium. Attalus, too, at first retired from Oreum;
but there receiving intelligence that Prusias, king of Bithynia, had invaded
his kingdom, he withdrew his attention from the Romans and the Aetolian
war, and passed over into Asia. Sulpicius also withdrew his fleet to Aegina,
from whence he had set out in the beginning of spring. Philip took Thronium
with as little difficulty as Attalus had at Opus. It was inhabited by foreigners,
fugitives from Thebes in Phthiotis, who, on the capture of their own town
by Philip, had fled to the protection of the Aetolians, and received from
them a city as a settlement which had been laid waste and desolated in
a former war by the same Philip. Having recovered Thronium, as has been
a little before mentioned, he set out thence; and having taken Tritonos
and Drymae, inconsiderable towns of Doris, he came thence to Elatia, where
he had ordered the ambassadors of Ptolemy and the Rhodians to wait for
him. While consulting there as to the best method of bringing the Aetolian
war to a conclusion, (for these ambassadors attended the late council of
the Romans and Aetolians at Heraclea,) intelligence is brought that Machanidas
intended to attack the Elians while busied in preparing for the celebration
of the Olympic games. Thinking it his duty to prevent such an attempt,
he dismissed the ambassadors with a gracious answer to the effect, that
he had neither caused the war, nor would he be any obstacle to the restoration
of peace, if it should be possible on equitable and honorable terms; then
marching quickly through Boeotia he came down from Megara, and thence to
Corinth, where receiving supplies of provisions, he went to Phlius and
Pheneus. And now, when he had proceeded as far as Heraea, having received
intelligence that Machanidas, terrified at the news of his approach, had
retreated to Lacedaemon, he betook himself to Aegium, where the Achaeans
were assembled in council, expecting at the same time to meet there a Carthaginian
fleet, which he had sent for, in order that he might accomplish something
by sea. But the Carthaginians had left a few days before, and were gone
to the Oxean islands; and thence, hearing that the Romans and Attalus had
left Oreum, to the harbors of the Acarnanians, for they feared that it
was intended to attack them, and that they would be overpowered while within
the straits of Rhium, which is the name of the entrance of the Corinthian
bay.
8. Philip was grieved and vexed when he reflected, that though he proceeded
with the utmost speed on all occasions, yet he had not come up in time
to accomplish any one object, and that fortune had frustrated his activity
by snatching away every advantage from before his eyes. In the assembly,
however, concealing his chagrin, he discoursed with elated spirits, calling
gods and men to witness, that "he had never been wanting at any time
or place, so as not to repair instantly wherever the enemy's arms resounded,
but that it was difficult to calculate whether the war was carried on more
boldly by him or more pusillanimously by the enemy. Such was the manner
in which Attalus had slipped out of his hands from Opus; Sulpicius from
Chalcis; and so, within these few days, Machanidas. That flight, however,
was not always successful; and that that should not be esteemed a difficult
war in which victory would be certain if the enemy could be brought to
a regular engagement. He had already obtained one very great advantage,
which was a confession on the part of the enemy themselves, that they were
not a match for him; and in a short time," he said, "he would
be in possession of undoubted victory; for that he would engage with him
with a result no better than their expectations." The allies listened
to the king with great satisfaction. He then gave up to the Achaeans Heraera
and Triphylia. Aliphera he restored to the Megalopolitans, they having
brought satisfactory proof that it belonged to their territories. Then
having received some ships from the Achaeans, three quadriremes and three
biremes, he sailed to Anticyra, whence with seven quinqueremes and more
than twenty barks, which he had sent to the bay of Corinth to join the
Carthaginian fleet, he proceeded to Erythrae, a town of the Aetolians near
Eupalium, where he made a descent. He was not unobserved by the Aetolians;
for all who were either in the fields or in the neighboring forts of Potidania
and Apollonia, fled to the woods and mountains. The cattle which they could
not drive off in their haste they seized and put on board. He sent Nicias,
praetor of the Achaeans, to Aegium with these and the other booty; and
then going to Corinth, ordered his army to march by land through Boeotia,
while he himself, sailing from Cenchreae along the coast of Attica, round
the promontory of Sunium, reached Chalcis, having passed almost through
the midst of the enemy's fleet. After commending in the highest terms their
fidelity and bravery, as neither fear nor hope had influenced their minds,
and after exhorting them to show the same fidelity in maintaining the alliance,
he sailed to Oreum; and having placed such of the chief inhabitants as
chose to fly, rather than surrender to the Romans, in the command of the
city and the direction of affairs, he sailed over from Euboea to Demetrias,
from which place he at first set out to succor his allies. After this,
having laid the keels of one hundred ships of war at Cassandrea, and collected
a large number of ship carpenters for the completion of that business,
and as both the departure of Attalus and the seasonable assistance he had
brought to his allies had tranquillized affairs in Greece, he retired into
his own dominions, in order to make war upon the Dardanians.
9. Just at the close of the summer during which these operations were carried
on in Greece, when Quintus Fabius, son of Maximus, ambassador from Marcus
Livius the consul, brought a message to Rome to the senate, to the effect,
that the consul considered that Lucius Portius with his legions formed
a sufficient protection for the province, that he might himself retire
thence, and that the consular army might be withdrawn, the fathers directed
that not only Livius should return to the city, but also his colleague,
Caius Claudius. The only difference made between them in the decree was,
that they ordered the army of Marcus Livius to be led back, and the legions
of Nero to remain in their province opposed to Hannibal. The consuls agreed
between themselves by letter, that as they had conducted the affairs of
the commonwealth with unanimity, they should arrive at the city at the
same time, though they came from different quarters. He who arrived first
at Praeneste was enjoined to wait there for his colleague. It so happened
that they both came to Praeneste on the same day, and thence, sending a
proclamation before them, directing that there should be a full attendance
of the senate at the temple of Bellona, three days after, they came up
to the city, when they were met by the whole body of the inhabitants. Not
only did the whole body pour around them and salute them, but each person
individually, desiring to touch the victorious right hands of the consuls,
some congratulated them, while others thanked them because by their services
the state had been preserved. In the senate, when, having made a recital
of their services according to the custom observed by all generals, they
had requested, that "in consideration of the brave and successful
conduct of the affairs of the commonwealth, honors should be paid to the
immortal gods, and they themselves enter the city in triumph;" the
fathers replied, that "they most willingly decreed those things which
they requested in gratitude to the gods in the first instance, and, next
to them, to the consuls." A supplication in the name of both, and
a triumph to both of them, having been decreed, lest after having carried
on the war with entire unanimity they should have a separate triumph, they
made the following agreement; that "since both the service had been
performed in the province of Marcus Livius, and he was in possession of
the command on the day on which the battle was fought, and further, that
as the army of Livius had been withdrawn and had come to Rome, while Nero's
could not be withdrawn from the province, Marcus Livius should enter the
city in a four-horse chariot and followed by the soldiers; Caius Claudius
on horseback without soldiers." This plan of associating the generals
in the triumph increased the glory of both, but particularly of him who
had yielded to his colleague in the honors he received, as much as he surpassed
him in merit. The people said, that "the general on horseback had
traversed the whole length of Italy in the space of six days, and had fought
a pitched battle with Hasdrubal in Gaul, on the very day on which Hannibal
supposed that he was occupying a camp pitched in Apulia to oppose him.
That thus one consul, acting in defense of either extremity of Italy against
two leaders, had opposed against one his skill, against the other his person.
That the name of Nero had been sufficient to confine Hannibal within his
camp, while with regard to Hasdrubal, by what, but his arrival, had he
been overwhelmed and annihilated? The other consul might move along raised
aloft in a chariot, drawn if he pleased by a number of horses, but that
the real triumph was his who was conveyed by one horse; and that Nero,
though he should go on foot, would be immortalized, whether on account
of the glory he had acquired in the war, or the contempt he had shown for
it in the triumph." Such continual expressions of the spectators attended
Nero all the way to the Capitol. The money they brought into the treasury
was three hundred thousand sesterces, with eighty thousand asses of brass.
Marcus Livius distributed among the soldiers fifty-six asses each. Caius
Claudius promised the same sum to his absent troops when he returned to
the army. It was observed that more verses were written by the soldiery
upon Caius Claudius in their jocular style, than upon their own consul;
that the horsemen highly extolled Lucius Veturius and Quintus Caecilius,
lieutenant-generals, and exhorted the commons to create them consuls for
the ensuing year; that the consuls added their authority to the recommendation
of the knights, relating in the public assembly the following day with
what courage and fidelity their two lieutenant-generals in particular had
served them.
10. When the time for the elections approached, and it was resolved that
it should be held by a dictator, the consul Caius Claudius nominated as
dictator his colleague Marcus Livius, who appointed Quintus Caecilius his
master of the horse. Lucius Veturius and Quintus Caecilius were created
consuls by Marcus Livius the dictator, the latter being then master of
the horse. After this the election of praetors was held. The persons appointed
were, Caius Servilius, Marcus Caecilius Metellus, Titus Claudius Asellus,
and Quintus Mamilius Turinus, who was at that time plebeian aedile. When
the elections were finished, the dictator, having abdicated his office
and dismissed his army, set out for his province of Etruria, according
to a decree of the senate, to make inquiry what states of the Tuscans and
Umbrians had formed schemes of revolt from the Romans to Hasdrubal at the
time of his approach, and what states had assisted him with auxiliaries,
provisions, or succors of any kind. Such were the transactions this year
at home and abroad. The Roman games were thrice repeated in full by the
curule aediles, Cneius Servilius Caepio and Servius Cornelius Lentulus.
In the same manner the plebeian games also were once repeated entire by
the plebeian aediles, Manius Pomponius Matho and Quintus Mamilius Thurinus.
In the thirteenth year of the Punic war, when Lucius Veturius Philo
and Quintus Caecilius Metellus were consuls, Bruttium was assigned to
both of them, as their province, to carry on the war with Hannibal.
The praetors then cast lots for their provinces: Marcus Caecilius
Metellus had the city jurisdiction; Quintus Mamilius, the foreign;
Caius Servilius, Sicily; Tiberius Claudius, Sardinia. The armies were
distributed thus: to one of the consuls was given the army which
Caius Claudius the consul of the former year, to the other that which
Quintus Claudius the propraetor, had commanded, consisting of two
legions each. It was decreed that Marcus Livius, proconsul, who was
continued in command for the year, should take the two legions of
volunteer slaves from Caius Terentius the propraetor, and that Quintus
Mamilius, transferring his judicial business to his colleague, should
occupy Gaul with the army which Lucius Porcius, the praetor, had
commanded, with orders to lay waste the lands of those Gauls who
had revolted to the Carthaginians on the approach of Hasdrubal. The
protection of Sicily was assigned to Caius Servilius with the two
legions which fought at Cannae, in the same manner as Caius Mamilius
had held it. The old army which Aulus Hostilius had commanded was
conveyed out of Sardinia, and the consuls enlisted a new legion, which
Tiberius Claudius might take over with him. Quintus Claudius and
Caius Hostilius Tubulus were continued in command for a year, that the
former might hold Tarentum as his province, the latter, Capua. Marcus
Valerius, the proconsul, to whom had been committed the protection
of the sea-coast round Sicily, was ordered to deliver thirty ships
to Caius Servilius, and return to the city with all the rest of the
fleet.
11. In a state where the greatest anxiety prevailed, in consequence of
the very critical situation in which the war stood, and where all events,
prosperous or adverse, were attributed to the interposition of the gods,
accounts of many prodigies were received; that the temple of Jupiter at
Tarracina, and that of Mater Matuta at Satricum, had been struck by lightning.
The people of Satricum were no less terrified by two snakes gliding into
the temple of Jupiter by the very doors. A report was brought from Antium,
that bloody ears of corn had been seen by the reapers. At Caere a pig with
two heads had been littered, and a lamb born which was both male and female.
Intelligence was brought that two suns had been seen at Alba, and that
light had suddenly appeared during night at Fregellae. An ox was reported
to have spoken in the Roman territory. A copious perspiration was said
to have exuded from the altar of Neptune, in the Flaminian circus; and
the temples of Ceres, Safety, and Quirinus were said to have been struck
by lightning. The consuls were directed to expiate these prodigies with
victims of the larger sort, and to make a supplication for one day. These
things were executed according to a decree of the senate. The extinction
of the fire in the temple of Vesta struck more terror upon the minds of
men than all the prodigies which were reported from abroad, or seen at
home; and the vestal, who had the guarding of it for that night, was scourged
by the command of Publius Licinius the pontiff. Although this event was
not appointed by the gods as a portent, but had happened through human
neglect, yet it was thought proper that it should be expiated with victims
of the larger sort, and that a supplication should be made at the temple
of Vesta.
Before the consuls set out for the campaign, they were cautioned by the
senate to take care that the common people should be brought back into
the country; for since, through the goodness of the gods, the war was removed
from the city of Rome and Latium, the country might be inhabited without
fear. That it was most inconsistent that greater care should be taken in
cultivating Sicily than Italy. But it was a matter by no means easy for
the people, the free laborers having been cut off by war, and there being
a scarcity of slaves, their cattle having been carried off as booty, and
the farmhouses pulled down or burnt. A large number, however, compelled
by the authority of the consuls, returned into the country. The mention
of this affair had been occasioned by ambassadors of Placentia and Cremona,
who complained that their lands were being invaded and laid waste by the
neighboring Gauls; that a large portion of their settlers had dispersed;
that their cities were thinly inhabited, and their lands devastated and
deserted. Mamilius the praetor was charged with the protection of the colonies
from the enemy. The consuls, in conformity with a decree of the senate,
issued an edict that all who were citizens of Cremona and Placentia should
return to those colonies before a certain day; after which, in the beginning
of spring, they set out for the campaign. Quintus Caecilius, the consul,
received the army from Caius Nero; Lucius Veturius received his from Quintus
Claudius the propraetor, filling it up with new-raised soldiers, whom he
had himself enlisted. The consuls marched their army into the territory
of Consentia, and devastating the country on all hands, when the troops
were loaded with plunder, they were thrown into such confusion by some
Bruttians and Numidian spearmen, who attacked them in a narrow defile,
that not only the booty but the troops were in danger. There was more of
confusion, however than fighting; and sending the booty in advance, the
legions themselves also escaped into a place free from danger. Proceeding
thence into Lucania, the whole of that people returned, without a contest,
into subjection to the Roman people.
12. No action with Hannibal took place this year; for neither did he present himself after the public and personal calamity so recently inflicted, and the Romans did not provoke him while he remained quiet, such power did they consider that single general possessed, though every thing else around him was falling into ruin. Indeed I know not whether he was not more deserving of admiration in adversity than in prosperity; inasmuch as though he carried on a war in the territory of enemies through a period of thirteen years, at so great a distance from home, with varying success, and with, an army not composed of his own countrymen, but made up of the offscouring of all nations, without communion of laws, customs, or language, different in their appearance, their dress, their arms, their religious ceremonies and observances, and I had almost said, their gods; yet he so effectually united them by some one bond, that no disturbance ever arose either among the soldiers themselves, or between them and their general, though he often wanted money to pay them, and provisions, as being in a hostile country, through want of which, in the former Punic war, many dreadful transactions had occurred between the generals and their soldiers. But after the destruction of Hasdrubal and his army, in which all hopes of victory had been treasured up; and after retiring from the possession of every other part of Italy by withdrawing into Bruttium, one corner of it; to whom does it not appear wonderful that no disturbance arose in the camp? For to other circumstances this also was added, that he had no hope of subsisting his army, except from the lands of Bruttium, which, though they were all cultivated, would be very insufficient for the maintenance of so large an army. Besides, many of the youth were drawn off from the cultivation of the fields, and engaged in the war; and a custom also prevailed among the people of that nation, grafted on a naturally depraved inclination, of carrying on a predatory kind of warfare. Nor did he receive any supplies from home, where they were anxious about the retention of Spain, as if every thing was going on prosperously in Italy. In Spain the state of affairs was in one respect similar, but in another widely different; similar in that the Carthaginians, having been defeated with the loss of their general, had been driven to the remotest coast of that country, even to the ocean; but different, because Spain, both from the nature of the country and the genius of its inhabitants, was better adapted not only than Italy, but than any other part of the world, for renewing a war. And accordingly, therefore, though this was the first of the provinces on the continent which the Romans entered, it was the last which was at length reduced, in the present age, under the conduct and auspices of Augustus Caesar. Here Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, the greatest and most renowned general concerned in the war, next to the Barcine family, returning from Gades, and encouraged in his hopes of reviving the war by Mago, son of Hamilcar, by means of levies made throughout the Farther Spain, armed as many as fifty thousand foot and four thousand five hundred horse. With regard to his mounted force, authors are pretty much agreed, but some state that seventy thousand infantry were led to the city Silpia. Here the two Carthaginian generals sat down on open plains, with a determination not to avoid a battle.
13. When Scipio received an account of the collection of so large an
army, he felt convinced that he would not be a match for so great a
multitude with the Roman legions only, without making a show at least
of the auxiliary troops of the barbarians; at the same time that he
did not think it right that they should form so large a portion of
his force as to occasion important consequences if they should
change sides, which had brought ruin upon his father and his uncle.
Therefore, sending forward Silanus to Colca, who was sovereign of
twenty-eight towns, to receive from him the infantry and cavalry,
which he promised to enlist during the winter, he himself set out from
Tarraco; and collecting small bodies of auxiliaries from his allies,
who lay near his road as he proceeded, he came to Castulo. To this
place Silanus led the auxiliaries, consisting of three thousand
infantry and five hundred horse. Thence he advanced to the city of
Baecula, with his entire army of countrymen and allies, foot and
horse, amounting to forty-five thousand. Mago and Masinissa attacked
them with the whole body of their cavalry while forming their camp,
and would have dispersed those engaged in the works, had not a party
of horse, concealed by Scipio behind an eminence conveniently situated
for the purpose, unexpectedly charged them when rushing on to the
attack, and, ere the battle was well begun, routed all the most
forward, both those who had advanced nearest the rampart, and those
who were foremost in charging the very workmen. With the rest of the
troops who came up with their standards, and in order of march, the
contest lasted longer, and was for a considerable time doubtful. But
when first the light cohorts from the outposts, and then the troops
withdrawn from the works and ordered to take arms, came up, being more
numerous than those which had been engaged, and fresh while they were
fatigued, and now a large body of armed troops rushed from the camp
to the battle, the Carthaginians and Numidians at once turned their
backs. At first they moved off in troops without breaking their ranks,
through fear or precipitation; but afterwards, when the Romans pressed
furiously upon their rear, and they were unable to bear the violence
of their attack, then at length, utterly regardless of order,
they fled precipitately in every direction, as suited each man's
convenience. And although, in consequence of this battle, the spirits
of the Romans were considerably raised, and those of the enemy
depressed, yet, for several days following, the horsemen and
light-armed troops never ceased from skirmishes.
14. After having made sufficient trial of their strength in these slight
engagements, Hasdrubal first led out his forces for battle, and then the
Romans also advanced. But both the armies stood drawn up before their ramparts;
and as neither party began the attack, and the sun was now going down,
the Carthaginian first, and then the Roman, led back his troops into the
camp. The same occurred for several days. The Carthaginian was always the
first to lead out his troops into the field, and the first to give the
signal for retiring, when they were weary with standing. Neither party
sallied from their posts, nor was a weapon discharged, or a word uttered.
On one side the Romans occupied the center, on the other, the Carthaginians
and Africans together; the allies occupied the wings, which were composed
of Spaniards on both sides. The elephants which stood before the Carthaginian
line, appeared at a distance like castles. It was now commonly talked of
in both camps, that they would fight in the order in which they had stood
when drawn up, and that their centers, composed of Romans and Carthaginians,
who were the principals in the war, would engage with equal courage and
strength. When Scipio perceived that this was firmly believed, he studiously
altered all his arrangements against the day on which he intended to fight.
He issued orders through the camp at evening, that the men and horses should
be refreshed and fed before daylight, and that the horsemen, armed themselves,
should keep their horses bridled and saddled. When it was scarcely yet
daylight, he sent all his cavalry, with the light troops, against the Carthaginian
outposts, and then without delay advanced himself, at the head of the heavy
body of the legions, having strengthened his wings with Roman soldiers,
and placed the allies in the center, contrary to the full anticipations
of his own men and of the enemy. Hasdrubal, alarmed by the shout of the
cavalry, sprang out of his tent, and, perceiving a tumult before the rampart,
and his own troops in a state of hurry and confusion, the standards of
the legions gleaming at a distance, and the plain filled with the enemy,
immediately sent out the whole body of his cavalry against the horsemen
of the enemy; marching himself out of the camp, at the head of the infantry,
without departing at all from the usual arrangement in forming his line.
The battle between the cavalry had continued for a long time doubtful;
nor could they decide it themselves, because, when repulsed, which was
the case in a manner alternately, they had a safe retreat upon the line
of infantry. But when the armies were not more than five hundred paces
distant from each other, Scipio, sounding a retreat and opening his files,
received into the midst of them the whole body of his cavalry and light-armed
troops; and dividing them into two parts, placed them in reserve behind
the wings. After this, when it was now time to commence the battle, he
ordered the Spaniards, who formed the center, to advance at a slow pace;
he himself sent a messenger from the right wing, for that he commanded,
to Silanus and Marcius to extend the wing on the left in the same manner
as they should see him extend that on the right, and engage the enemy with
the light-armed of the horse and foot, before the two centers could meet.
The wings being thus extended, they advanced against the enemy at a rapid
pace, with three cohorts of infantry, and three troops of horse, each with
the addition of skirmishers, the rest following them in an oblique line.
There was a depression in the center of the line, because the battalions
of the Spaniards advanced slower than the rest, and the wings had already
encountered the enemy, when the veteran Carthaginians and Africans had
not yet come within distance to discharge their darts; nor dared they run
in different directions to the wings to assist them when fighting, lest
they should expose their center to the enemy approaching over against them.
The wings were hard pressed, by a twofold attack; the cavalry, the light-armed,
and the skirmishers, wheeling round, charged their flanks, while the cohorts
pressed them hard in front, in order to separate the wings from the rest
of the line.
15. The battle was now extremely unequal in every part, both because an
irregular band of Balearians and raw Spaniards were opposed to Roman and
Latin soldiers, and further, because, as the day was now getting on, Hasdrubal's
troops began to grow languid, having been dispirited by the alarm in the
morning, and compelled to go out hastily into the field, without refreshing
themselves with food. Scipio had designedly spun out the day, in order
that the battle might take place at a late hour; for it was not until the
seventh hour that the battalions of infantry charged the wings. It was
considerably later before the battle reached the centers, so that the heat
from the meridian sun, and the fatigue of standing under arms, together
with hunger and thirst, enfeebled their bodies before they engaged the
enemy. Thus they stood still, supporting themselves upon their shields.
In addition to their other misfortunes, the elephants too, terrified at
the tumultuous kind of attack of the cavalry, the skirmishers, and the
light-armed, had transferred themselves from the wings to the center. Fatigued
therefore in mind and body, they gave ground, preserving their ranks, however,
just as though the army were retreating entire at the command of their
general. But when the victors, perceiving that the enemy had given way,
charged them on all sides with increased vehemence on that very account,
so that the shock could hardly be sustained, though Hasdrubal endeavoured
to stop them and hinder them from retiring, vociferating, "that there
were hills on their rear, and a safe refuge if they would retreat without
precipitation;" yet, fear getting the better of their sense of shame,
and all those who were nearest the enemy giving way, they immediately turned
their backs, and all gave themselves up to disorderly flight. The first
place they halted at was the foot of the hills, where they endeavoured
to recall the soldiers to their ranks, the Romans hesitating to advance
their line up the opposite steep; but afterwards, when they saw them push
on briskly, renewing their flight, they were driven into their camp in
extreme alarm. Nor were the Romans far from the rampart; and such was their
impetuosity, that they would have taken their camp had not so violent a
shower of rain suddenly poured down, while, as is usually the case, the
solar rays darted with the greatest intensity between the clouds surcharged
with water, that the victors with difficulty returned to their camp. Some
were even deterred, by superstition, from making any further attempts that
day. Though night and the rain invited the Carthaginians to take necessary
rest, yet, as their fears and the danger would not allow them to delay,
as it was expected that the enemy would assault their camp as soon as it
was light, they raised their rampart by stones collected from the neighboring
valleys around them on all sides, with the determination to defend themselves
by works, since there was but little protection in their arms. But the
desertion of their allies made it appear safer to fly than stay. Attanes,
prince of the Turdetani, began this revolt; he deserted at the head of
a numerous band of his countrymen. Then two fortified towns, together with
their garrisons, were delivered up by their praefects to the Romans. And,
lest the evil should spread more widely, now that the disposition to revolt
from the Carthaginians had evinced itself in one instance, Hasdrubal decamped
during the silence of the ensuing night.
16. The troops in the outposts having brought word, as soon as it was light,
that the enemy had departed, Scipio, dispatching his cavalry in advance,
ordered the army to move forward; and so rapidly were they led, that had
they directly followed the track of the fugitives, they would certainly
have overtaken them; but they trusted to the report of their guides, that
there was a shorter cut to the river Baetis, where they might attack them
while crossing it. Hasdrubal, being precluded from passing the river, turned
his course to the ocean; and they now advanced in disorder and in the manner
of fugitives, so that the Roman legions were left considerably behind.
The cavalry and light-armed, attacking sometimes their rear, and sometimes
their flank, harassed and delayed them; and as they were obliged to halt,
in consequence of these frequent annoyances, and engaged sometimes the
cavalry, at other times the skirmishers and the auxiliary infantry, the
legions came up. After this it was no longer a fight, but a butchering
as of cattle, till the general himself, who was the first to run away,
made his escape to the neighboring hills with about six thousand men half
armed; the rest were slain or made prisoners. The Carthaginians hastily
fortified an irregular camp on the highest eminence, and from thence they
defended themselves without difficulty, the enemy failing in his attempt
to get at them, from the difficulty of the ascent. But a siege in a place
bare and affording no means of subsistence, was hardly to be supported,
even for a few days; the troops therefore deserted to the enemy. At last
the general himself, having procured some ships, for the sea was not at
a great distance, left his army by night and effected his escape to Gades.
Scipio, having heard of the flight of the general of the enemy, left ten
thousand foot and one thousand cavalry for Silanus to carry on the siege
of the camp, and returned to Tarraco with the rest of the troops, after
a march of seventy days, during which he took cognizance of the causes
of the petty princes and states, in order that rewards might be conferred
according to a just estimate of their merits. After his departure, Masinissa,
having held a private conference with Silanus, passed over into Africa
with a few of his countrymen, in order that he might induce his nation
also to acquiesce in his new designs. The cause of this sudden change was
not so evident at the time, as the proof was convincing which was afforded
by his subsequent fidelity, preserved to extreme old age, that he did not
on this occasion act without reasonable grounds. Mago went to Gades in
the ships which had been sent back by Hasdrubal. Of the rest of the troops
thus abandoned by their generals, some deserted and others betook themselves
to flight, and in this manner were dispersed through the neighboring states.
There was no body of them considerable either for numbers or strength.
Such were, as near as possible, the circumstances under which the Carthaginians
were driven out of Spain, under the conduct and auspices of Publius Scipio,
in the thirteenth year from the commencement of the war, and the fifth
from the time that Publius Scipio received the province and the army. Not
long after, Silanus returned to Tarraco to Scipio, with information that
the war was at an end.
17. Lucius Scipio was sent to Rome to convey the news of the reduction
of Spain, and with him a number of distinguished captives. While everybody
else extolled this achievement as an event in the highest degree joyful
and glorious, yet the author of it alone, whose valor was such that he
never thought he had achieved enough, and whose search for true glory was
insatiable, considered the reduction of Spain as affording but a faint
idea of the hopes which his aspiring mind had conceived. He now directed
his view to Africa and Great Carthage, and the glorious termination of
the war, as redounding to his honor, and giving luster to his name. Judging
it therefore to be now necessary to pave the way to his object, and to
conciliate the friendship of kings and nations, he resolved first to sound
the disposition of Syphax, king of the Masaesylians, a nation bordering
on the Moors, and lying for the most part over-against that quarter of
Spain in which New Carthage is situated. The king was at the present juncture
in league with the Carthaginians; and Scipio, concluding that he would
not hold it as more binding and sacred than was customary with barbarians,
sent Caius Laelius as envoy to him with presents. The barbarian, delighted
with these, and seeing that the Roman cause was then successful in every
quarter, but that the Carthaginians were unfortunate in Italy, and no longer
existed in Spain, consented to accept the friendship of the Romans, but
refused to give or receive a solemn ratification of it except the Roman
general himself were present in person. This being the case, Laelius returned
to Scipio, having received from the king merely an assurance of a safe
journey. To one desirous of getting a footing in Africa, Syphax was of
great importance, as he was the most powerful king in that country, had
already had experience of the Carthaginians themselves in war, and the
boundaries of his dominions lay very conveniently with respect to Spain,
from which they are separated by a narrow strait. Scipio, therefore, considering
it an object of sufficient importance to warrant his attempting it, notwithstanding
the greatness of the danger which attended it, since he could not effect
it otherwise, left for the protection of Spain Lucius Marcius at Tarraco,
and Marcus Silanus at New Carthage, to which place he had gone on foot
by long marches; and setting out himself in company with Caius Laelius,
with two quinqueremes from Carthage, passed over into Africa, working the
vessels with oars for the greatest part of the voyage, in consequence of
the calmness of the sea, though sometimes they were assisted by a gentle
breeze. It so happened, that just at that time Hasdrubal, having been driven
out of Spain, had entered the harbor with seven triremes, and having cast
anchor was mooring his ships. The sight of two quinqueremes, which it was
the firm opinion of everybody belonged to the enemy, and might be overpowered
by superior numbers before they entered the harbor, produced no other effect
than a tumult and confusion among the soldiers and sailors, who endeavoured
to no purpose to get their arms and ships ready; for their sails, impelled
by a somewhat brisker gale from the sea, brought the quinqueremes into
the harbor before the Carthaginians weighed their anchors, and no one dared
make any further stir now that they were in the king's harbor. Thus Hasdrubal,
who landed first, and Scipio and Laelius, who landed soon after, proceeded
to the king.
18. Syphax considered it highly honorable to him, as it really was, that
generals of the two most powerful people of the age should come to him
on the same day to solicit peace and friendship with him. He invited them
both to become his guests; and, as it was the will of fortune that they
should be under one roof, and under the protection of the same household
gods, he endeavoured to bring them together to a conference, in order to
put an end to the difference between them; when Scipio declared, that there
was no personal enmity between the Carthaginian and himself which he might
do away with by a conference, and that he could not transact any business
relating to the republic with an enemy without the command of the senate.
But the king being earnest in his endeavors to persuade him to come to
the same entertainment, lest one of his guests should appear to be excluded,
he did not withhold his assent. They supped together at the king's table,
and Scipio and Hasdrubal even sat at meat on the same couch, because it
was the king's pleasure. So courteous was the manner of Scipio, so naturally
happy and universal was his genius, that by his conversation he gained
the esteem not only of Syphax, a barbarian, and unused to Roman manners,
but even of a most inveterate enemy, who openly avowed, that "he appeared
to him more to be admired for the qualities he displayed on a personal
interview with him, than for his exploits in war, and that he had no doubt
that Syphax and his kingdom were already at the disposal of the Romans,
such were the abilities that man possessed for gaining the esteem of others.
That it, therefore, was incumbent upon the Carthaginians not more to inquire
by what means they had lost Spain, than to consider how they might retain
possession of Africa. That it was not from a desire to visit foreign countries,
or to roam about delightful coasts, that so great a Roman captain, leaving
a recently subdued province, and his armies, had crossed over into Africa
with only two ships, entering an enemy's territory, and committing himself
to the untried honor of the king, but in pursuance of a hope he had conceived
of subduing Africa. That it had been long the object of his anxious solicitude,
and had drawn from him open expressions of his indignation, that Scipio
was not carrying on war in Africa in the same way as Hannibal was in Italy."
Scipio, having formed a league with Syphax, set out from Africa, and, after
having been tossed about during his voyage by variable and generally tempestuous
winds, made the port of New Carthage on the fourth day.
19. As Spain was undisturbed by a Carthaginian war, so it was evident that
some of the states remained quiet more from fear, arising from a consciousness
of demerit, than from sincere attachment. The most remarkable of them,
both for their greatness and guilt, were Illiturgi and Castulo. Castulo
had been in alliance with the Romans when in prosperity, but had revolted
to the Carthaginians after the destruction of the Scipios and their armies.
The Illiturgians, by betraying and putting to death those who fled thither
after that calamity, had added villainy to revolt. It would have been more
deserved than expedient to have executed severe vengeance upon these people
on his first arrival, while the affairs of Spain were in an uncertain state;
but now, when all was tranquil, as the time for visiting them with punishment
appeared to have arrived, he summoned Lucius Marcius from Tarraco, and
sent him with a third of his forces to attack Castulo, and with the rest
of the army he himself reached Illiturgi, after about five days' march.
The gates were closed, and every arrangement and preparation made for repelling
an attack; so completely had the consciousness of what they deserved produced
the same effect as a declaration of war against them. From this circumstance
Scipio commenced his exhortation to his soldiers: he said, that "by
closing their gates the Spaniards had themselves shown what their deserts
were by what they feared, and that therefore they ought to prosecute the
war against them with much greater animosity than against the Carthaginians.
For with the latter the contest was carried on for empire and glory almost
without any exasperated feeling, while they had to punish the former for
perfidy, cruelty, and villainy. That the time had now arrived when they
should take vengeance for the horrid massacre of their fellow soldiers,
and for the treachery which was prepared for themselves, had they been
carried in their flight to the same place; and by the severity of the punishment
inflicted in the present instance, establish it as a law for ever, that
no one should consider a Roman citizen and soldier, whatever his situation,
a fit object for injurious treatment." Animated by this exhortation
of their general, they distributed the scaling-ladders to men selected
from each of the companies; and the army being divided into two parts,
so that Laelius, as lieutenant-general, might command one, they attacked
the city in two places at once; thus creating an alarm in two quarters
at the same time. It was not by the exhortations of one general, nor of
the several nobles who were present, that the townsmen were stimulated
to a vigorous defense of the city, but by the fear which they themselves
entertained; they bore in mind, and admonished each other, that the object
aimed at was punishment, and not victory. That the only question for them
was, where they should meet death, whether in the battle and in the field,
where the indiscriminate chance of war frequently raised up the vanquished
and dashed the victor to the ground; or whether, after a short interval,
when the city was burnt and plundered, after suffering every horror and
indignity, they should expire amid stripes and bonds before the eyes of
their captive wives and children. Therefore, not only those who were of
an age to bear arms, or men only, but women and children, beyond the powers
of their minds and bodies, were there, supplying with weapons those who
were fighting in defense of the place, and carrying stones to the walls
for those who were strengthening the works; for not only was their liberty
at stake, which excites the energies of the brave only, but they had before
their eyes the utmost extremity of punishment, to be inflicted on all indiscriminately,
and an ignominious death. Their minds were worked up to the highest pitch,
both by emulation in toil and danger, and also by the mere sight of each
other. Accordingly the contest was entered upon with such ardor, that the
army which had subdued the whole of Spain was frequently driven back from
the walls of one town, and exhibited such a want of resolution in the contest
as was not very honorable to it. When Scipio perceived this, he was afraid
lest, by the failure of his attempts, the courage of the enemy should be
raised and his own troops be dispirited; and thinking it incumbent upon
him to exert himself in person and share the danger, reproved his soldiers
for their cowardice, and ordered the scaling-ladders to be brought, threatening
to mount the wall himself, since the rest hesitated. He had now advanced
near the walls with no small danger, when a shout was raised from all sides
by the soldiers, who were alarmed at the danger their general was exposed
to, and the scaling-ladders began to be reared in several places at once.
Laelius too, in another quarter, pressed on vigorously. It was then that
the energy of the townsmen was subdued, and those who defended the walls
being beaten off, the Romans took possession of them. The citadel also
was captured during the confusion on a side where it was thought impregnable.
20. Some African deserters, who were at that time among the Roman
auxiliaries, while the townsmen were occupied in defending those
quarters whence danger was apprehended, and the Romans were making
approaches where they could gain access, observed that the most
elevated part of the town, which was protected by a very high rock,
was neither fortified by any work nor furnished with defenders. Being
men of light make and nimble from being well exercised, they climbed
up wherever they could gain access over the irregular projections of
the rock, carrying with them iron spikes. If in any part they met with
a cliff too steep and smooth, they fixed spikes at moderate intervals,
and having thus formed a sort of steps, and those who were foremost
pulling up those who followed, and those who were behind lifting up
those before them, they succeeded in gaining the summit, whence they
ran down with a shout into the city, which had already been taken by
the Romans. Then it became manifest indeed that it was resentment and
hatred which prompted the assault upon the city. No one thought of
taking any alive, nor of booty, though every thing lay exposed to
plunder. They butchered all indiscriminately, armed and unarmed,
male and female. Their cruel resentment extended to the slaughter of
infants. They then set fire to the houses, and pulled down those which
could not be consumed by fire, so bent were they upon erasing even
every vestige of the city, and blotting out the memory of their
enemies. Scipio marched his army thence to Castulo, which was
defended, not only by Spaniards who had assembled there, but also by
the remains of the Carthaginian army, which had gone there from the
various places to which they had been dispersed in their flight. But
the news of the calamity of the Illiturgians had reached them
before the arrival of Scipio; and in consequence of this, dismay
and desperation had seized them; and as their cases were differently
circumstanced, and each party was desirous of consulting its own
safety independent of the other, at first secret jealousy, and then
an open rupture, created a separation between the Carthaginians
and Spaniards. Cerdubellus without disguise advised the latter to
surrender. Himilco commanded the Carthaginian auxiliaries, which,
together with the city, Cerdubellus delivered up to the Romans, having
secretly obtained terms. This victory was attended with less cruelty;
for not only was the guilt of this people less than the others, but
their voluntary surrender had considerably mitigated resentment.
21. Marcius was then sent against the barbarians, to reduce under the
authority and dominion of the Romans such of them as had not yet been
subdued. Scipio returned to Carthage, to pay his vows to the gods, and
to exhibit a gladiatorial show, which he had prepared on account of
the death of his father and uncle. This exhibition of gladiators
was not formed from that description of men which the lanistae are
accustomed to procure, such as slaves, or those who sell their blood.
All the service of the combatants was voluntary and gratuitous; for
some were sent by the petty princes, to show an example of the natural
courage of their people; others came forward to fight, in compliment
to their general; others were induced to give and accept challenges,
by a spirit of emulation and a desire of victory. Some decided by
the sword disputes which they either could not or were unwilling to
determine by argument, with an agreement that the matter in question
should be given up to the victor. Nor was it confined to men of
obscure rank, but comprehended persons of distinction and celebrity;
such were Corbis and Orsua, cousins-german, who, having a dispute
about the sovereignty of a city called Ibis, declared that they would
contest it with the sword. Corbis was the elder of the two. The father
of Orsua was the last sovereign, having succeeded to that dignity on
the death of his elder brother. When Scipio was desirous of settling
the dispute by argument and allaying their irritation, they both
declared that they had refused that to their mutual kinsmen, and that
they would appeal to no other judge, whether god or man, than Mars.
The elder presuming upon his strength, the younger on the prime of
youth, each wished to die in the combat rather than become the subject
of the other; and every effort failing to prevent their prosecuting
their mad design, they exhibited to the army a most interesting
spectacle, and a proof how great mischief is occasioned among men by a
thirst for power. The elder, in consequence of his experience in
arms and his address, easily mastered the unscientific efforts of
the younger. To this show of gladiators were added funeral games,
proportioned to the means possessed, and with such magnificence as the
provinces and the camp afforded.
22. Meanwhile the operations of the war were carried on with unabated activity
by the lieutenant-generals. Marcius, crossing the river Baetis, which the
natives call Certis, received the submission of two powerful cities without
a contest. There was a city called Astapa, which had always sided with
the Carthaginians; nor was it that which drew upon it the resentment of
the Romans so much as the fact, that its inhabitants harbored an extraordinary
animosity against them, which was not called for by the necessities of
the war. Their city was not so secured by nature or art as to make their
dispositions so fierce, but the natural disposition of the inhabitants,
which took delight in plunder, had induced them to make excursions into
the neighboring lands belonging to the allies of the Romans, and to intercept
such Roman soldiers, suttlers, and merchants as they found ranging about.
They had also surrounded, by means of an ambuscade, and put to the sword
on disadvantageous ground, a large company which was crossing their borders,
for it had proved hardly safe to go in small parties. When the troops were
marched up to assault this city, the inhabitants, conscious of their guilt,
and seeing that it would be dangerous to surrender to an enemy so highly
incensed, and that they could not hope to keep themselves in safety by
means of their walls or their arms, resolved to execute upon themselves
and those belonging to them a horrid and inhuman deed. They fixed upon
a place in their forum, in which they collected the most valuable of their
property, and having directed their wives and children to seat themselves
upon this heap, they raised a pile of wood around it and threw on it bundles
of twigs. They then ordered fifty armed youths to stand there and guard
their fortunes, and the persons dearer to them than their fortunes, as
long as the issue of the battle continued doubtful. If they should perceive
that the battle went against them, and that it came to the point that the
city must be captured, they might be assured that those whom they saw going
out to engage the enemy would perish in the battle itself; but implored
them by all the gods, celestial and infernal, that, mindful of their liberty,
which must be terminated on that day either by an honorable death or ignominious
servitude, they would leave nothing on which an exasperated enemy could
wreak his fury; that they had fire and sword at their command, and it was
better that friendly and faithful hands should destroy what must necessarily
perish, than that enemies should insult it with haughty wantonness. To
these exhortations a dreadful execration was added against any one who
should be diverted from this purpose by hope or faint-heartedness. Then
throwing open the gates, they rushed out at a rapid pace and with the utmost
impetuosity. Nor was there any guard sufficiently strong opposed to them;
for there could be nothing that was less apprehended than that they would
have the courage to sally from their walls. A very few troops of horse,
and the light-armed, hastily sent out of the camp for that purpose, opposed
them. The battle was furious and spirited, rather than steady and regular
in any degree. The horse, therefore, which had first encountered the enemy,
being repulsed, created an alarm among the light-armed; and the battle
would have been fought under the very rampart, had not the legions, which
were their main strength, drawn out their line, though they had a very
short time to form in. These too, for a short time, wavered around their
standards, when the Astapans, blind with rage, rushed upon wounds and the
sword with reckless daring; but afterwards the veteran soldiers, standing
firm against their furious assaults, checked the violence of those that
followed by the slaughter of the foremost. Soon after, the veteran troops
themselves made an attempt to charge them, but seeing that not a man gave
ground, and that they were inflexibly determined on dying each in his place,
they extended their line, which the number of their troops enabled them
to do with ease, and, surrounding their flanks, slew them all to a man
while fighting in a circle.
23. But these, however, were acts committed by exasperated enemies in the heat of battle, and executed, in conformity with the laws of war, upon men armed and most fiercely resisting; there was another more horrible carnage in the city, where a harmless and defenseless crowd of women and children were butchered by their own countrymen, who threw their bodies, most of them still alive, upon the burning pile while streams of blood damped the rising flame; and lastly, wearied with the piteous slaughter of their friends, they threw themselves, arms and all, into the midst of the flames. When the carnage was now completed the victorious Romans came up, and at the first sight of so revolting a transaction they stood for some time wrapt in wonder and amazement; but afterwards, from a rapacity natural to humanity, wishing to snatch out of the fire the gold and silver which glittered amid the heap of other materials, some were caught by the flames, others scorched by the hot blasts, as the foremost were unable to retreat, in consequence of the immense crowd which pressed upon them. In this manner was Astapa destroyed by the sword and fire, without affording any booty to the soldiers. After the rest of the people in that quarter, influenced by fear, had made submission to him, Marcius led his victorious troops to Scipio, at Carthage. Just at this same time deserters arrived from Gades, who promised to betray the town and Carthaginian garrison which occupied it, together with the commander and the fleet. Mago had halted there after his flight, and having collected some ships on the ocean, had got together a considerable number of auxiliaries from the coast of Africa, on the other side the strait, and also by means of Hanno the prefect from the neighboring parts of Spain. After pledges had been exchanged with the deserters, Marcius and Laelius were sent thither, the former with the light cohorts, the latter with seven triremes and one quinquereme, in order that they might act in concert by land and sea.
24. In consequence of Scipio's being afflicted with a severe fit of illness,
which rumor represented as more serious than it really was; for every one
made some addition to the account he had received, from a desire inherent
in mankind of intentionally exaggerating reports, the whole province, and
more especially the distant parts of it, were thrown into a state of ferment;
and it was evident what a serious disturbance would have been excited had
he really died, when an unfounded report created such violent commotions.
Neither the allies kept their allegiance, nor the army their duty. Mandonius
and Indibilis, who were not at all satisfied with what had occurred, for
they had anticipated with certainty that they would have the dominion of
Spain on the expulsion of the Carthaginians, called together their countrymen
the Lacetani, and summoning the Celtiberian youth to arms, devastated in
a hostile manner the territories of the Suessetanians and Sedetanians,
allies of the Romans. Besides, a mutiny arose in the camp at Sucro. Here
were eight thousand men, stationed as a guard over the nations dwelling
on this side the Iberus. It was not on hearing uncertain rumors respecting
the life of the general that their minds were first excited, but previously,
owing to the licentiousness which naturally results from long-continued
idleness, and in some degree also owing to the restraint felt in time of
peace by men who had been accustomed to live freely on what they gained
by plunder in an enemy's country. At first they only discoursed in private,
asking what they were doing among people who were at peace with them, if
there was a war in the province? if the war was terminated and the province
completely subdued, why were they not conveyed back into Italy? The pay
also was demanded with more insolence than was customary or consistent
with military subordination, and the guards cast reproaches upon the tribunes
while going round to the watches. Some too had gone out by night into the
neighboring lands, belonging to persons at peace with the Romans, to plunder;
but at last they quitted their standards in the day-time and openly without
furloughs. Every thing was done according to the caprice and unrestrained
will of the soldiers, and nothing according to rule and military discipline,
or the orders of those who were in command. The form, however, of a Roman
camp was preserved solely in consequence of the hopes they entertained
that the tribunes, catching the spirit of insubordination, would not be
averse from taking part in the mutiny and defection, on which account they
suffered them to dispense justice in their courts, went to them for the
watch-word, and served in their turn on the outposts and watches; and as
they had taken away the power of command, so they preserved the appearance
of obedience to orders, by spontaneously executing their own. Afterwards,
when they perceived that the tribunes censured and reprobated their proceedings,
endeavoured to counteract them, and publicly declared that they would not
take any share in their disorderly conduct, the mutiny assumed a decided
character; when, after driving the tribunes from their courts, and shortly
after from the camp, the command was conferred by universal consent upon
Caius Albius of Cales and Caius Atrius of Umbria, common soldiers, who
were the prime movers of the sedition. These men were so far from being
satisfied with the ornaments used by tribunes, that they had the audacity
to lay hold even of the insignia of the highest authority, the fasces and
axes, without ever reflecting that their own backs and necks were in danger
from those very rods and axes which they carried before them to intimidate
others. Their mistaken belief of the death of Scipio had blinded their
minds, and they doubted not that, in a short time, when that event should
be made generally known, all Spain would blaze with war; that during this
confusion money might be exacted from the allies and the neighboring cities
plundered; and that in this unsettled state of affairs, when there was
nothing which any man would not dare, their own acts would be less conspicuous.
25. As they expected that other fresh accounts would follow those which they had received, not only of the death, but even of the burial, of Scipio, and yet none arrived; and as the rumor which had been so idly originated began to die away, the first author of it began to be sought out; and each backing out in order that he might appear rather to have inconsiderately credited than to have fabricated such a report, the leaders were forsaken, and began now to dread their own ensigns of authority, and to apprehend that, instead of that empty show of command which they wore, a legitimate and rightful power would be turned against them. The mutiny being thus paralyzed, and credible persons bringing in accounts, first, that Scipio was alive, and, soon after, that he was even in good health, seven military tribunes were sent by Scipio himself. At the first arrival of these their minds were violently excited; but they were soon calmed by the mild and soothing language which they addressed to such of their acquaintance as they met with; for, going round first of all to the tents, and then entering the principia and the praetorium, wherever they observed circles of men conversing together, they addressed them, inquiring rather what it was that had occasioned their displeasure and sudden consternation, than taxing them with what had occurred. "That they had not received their pay at the appointed time," was generally complained; and "that although at the time of the horrid transaction of the Illiturgians, and after the destruction of two generals and two armies, the Roman cause had been defended and the province retained by their valor; the Illiturgians had received the punishment due to their offense, but there was no one found to reward them for their meritorious services." The tribunes replied, "that, considering the nature of their complaints, what they requested was just, and that they would lay it before the general; that they were happy that there was nothing of a more gloomy and irremediable character; that both Publius Scipio, by the favor of the gods, and the commonwealth, were in a situation to requite them." Scipio, who was accustomed to war but inexperienced in the storms of sedition, felt great anxiety on the occasion, lest the army should run into excess in transgressing, or himself in punishing. For the present he resolved to persist in the lenient line of conduct with which he had begun, and sending collectors round to the tributary states, to give the soldiers hopes of soon receiving their pay. Immediately after this a proclamation was issued that they should come to Carthage to receive their pay, whether they wished to do so in detached parties or all in a body. The sudden suppression of the rebellion among the Spaniards had the effect of tranquillizing the mutiny, which was by this time beginning to subside of itself; for Mandonius and Indibilis, relinquishing their attempt, had returned within their borders when intelligence was brought that Scipio was alive; nor did there now remain any person, whether countryman or foreigner, whom they could make their companion in their desperate enterprise. On examining every method, they had no alternative except that which afforded a retreat from wicked designs, which was not of the safest kind, namely, to commit themselves either to the just anger of the general, or to his clemency, of which they need not despair. For he had pardoned even enemies whom he had encountered with the sword; while they reflected that their sedition had been unaccompanied with wounds or blood, and was neither in itself of an atrocious character nor merited severe punishment. So natural is it for men to be over-eloquent in extenuating their own demerit. They felt doubtful whether they should go to demand their pay in single cohorts or in one entire body; but the opinion that they should go in a body, which they regarded as the safer mode, prevailed.
26. At the same time, when they were employed in these deliberations, a
council was held on their case at Carthage; when a warm debate took place
as to whether they should visit with punishment the originators only of
the mutiny, who were in number not more than thirty-five, or, whether atonement
should be made for this defection, (for such it was rather than a mutiny,)
of so dreadful a character as a precedent, by the punishment of a greater
number. The opinion recommending the more lenient course, that the punishment
should fall where the guilt originated, was adopted. For the multitude
a reprimand was considered sufficient. On the breaking up of the council,
orders were given to the army, which was in Carthage, to prepare for an
expedition against Mandonius and Indibilis, and to get ready provisions
for several days, in order that they might appear to have been deliberating
about this. The seven tribunes who had before gone to Sucro to quell the
mutiny, having been sent out to meet the army, gave in, each of them, five
names of persons principally concerned in the affair, in order that proper
persons might be employed to invite them to their homes, with smiles and
kind words; and that, when overpowered with wine, they might be thrown
into chains. They were not far distant from Carthage when the intelligence,
received from persons on the road, that the whole army was going the following
day with Marcus Silanus against the Lacetanians, not only freed them from
all the apprehensions which, though they did not give utterance to them,
sat heavy upon their minds, but occasioned the greatest transport, because
they would thus have the general alone, and in their power, instead of
being themselves in his. They entered the city just at sun-set, and saw
the other army making every preparation for a march. Immediately on their
arrival they were greeted in terms feigned for the purpose, that their
arrival was looked upon by the general as a happy and seasonable circumstance,
for they had come when the other army was just on the point of setting
out. After which they proceeded to refresh themselves. The authors of the
mutiny, having been conveyed to their lodgings by proper persons, were
apprehended by the tribunes without any disturbance, and thrown into chains.
At the fourth watch the baggage belonging to the army, which, as it was
pretended, was about to march, began to set out. As soon as it was light
the troops marched, but were stopped at the gate, and guards were sent
round to all the gates to prevent any one going out of the city. Then those
who had arrived the day before, having been summoned to an assembly, ran
in crowds into the forum to the tribunal of the general, with the presumptuous
purpose of intimidating him by their shouts. At the same time that the
general mounted the tribunal, the armed troops, which had been brought
back from the gates, spread themselves around the rear of the unarmed assembly.
Then all their insolence subsided; and, as they afterwards confessed, nothing
terrified them so much as the unexpected vigor and hue of the general,
whom they had supposed they should see in a sickly state, and his countenance,
which was such as they declared that they did not remember to have ever
seen it even in battle. He sat silent for a short time till he was informed
that the instigators of the mutiny were brought into the forum, and that
every thing was now in readiness.
27. Then, a herald having obtained silence, he thus began: "I imagined
that language would never fail me in which to address my army; not that
I have ever accustomed myself to speaking rather than action, but because,
having been kept in a camp almost from my boyhood, I had become familiar
with the dispositions of soldiers. But I am at a loss both for sentiments
and expressions with which to address you, whom I know not even by what
name I ought to call. Can I call you countrymen, who have revolted from
your country? or soldiers, who have rejected the command and authority
of your general, and violated the solemn obligation of your oath? Can I
call you enemies? I recognize the persons, faces, dress, and mien of fellow
countrymen; but I perceive the actions, expressions, intentions, and feelings
of enemies. For what have you wished and hoped for, but what the Ilergetians
and Lacetanians did. Yet they followed Mandonius and Indibilis, men of
royal rank, who were the leaders of their mad project; you conferred the
auspices and command upon the Umbrian, Atrius, and the Calenian, Albius.
Deny, soldiers, that you were all concerned in this measure, or that you
approved of it when taken. I shall willingly believe, when you disclaim
it, that it was the folly and madness of a few. For the acts which have
been committed are of such a nature, that, if the whole army participated
in them, they could not be expiated without atonements of tremendous magnitude.
Upon these points, like wounds, I touch with reluctance; but unless touched
and handled, they cannot be cured. For my own part, I believed that, after
the Carthaginians were expelled from Spain, there was not a place in the
whole province where, or any persons to whom, my life was obnoxious; such
was the manner in which I had conducted myself, not only towards my allies,
but even towards my enemies. But lo, even in my own camp, so much was I
deceived in my opinion, the report of my death was not only readily believed,
but anxiously waited for. Not that I wish to implicate you all in this
enormity; for, be assured, if I supposed that the whole of my army desired
my death, I would here immediately expire before your eyes; nor could I
take any pleasure in a life which was odious to my countrymen and my soldiers.
But every multitude is in its nature like the ocean; which, though in itself
incapable of motion, is excited by storms and winds. So, also, in yourselves
there is calm and there are storms; but the cause and origin of your fury
is entirely attributable to those who led you on; you have caught your
madness by contagion. Nay, even this day you do not appear to me to be
aware to what a pitch of frenzy you have proceeded; what a heinous crime
you have dared to commit against myself, your country, your parents, your
children; against the gods, the witnesses of your oath; against the auspices
under which you serve; against the laws of war, the discipline of your
ancestors, and the majesty of the highest authority. With regard to myself,
I say nothing. You may have believed the report of my death rather inconsiderately
than eagerly. Lastly, suppose me to be such a man that it could not at
all be a matter of astonishment that my army should be weary of my command,
yet what had your country deserved of you, which you betrayed by making
common cause with Mandonius and Indibilis? What the Roman people, when,
taking the command from the tribunes appointed by their suffrages, you
conferred it on private men? When, not content even with having them for
tribunes, you, a Roman army, conferred the fasces of your general upon
men who never had a slave under their command? Albius and Atrius had their
tents in your general's pavilion. With them the trumpet sounded, from them
the word was taken, they sat upon the tribunal of Scipio, upon whom the
lictor attended, for them the crowd was cleared away as they moved along,
before them the fasces with the axes were carried. When showers of stones
descend, lightnings are darted from the heavens, and animals give birth
to monsters, you consider these things as prodigies. This is a prodigy
which can be expiated by no victims, by no supplications, without the blood
of those men who have dared to commit so great a crime.
28. "Now, though villainy is never guided by reason, yet so far as it could exist in so nefarious a transaction, I would fain know what was your design. Formerly, a legion which was sent to garrison Rhegium, wickedly put to the sword the principal inhabitants and kept possession of that opulent city through a space of ten years; on account of which enormity the entire legion, consisting of four thousand men, were beheaded in the forum at Rome. But they, in the first place, did not put themselves under the direction of Atrius the Umbrian, scarcely superior to a scullion, whose name even was ominous, but of Decius Jubellius, a military tribune; nor did they unite themselves with Pyrrhus, or with the Samnites or Lucanians, the enemies of the Roman people. But you made common cause with Mandonius and Indibilis, and intended also to have united your arms with them. They intended to have held Rhegium as a lasting settlement, as the Campanians held Capua, which they took from its ancient Tuscan inhabitants; and as the Mamertines held Messana in Sicily, without any design of commencing without provocation a war upon the Roman people or their allies. Was it your purpose to hold Sucro as a place of abode? where, had I, your general, left you on my departure after the reduction of the province, you would have been justified in imploring the interference of gods and men, because you could not return to your wives and children. But suppose that you banished from your minds all recollection of these, as you did of your country and myself; I would wish to track the course of a wicked design, but not of one utterly insane. While I was alive, and the rest of the army safe, with which in one day I took Carthage, with which I routed, put to flight, and expelled from Spain four generals and four armies of the Carthaginians; did you, I say, who were only eight thousand men, all of course of less worth than Albius and Atrius, to whom you subjected yourselves, hope to wrest the province of Spain out of the hands of the Roman people? I lay no stress upon my own name, I put it out of the question. Let it be supposed that I have not been injured by you in any respect beyond the ready credence of my death. What! if I were dead, was the state to expire with me? was the empire of the Roman people to fall with me? Jupiter, most good and great, would not have permitted that the existence of the city, built under the auspices and sanction of the gods to last for ever, should terminate with that of this frail and perishable body. The Roman people have survived those many and distinguished generals who were all cut off in one war; Flaminius, Paulus, Gracchus, Posthumius Albinus, Marcus Marcellus, Titus Quinctius Crispinus, Cneius Fulvius, my kinsmen the Scipios; and will survive a thousand others who may perish, some by the sword, others by disease; and would the Roman state have been buried with my single corpse? You yourselves, here in Spain, when your two generals, my father and my uncle, fell, chose Septimus Marcius as your general to oppose the Carthaginians, exulting on account of their recent victory. And thus I speak, on the supposition that Spain would have been without a leader. Would Marcus Silanus, who was sent into the province with the same power and the same command as myself, would Lucius Scipio my brother, and Caius Laelius, lieutenant-generals, have been wanting to avenge the majesty of the empire? Could the armies, the generals themselves, their dignity or their cause, be compared with one another? And even had you got the better of all these, would you bear arms in conjunction with the Carthaginians against your country, against your countrymen? Would you wish that Africa should rule Italy, and Carthage the city of Rome? If so, for what offense on the part of your country?
29. "An unjust sentence of condemnation, and a miserable and
undeserved banishment, formerly induced Coriolanus to go and fight
against his country; he was restrained, however, by private duty from
public parricide. What grief, what resentment instigated you? Was the
delay of your pay for a few days, during the illness of your general,
a reason of sufficient weight for you to declare war against your
country? to revolt from the Roman people and join the Ilergetians?
to leave no obligation, divine or human, unviolated? Without doubt,
soldiers, you were mad; nor was the disease which seized my frame more
violent than that with which your minds were affected. I shrink with
horror from the relation of what men believed, what they hoped and
wished. Let oblivion cover all these things if possible; if not,
however it be, let them be covered in silence. I must confess my
speech must have appeared to you severe and harsh, but how much more
harsh, think you, must your actions be than my words! Do you think it
reasonable that I should suffer all the acts which you have committed,
and that you should not bear with patience even to hear them
mentioned? But you shall not be reproached even with these things any
further. I could wish that you might as easily forget them as I shall.
Therefore, as far as relates to the general body of you, if you repent
of the error you have committed, I shall have received sufficient and
more than sufficient atonement for it. Albius the Calenian, and Atrius
the Umbrian, with the rest of the principal movers of this
impious mutiny, shall expiate with their blood the crime they have
perpetrated. To yourselves, if you have returned to a sound state
of mind, the sight of their punishment ought not only to be not
unpleasant, but even gratifying; for there are no persons to whom the
measures they have taken are more hostile and injurious than to
you." He had scarcely finished speaking, when, according to the plan
preconcerted, every object of terror was at once presented to their
eyes and ears. The troops, which had formed a circle round the
assembly, clashed their swords against their shields; the herald's
voice was heard citing by name the persons who had been condemned in
the council; the culprits were dragged naked into the midst of the
assembly, and at the same time all the apparatus for punishment was
brought forth. They were tied to the stake, scourged with rods, and
decapitated; while those who were present were so benumbed with fear,
that not only no expression of dissatisfaction at the severity of the
punishment, but not even a groan was heard. They were then all dragged
out, the place was cleared, and the men cited by name took the oath of
allegiance to Scipio before the military tribunes, each receiving
his full demand of pay as he answered to his name. Such was the
termination and result which the insurrection of the soldiers, which
began at Sucro, met with.
30. During the time of these transactions, Hanno, the lieutenant-general
of Mago, having been sent from Gades to the river Baetis with a small body
of Africans, by tempting the Spaniards with money, armed as many as four
thousand men; but afterwards, being deprived of his camp by Lucius Marcius,
and losing the principal part of his troops in the confusion occasioned
by its capture, and some also in the flight, for the cavalry pursued them
closely while they were dispersed, he made his escape with a few attendants.
During these transactions on the river Baetis, Laelius in the mean time,
sailing out of the straits into the ocean, came with his fleet before Carteia,
a city situated on the coast of the ocean, where the sea begins to expand
itself, after being confined in a narrow strait. He had entertained hopes
of having Gades betrayed to him without a contest, persons having come
unsolicited into the Roman camp to make promises to that effect, as has
been before mentioned. The plot was discovered before it was ripe, and
all having been apprehended, were placed by Mago in the hands of Adherbal
the praetor, to be conveyed to Carthage. Adherbal, having put the conspirators
on board a quinquereme, sent it in advance, because it sailed slower than
a trireme, and followed himself at a moderate distance with eight triremes.
The quinquereme was just entering the strait, when Laelius, who had himself
also sailed out of the harbor of Carteia in a quinquereme, followed by
seven triremes, bore down upon Adherbal and his triremes, feeling assured
that the trireme, when once caught in the rapid strait, would not be able
to return against the opposing current. The Carthaginian, alarmed by the
suddenness of the affair, hesitated for some little time whether he should
follow the trireme, or turn his prows against the enemy. This very delay
put it out of his power to decline an action, for they were now within
a weapon's cast, and the enemy were bearing down upon him on all sides.
The current also had rendered it impossible to manage the ships. Nor was
the action like a naval engagement, inasmuch as it was in no respect subject
to the control of the will, nor afforded any opportunity for the exercise
of skill or method. The nature of the strait and the tide, which solely
and entirely governed the contest, carried the ships against those of their
own and the enemy's party indiscriminately, though striving in a contrary
direction; so that you might see one ship which was flying whirled back
by an eddy and driven against the victors, and another which was engaged
in pursuit, if it had fallen into an opposite current, turning itself away
as if for flight. And when actually engaged, one ship while bearing down
upon another with its beak directed against it, assuming an oblique position
itself, received a stroke from the beak of the other; while another which
lay with its side exposed to the enemy, receiving a sudden impulse, was
turned round so as to present its prow. While the triremes were thus engaged
in a doubtful and uncertain contest, in which every thing was governed
by chance, the Roman quinquereme, whether being more manageable in consequence
of its weight, or by means of more banks of oars making its way through
the eddies, sunk two triremes, and swept off the oars from one side of
another, while sailing by it with great violence. The rest too, had they
come in its way, it would have disabled; but Adherbal, with his remaining
four ships, sailed over into Africa.
31. Laelius returned victorious into Carteia; and hearing there what had occurred at Gades, that the plot had been discovered, the conspirators sent to Carthage, and that the hopes which had brought them there had been completely frustrated, he sent a message to Lucius Marcius, to the effect that, unless they wished to waste time uselessly in lying before Gades, they should return to the general; and Marcius consenting to the proposal, they both returned to Carthage a few days after. In consequence of their departure, Mago not only obtained a temporary relief from the dangers which beset him on all sides, both by sea and land, but also on hearing of the rebellion of the Ilergetians, conceived hopes of recovering Spain, and sent messengers to Carthage to the senate, who, at the same time that they represented to them in exaggerated terms both the intestine dissension in the Roman camp and the defection of their allies, might exhort them to send succors by which the empire of Spain, which had been handed down to them by their ancestors, might be regained. Mandonius and Indibilis, retiring within their borders, remained quiet for a little time, not knowing what course to take, till they knew what was determined upon respecting the mutiny; but not distrusting that if Scipio pardoned the error of his own countrymen, they also might obtain the same. But when the severe punishment inflicted came to be generally known, concluding that their offense also would be considered as demanding a similar expiation, they again summoned their countrymen to arms; and assembling the auxiliaries which had joined them before, they crossed over into the Sedetanian territory, where they had had a fixed camp at the beginning of the revolt, with twenty thousand foot and two thousand five hundred horse.
32. Scipio having without difficulty regained the affection of his soldiers, both by his punctuality in discharging the arrears of pay to all, as well the guilty as the innocent, and particularly by the looks and language of reconciliation towards all, before he quitted Carthage summoned an assembly; and after inveighing at large against the perfidy of the petty princes who were in rebellion, declared "that the feelings with which he set out to take revenge for their villainy were widely different from those with which he lately corrected the error committed by his countrymen. That on the latter occasion, he had with groans and tears, as though he were cutting his own vitals, expiated either the imprudence or the guilt of eight thousand men with the heads of thirty; but now he was going to the destruction of the Ilergetians with joyful and animated feelings: for they were neither natives of the same soil, nor united with him by any bond of society. The only connection which did subsist between them, that of honor and friendship, they had themselves severed by their wicked conduct." When he looked at the troops which composed his army, besides that he saw that they were all either of his own country, or allies and of the Latin confederacy; he was also strongly affected by the circumstance, that there was scarcely a soldier in it who was not brought out of Italy into that country either by his uncle, Cneius Scipio, who was the first of the Roman name who had come into that province, or by his father when consul, or by himself. That they were all accustomed to the name and auspices of the Scipios; that it was his wish to take them home to their country to receive a well-earned triumph; and that he hoped that they would support him when he put up for the consulship, as if the honor sought were to be shared in common by them all. With regard to the expedition which they were just going to undertake, that the man who considered it as a war must be forgetful of his own achievements. That, by Hercules, Mago, who had fled for safety with a few ships beyond the limits of the world into an island surrounded by the ocean, was a source of greater concern to him than the Ilergetians; for in it there was both a Carthaginian general and a Carthaginian army, whatever might be its numbers; while here were only robbers and leaders of robbers, who, though they possessed sufficient energy for ravaging the lands of their neighbors, burning their houses, and carrying off their cattle, yet would have none at all in a regular and pitched battle; and who would come to the encounter relying more on the swiftness with which they can fly than on their arms. "Accordingly," he said, "that he had thought it right to quell the Ilergetians before he quitted the province, not because he saw that any danger could arise from them, or that a war of greater importance could grow out of these proceedings; but in the first place, that a revolt of so heinous a character might not go unpunished, and in the next place, that not a single enemy might be said to be left in a province which had been subdued with such valor and success. He bid them, therefore, follow him, with the assistance of the gods, not so much to make war upon, for the contest was not with an enemy who was upon an equality with them, but to take vengeance on the basest of men."
33. After this harangue he dismissed them, with orders to get themselves
in readiness in every respect for marching the next day; when, setting
out, he arrived at the river Iberus in ten days. Then crossing the river,
he, on the fourth day, pitched his camp within sight of the enemy. Before
him was a plain enclosed on all sides by mountains. Into the valley thus
formed Scipio ordered some cattle, taken chiefly from the lands of the
enemy, to be driven, in order to excite the rapacity of the barbarians,
and then sent some light-armed troops as a protection for them, directing
Laelius to charge the enemy from a place of concealment when they were
engaged in skirmishing. A mountain which projected conveniently concealed
the ambuscade of the cavalry, and the battle began without delay. The Spaniards,
as soon as they saw the cattle at a distance, rushed upon them, and the
light-armed troops attacked the Spaniards while occupied with their booty.
At first they annoyed each other with missiles; but afterwards, having
discharged their light weapons, which were calculated to provoke rather
than to decide the contest, they drew their swords, and began to engage
foot to foot. The fight between the infantry would have been doubtful,
but that the cavalry then came up, and not only, charging them in front,
trod down all before them, but some also, riding round by the foot of the
hill, presented themselves on their rear, so that they might intercept
the greater part of them; and consequently the carnage was greater than
usually takes place in light and skirmishing engagements. The resentment
of the barbarians was rather inflamed by this adverse battle, than their
spirits depressed. Accordingly, that they might not appear cast down, they
marched out into the field the following day as soon as it was light. The
valley, which was confined, as has been before stated, would not contain
all their forces. About two-thirds of their foot and all their cavalry
came down to the engagement. The remainder of their infantry they stationed
on the declivity of the hill. Scipio, conceiving that the confined nature
of the ground would be in his favor, both because the Roman troops were
better adapted for fighting in a contracted space than the Spanish, and
also because the enemy had come down and formed their line on ground which
would not contain all their forces, applied his mind to a new expedient.
For he considered that he could not himself cover his flanks with his cavalry,
and that those of the enemy which they had led out, together with their
infantry, would be unable to act. Accordingly he ordered Laelius to lead
the cavalry round by the hills as secretly as possible, and separate, as
far as he could, the fight between the cavalry from that between the infantry.
He himself drew up the whole body of his infantry against the enemy, placing
four cohorts in front, because he could not extend his line further. He
commenced the battle without delay, in order that the contest itself might
divert the attention of the enemy, and prevent their observing the cavalry
which were passing along the hills. Nor were they aware that they had come
round before they beard the noise occasioned by the engagement of the cavalry
in their rear. Thus there were two battles; two lines of infantry and two
bodies of horse being engaged within the space occupied by the plain lengthwise;
and that because it was too narrow to admit of both descriptions of force
being engaged in the same lines. When the Spanish infantry could not assist
their cavalry, nor their cavalry the infantry, and the infantry, which
had rashly engaged in the plain, relying on the assistance of the cavalry,
were being cut to pieces, the cavalry themselves also, being surrounded
and unable to stand the shock of the enemy's infantry in front, (for by
this time their own infantry were completely overthrown,) nor of the cavalry
in their rear, after having formed themselves into a circle and defended
themselves for a long time, their horses standing still, were all slain
to a man. Nor did one person, horse or foot, survive of those who were
engaged in the valley. The third part, which stood upon the hill rather
to view the contest in security than to take any part of it upon themselves,
had both time and space to fly; among whom the princes themselves also
fled, having escaped during the confusion, before the army was entirely
surrounded.
34. The same day, besides other booty, the camp of the Spaniards was taken, together with about three thousand men. Of the Romans and their allies as many as one thousand two hundred fell in that battle; more than three thousand were wounded. The victory would have been less bloody had the battle taken place in a plain more extended, and affording facilities for flight. Indibilis, renouncing his purpose of carrying on war, and considering that his safest reliance in his present distress was on the tried honor and clemency of Scipio, sent his brother Mandonius to him; who, falling prostrate before his knees, ascribed his conduct to the fatal frenzy of those times, when, as it were from the effects of some pestilential contagion, not only the Ilergetians and Lacetanians, but even the Roman camp had been infected with madness. He said that his own condition, and that of his brother and the rest of his countrymen, was such, that either, if it seemed good, they would give back their lives to him from whom they had received them, or if preserved a second time, they would in return for that favor devote their lives for ever to the service of him to whom alone they were indebted for them. They before placed their reliance on their cause, when they had not yet had experience of his clemency, but now, on the contrary, placing no reliance on their cause, all their hopes were centered in the mercy of the conqueror. It was a custom with the Romans, observed from ancient times, not to exercise any authority over others, as subject to them, in cases where they did not enter into friendship with them by a league and on equal terms, until they had surrendered all they possessed, sacred and profane; until they had received hostages, taken their arms from them, and placed garrisons in their cities. In the present instance, however, Scipio, after inveighing at great length against Mandonius, who stood before him, and Indibilis, who was absent, said "that they had justly forfeited their lives by their wicked conduct, but that they should be preserved by the kindness of himself and the Roman people. Further, that he would neither take their arms from them, (which only served as pledges to those who feared rebellion,) but would leave them the free use of them, and their minds free from fear; nor would he take vengeance on their unoffending hostages, but upon themselves, should they revolt, not inflicting punishment upon a defenseless but an armed enemy. That he gave them the liberty of choosing whether they would have the Romans favorable to them or incensed against them, for they had experienced them under both circumstances." Thus Mandonius was allowed to depart, having only a pecuniary fine imposed upon him to furnish the means of paying the troops. Scipio himself, having sent Marcius in advance into the Farther Spain, and sent Silanus back to Tarraco, waited a few days until the Ilergetians had paid the fine imposed upon them; and then, setting out with some troops lightly equipped, overtook Marcius when he was now drawing near to the ocean.
35. The negotiation which had some time before commenced respecting Masinissa, was delayed from one cause after another; for the Numidian was desirous by all means of conferring with Scipio in person, and of touching his right hand in confirmation of their compact. This was the cause of Scipio's undertaking at this time a journey of such a length, and into so remote a quarter. Masinissa, when at Gades, received information from Marcius of the approach of Scipio, and by pretending that his horses were injured by being pent up in the island, and that they not only caused a scarcity of every thing to the rest, but also felt it themselves; moreover that his cavalry were beginning to lose their energy for want of employment; he prevailed upon Mago to allow him to cross over to the continent, to plunder the adjacent country of Spain. Having passed over, he sent forward three chiefs of the Numidians, to fix a time and place for the conference desiring that two might be detained by Scipio as hostages. The third being sent back to conduct Masinissa to the place to which he was directed to bring him, they came to the conference with a few attendants. The Numidian had long before been possessed with admiration of Scipio from the fame of his exploits; and his imagination had pictured to him the idea of a grand and magnificent person; but his veneration for him was still greater when he appeared before him. For besides that his person, naturally majestic in the highest degree, was rendered still more so by his flowing hair, by his dress, which was not in a precise and ornamental style, but truly masculine and soldier-like, and also by his age, for he was then in full vigor of body, to which the bloom of youth, renewed as it were after his late illness, had given additional fullness and sleekness. The Numidian, who was in a manner thunderstruck by the mere effect of the meeting, thanked him for having sent home his brother's son. He affirmed, that from that time he had sought for this opportunity, which being at length presented to him, by favor of the immortal gods, he had not allowed to pass without seizing it. That he desired to serve him and the Roman people in such a manner, as that no one foreigner should have aided the Roman interest with greater zeal than himself. Although he had long since wished it, he had not been so able to effect it in Spain, a foreign and strange country; but that it would be easy for him to do so in that country in which he had been born and educated, under the hope of succeeding to his father's throne. If, indeed, the Romans should send the same commander, Scipio, into Africa, he entertained a well-grounded hope that Carthage would continue to exist but a short time. Scipio saw and heard him with the highest delight, both because he knew that he was the first man in all the cavalry of the enemy, and because the youth himself exhibited in his manner the strongest proof of a noble spirit. After mutual pledges of faith, he set out on his return to Tarraco. Masinissa, having laid waste the adjacent lands, with the permission of the Romans, that he might not appear to have passed over into the continent to no purpose, returned to Gades.
36. Mago, who despaired of success in Spain, of which he had entertained hopes, from the confidence inspired first by the mutiny of the soldiers, and afterwards by the defection of Indibilis, received a message from Carthage, while preparing to cross over into Africa, that the senate ordered him to carry over into Italy the fleet he had at Gades; and hiring there as many as he could of the Gallic and Ligurian youth, to form a junction with Hannibal, and not to suffer the war to flag which had been begun with so much vigor and still more success. For this object Mago not only received a supply of money from Carthage, but himself also exacted as much as he could from the inhabitants of Gades, plundering not only their treasury, but their temples, and compelling them individually to bring contributions of gold and silver, for the public service. As he sailed along the coast of Spain, he landed his troops not far from New Carthage, and after wasting the neighboring lands, brought his fleet thence to the city. Here, keeping his troops in the ships by day, he landed them by night, and marched them to that part of the wall at which Carthage had been captured by the Romans; for he had supposed both that the garrison by which the city was occupied was not sufficiently strong for its protection, and that some of the townsmen would act on the hope of effecting a change. But messengers who came with the utmost haste and alarm from the country, brought intelligence at once of the devastation of the lands, the flight of the rustics, and the approach of the enemy. Besides, the fleet had been observed during the day, and it was evident that there was some object in choosing a station before the city. Accordingly, the troops were kept drawn up and armed within the gate which looks towards the lake and the sea. When the enemy, rushing forward in a disorderly manner, with a crowd of seamen mingled with soldiers, came up to the walls with more noise than strength; the gate being suddenly thrown open, the Romans sallied forth with a shout, and pursued the enemy, routed and put to flight at the first onset and discharge of their weapons, all the way to the shore, killing a great number of them; nor would one of them have survived the battle and the flight, had not the ships, which had been brought to the shore, afforded them a refuge in their dismay. Great alarm and confusion also prevailed in the ships, occasioned by their drawing up the ladders, lest the enemy should force their way in together with their own men, and by cutting away their halsers and anchors that they might not lose time in weighing them. Many, too, met with a miserable death while endeavoring to swim to the ships, not knowing, in consequence of the darkness, which way to direct their course, or what to avoid. On the following day, after the fleet had fled back to the ocean whence it had come, as many as eight hundred were slain between the wall and the shore, and two thousand stand of arms were found.
37. Mago, on his return to Gades, not being allowed to enter the place,
brought his fleet to shore at Cimbis, a place not far distant from Gades;
whence he sent ambassadors with complaints of their having closed their
gates upon a friend and ally. While they endeavoured to excuse themselves
on the ground that it was done by a disorderly assembly of their people,
who were exasperated against them on account of some acts of plunder which
had been committed by the soldiers when they were embarking, he enticed
their suffetes, which is the name of the chief magistracy among the Carthaginians,
together with their quaestor, to come to a conference; when he ordered
them to be lacerated with stripes and crucified. He then passed over with
his fleet to the island Pityusa, distant about a hundred miles from the
continent, and inhabited at that time by Carthaginians; on which account
the fleet was received in a friendly manner; and not only were provisions
liberally furnished, but also young men and arms were given them to reinforce
their fleet. Rendered confident by these supplies, the Carthaginians crossed
over to the Balearian islands, fifty miles distant. The Balearian islands
are two in number; one larger than the other, and more powerful in men
and arms; having also a harbor in which, as it was now the latter end of
autumn, he believed he might winter conveniently. But here his fleet was
opposed with as much hostility as he would have met with had the Romans
inhabited that island. The only weapons they used at that time, and which
they now principally employ, were slings; nor is there an individual of
any other nation who possesses such a degree of excellence in the skillful
use of this weapon, as the Balearians universally possess over the rest
of the world. Such a quantity of stones, therefore, was poured like the
thickest hail on the fleet, when approaching the shore, that, not daring
to enter the harbor, they made off for the main. They then passed over
to the lesser Balearian island, which is of a fertile soil, but not equally
powerful in men and arms. Here, therefore, they landed, and pitched a camp
in a strong position above the harbor; and having made themselves masters
of the city and country without a contest, they enlisted two thousand auxiliaries,
which they sent to Carthage, and then hauled their ships on shore for the
winter. After Mago had left the coast of the ocean, the people of Gades
surrendered to the Romans.
38. Such were the transactions in Spain under the conduct and auspices
of Publius Scipio. Scipio himself, having put Lucius Lentulus and
Lucius Manlius Acidinus in charge of the province, returned to Rome
with ten ships. Having obtained an audience of the senate without the
city, in the temple of Bellona, he gave an account of the services he
had performed in Spain; how often he had fought pitched battles, how
many towns he had taken by force from the enemy, and what nations he
had brought under the dominion of the Roman people. He stated that he
had gone into Spain against four generals, and four victorious armies,
but that he had not left a Carthaginian in that country. On account of
these services he rather tried his prospect of a triumph, than pressed
it pertinaciously; for it was quite clear, that no one had triumphed
up to that time for services performed, when not invested with a
magistracy. When the senate was dismissed he entered the city, and
carried before him into the treasury fourteen thousand three hundred
and forty-two pounds of silver, and a great quantity of coined silver.
Lucius Veturius Philo then held the assembly for the election
of consuls, when all the centuries, with the strongest marks of
attachment, named Publius Scipio as consul. Publius Licinius Crassus,
chief pontiff, was joined with him as his colleague. It is recorded,
that this election was attended by a greater number of persons than
any other during the war. People had come together from all quarters,
not only to give their votes, but also for the purpose of seeing
Publius Scipio. They ran in crowds, not only to his house, but also to
the Capitol; where he was engaged in offering a sacrifice of a
hundred oxen to Jupiter, which he had vowed in Spain, impressed with
a presentiment, that as Caius Lutatius had terminated the former Punic
war, so Publius Scipio would terminate the present; and that as he had
driven the Carthaginians out of every part of Spain, so he would
drive them out of Italy; and dooming Africa to him as his province, as
though the war in Italy were at an end. The assembly was then held
for the election of praetors. Two were elected who were then plebeian
aediles, namely, Spurius Lucretius and Cneius Octavius; and of private
persons, Cneius Servilius Caepio and Lucius Aemilius Papus.
In the fourteenth year of the Punic war, Publius Cornelius Scipio and
Publius Licinius Crassus entered on the consulship, when the provinces
assigned to the consuls were, to Scipio, Sicily, without drawing lots,
his colleague not opposing it, because the care of the sacred affairs
required the presence of the chief pontiff in Italy; to Crassus,
Bruttium. The provinces of the praetors were then put to the
determination of lots, when the city jurisdiction fell to Servilius;
Ariminum, for so they called Gaul, to Spurius Lucretius; Sicily to
Lucius Aemilius; Sardinia to Cneius Octavius. A senate was held in
the Capitol, when, on the motion of Publius Scipio, a decree was made,
that he should exhibit the games which he had vowed in Spain during
the mutiny of the soldiers, out of the money which he had himself
brought into the treasury.
39. He then introduced into the senate the Saguntine ambassadors, the eldest of whom thus spoke: "Although there remains no degree of suffering, conscript fathers, beyond what we have endured, in order that we might keep our faith towards you to the last; yet such are the benefits which we have received both from yourselves and your generals, that we do not repent of the calamities to which we have ourselves been exposed. On our account you undertook the war, and having undertaken it, you have continued to carry it on for now the fourteenth year with such inflexible perseverance, that frequently you have both yourselves been reduced, and have brought the Carthaginians to the last extremity. At a time when you had a war of such a desperate character in Italy, and Hannibal as your antagonist, you sent your consul with an army into Spain, to collect, as it were, the remains of our wreck. Publius and Cneius Cornelius, from the time they entered the province, never ceased from adopting such measures as were favorable to us and detrimental to our enemies. First of all, they restored to us our town; and, sending persons to collect our countrymen, who were sold and dispersed throughout all Spain, restored them from a state of slavery to freedom. When our circumstances, from being wretched in the extreme, had nearly assumed a desirable state, your generals Publius and Cneius Cornelius fell more to be lamented by ourselves even than by you. Then truly we seemed to have been dragged back from distant places to our ancient abode, to perish again, and witness the second destruction of our country. Nor did it appear that there was any need forsooth of a Carthaginian army or general to effect our destruction; but that we might be annihilated by the Turdulans, our most inveterate enemies, who had also been the cause of our former overthrow. When suddenly, to our great surprise, you sent us this Publius Scipio, in seeing whom declared consul, and in having it in our power to carry word back to our countrymen that we have seen it, for on him our hopes and safety entirely rest, we consider ourselves the most fortunate of all the Saguntines. He, when he had taken a great number of the cities of your enemies in Spain, on all occasions separated the Saguntines out of the mass of captives, and sent them back to their country; and lastly, by his arms he reduced to so low a state Turdetania, which harbored such animosity against us, that if that nation continued to flourish it was impossible that Saguntum could stand, that it not only was not an object of fear to us, but, and may I say it without incurring odium, not even to our posterity. We see the city of those persons demolished, to gratify whom Hannibal destroyed Saguntum. We receive tribute from their lands, which is not more acceptable to us from the advantage we derive from it than from revenge. In consideration of these benefits, than which we could not hope or wish for greater from the immortal gods, the senate and people of Saguntum have sent us ten ambassadors to you to return their thanks; and at the same time to offer you their congratulations on your having carried on your operations in Spain and Italy so successfully of late years, that you have subdued by your arms, and have gotten possession of Spain, not only as far as the river Iberus, but also to where the ocean forms the limit of the remotest regions of the world; while in Italy you have left nothing to the Carthaginian except so much space as the rampart of his camp encloses. We have been desired, not only to return thanks for these blessings to Jove most good and great, the guardian deity of the capitoline citadel, but also, if you should permit us, to carry into the Capitol this present of a golden crown in token of victory. We request that you would permit us so to do; and, if you think proper, that you would, by your authority, perpetuate and ratify the advantages which your generals have conferred upon us." The senate replied to the Saguntines, "that the destruction and restoration of Saguntum would form a monument to all the nations of the world of social faith preserved on both sides. That, in restoring Saguntum, and rescuing its citizens from slavery, their generals had acted properly, regularly, and according to the wishes of the senate; and that, whatever other acts of kindness they had done to them, were in conformity with the wishes of the senate. That they gave them permission to deposit their present in the Capitol." Orders were then given to furnish the ambassadors with apartments and entertainment, and that not less than ten thousand asses should be given to each as a present. After this, the rest of the embassies were introduced and heard. On the request of the Saguntines that they might go and take a view of Italy as far as they could with safety, they were furnished with guides, and letters were sent to the several towns, requiring them to entertain the Spaniards kindly. The senate then took into consideration the state of public affairs, the levying troops, and the provinces.
40. It being generally reported that Africa, as a new province, was destined
for Publius Scipio without casting lots; and he himself, not content with
any moderate share of glory, asserting that he had been declared consul,
not only for prosecuting, but for finishing the war; that that object could
not be accomplished by any other means than by his transporting an army
into Africa; and himself openly declaring that he would do it through the
people if the senate opposed him; the design by no means pleased the principal
senators; and when the rest, either through fear or a wish to ingratiate
themselves with him, only murmured, Quintus Fabius Maximus, being asked
his opinion, thus spoke: "I know, conscript fathers, that by many
of you the question which is this day agitated is considered as already
determined; and that the man who shall deliver his sentiments on the subject
of making Africa a province, as a new proposal, will speak to little purpose.
But, in the first place, I cannot see how it can be considered as determined,
that Africa shall be the province of the consul, that brave and active
officer, when neither the senate have voted nor the people ordered that
it should be constituted a province this year. In the next place, if it
is determined, I think the consul is to blame, who, by pretending to consult
the senate on a question already decided, insults that body, and not the
senator only who delivers his sentiments in his place on the subject of
deliberation. Now I am well aware, that by disapproving of this excessive
eagerness to pass over into Africa, I subject myself to two imputations:
one grounded on the caution inherent in my disposition, which young men
may if they please call cowardice and sloth, so long as we have the consolation
to reflect, that though hitherto the measures of others have always appeared
on the first view of them the more plausible, mine on experience have proved
the sounder. The other imputation is that of jealousy and envy towards
the daily increasing glory of this most valiant consul. But if neither
my past life and character, nor a dictatorship, together with five consulships,
and so much glory acquired, both in peace and war, that I am more likely
to loathe it than desire more, exempt me from such a suspicion, let my
age at least acquit me. For what rivalry can there exist between myself
and a man who is not equal in years even to my son? When I was dictator,
when as yet in the possession of full vigour, and engaged in a series of
affairs of the utmost magnitude, no one heard me, either in the senate
or in the popular assembly, express any reluctance to have the command
equally shared between myself and the master of the horse, at the time
when he was maligning me; a proposition which no one ever heard mention
of before. I chose to bring it about by actions rather than by words, that
he who was placed on the same footing with me in the judgment of others,
should soon by his own confession declare me his superior. Much less, after
having passed through these honors, would I propose to myself to enter
the lists of competition and rivalry with a man in the very bloom of youth.
And that, forsooth, in order that Africa, if it shall have been denied
to him, may be assigned as a province to me, who am now weary of life,
and not merely of active employments. I must live and die with that share
of glory which I have already acquired. I prevented Hannibal from conquering,
in order that he might even be conquered by you, whose powers are now in
full vigour.
41. "It is but fair, Publius Cornelius, that you should pardon me, if I, who in my own case never preferred the honor of men to the interest of the state, do not place even your fame before the public good. Although, if there were either no war in Italy, or an enemy of such a description that no glory could be acquired from conquering him, the man who would retain you in Italy, though actuated by a desire to promote the public good, might appear to wish to deprive you of an opportunity of acquiring renown when he objected to your removing the war. But since Hannibal is our antagonist, who is besieging Italy for now the fourteenth year, with an army unimpaired, will you have reason to be dissatisfied, Publius Cornelius, with the glory you will acquire, if you in your consulate shall drive out of Italy an enemy who has been the cause of so many deaths and so many disasters to us, and if you should enjoy the distinction of having terminated this, as Caius Lutatius did the former Punic war? Unless either Hamilcar is a general more worthy of consideration than Hannibal, or a war in Africa of more importance, or a victory there greater and more glorious, (should it be our lot to be victorious while you are consul,) than one here. Would you rather have drawn away Hamilcar from Drepanum and Eryx than have expelled the Carthaginians and Hannibal from Italy? Although you naturally prize more highly the renown which you have acquired than that which you hope for, yet surely you would not boast more of having freed Spain from war than of having freed Italy. Hannibal is not as yet in such a state as that the man who prefers another war would not appear to have feared rather than to have despised him. Why then do you not apply yourself to this, and carry the war in a straightforward manner to the place where Hannibal is, rather than pursue that circuitous course, according to which you expect that when you shall have crossed over into Africa Hannibal will follow you thither? Do you seek to obtain the distinguished honor of having finished the Punic war? After you have defended your own possessions, for this is naturally the first object, then proceed to attack those of others. Let there be peace in Italy before war in Africa; and let us be free from fear ourselves before we bring it upon others. If it is possible that both objects may be accomplished under your conduct and auspices, having first conquered Hannibal here, then go and lay siege to Carthage; but if one or other of these conquests must be left for the succeeding consuls, the former is both the greater and more glorious, and also the cause of the second. For now indeed, besides that the treasury is not able to maintain two different armies, one in Italy and one in Africa; besides that we nave nothing left from which we may equip fleets or be able to furnish provisions, who knows not how great danger would be incurred? Publius Licinius will wage war in Italy, Publius Scipio in Africa. What if, (an omen which may all the gods avert, and which my mind shrinks back with alarm from mentioning,--but what has happened may happen again,--) what I say, if Hannibal, having gained a victory, should advance to the city? Shall we then at length send for you, our consul, out of Africa, as we formerly sent for Quintus Fulvius from Capua? What shall we say when we consider that in Africa also both parties will be liable to the chances of war? Let your own house, your father and your uncle, slain together with their armies within the space of thirty days, after that, having spent several years in the performance of the most important services, both by sea and land, they had inspired foreign nations with the highest reverence for the name of the Roman people and your family, be a warning to you. The day would fail me were I disposed to enumerate the kings and generals who have brought the most signal calamities upon themselves and their armies by rashly passing into the territories of their enemies. The Athenians, a state distinguished for prudence, leaving a war at home, sent a great fleet into Sicily at the instance of a youth equally enterprising and illustrious; but by one naval battle they reduced their flourishing republic to a state of humiliation from which she could never recover.
42. "But I am adducing foreign and too remote examples. That same
Africa, and Marcus Atilius, who was a signal example of both extremes of
fortune, may form a warning to us. Without doubt, Publius Cornelius, when
you shall have a view of Africa from the sea, the reduction of your province
of Spain will appear to you to have been a mere matter of sport and pastime.
For what similarity is there between them? After sailing along the coast
of Italy and Gaul to Emporiae without any enemy to oppose you, you brought
your fleet to land at a city of our allies. There landing your soldiers,
you marched them through countries entirely secure from danger to Tarraco,
to join the allies and friends of the Roman people. After that, from Tarraco
you marched through places garrisoned by Roman troops. On the banks of
the Iberus were the armies of your father and your uncle, rendered still
more furious after the loss of their generals, even by the very calamity
they had suffered. The general, indeed, Lucius Marcius, had been irregularly
constituted and chosen for the time by the suffrages of the soldiers; but
had he been adorned with noble birth and the regular gradation of preferment,
he would have been equal to the most distinguished generals, from his skill
in every art of war. You then laid siege to Carthage, quite at your leisure,
not one of the three Punic armies coming to the defense of their allies.
The rest of your achievements, nor do I wish to disparage them, are by
no means to be compared with what you will have to do in a war in Africa,
where there is not a single harbor open to receive our fleet, no part of
the country at peace with us, no state in alliance, no king in friendship
with us, no room in any part either to take up a position or to advance.
Whichever way you turn your eyes, all is hostility and danger. Do you trust
in the Numidians and Syphax? Let it suffice to have trusted in them once.
Temerity is not always successful, and the fraudulent usually pave the
way to confidence in small matters, that when an advantageous opportunity
occurs, they may deceive with great gain. Your father and uncle were not
cut off by the arms of their enemies till they were duped by the treachery
of their Celtiberian allies; nor were you yourself exposed to so much danger
from Mago and Hasdrubal, the generals of your enemies, as from Indibilis
and Mandonius, whom you had received into friendship. Can you place any
confidence in Numidians after having experienced a defection in your own
soldiers? Syphax and Masinissa would rather that they themselves should
have the rule in Africa than the Carthaginians, but that the Carthaginians
should rather than any other state. At present emulation and the various
causes of dispute existing between them incite them against each other,
because the fear of any foreign enemy is remote. But show them the Roman
arms and a body of troops, natives of another country, and they will run
together as if to extinguish a common conflagration. These same Carthaginians
defended Spain in a different manner from that in which they will defend
the walls of their capital, the temples of their gods, their altars, and
their hearths; when their terrified wives will attend them on the way to
the battle, and their little children will run to them. What, moreover,
if the Carthaginians, feeling sufficiently secure in the harmony subsisting
in Africa, in the attachment of the sovereigns in alliance with them, and
their own fortifications, should, when they see Italy deprived of the support
of yourself and your army, themselves assuming an offensive attitude, either
send a fresh army out of Africa into Italy, or order Mago, who, it is certain,
having passed over from the Baleares, is now sailing along the coast of
Liguria and the Alps, to form a junction with Hannibal. Without doubt,
we should be thrown into the same state of alarm as we were lately, when
Hasdrubal passed over into Italy; that Hasdrubal, whom you, who are about
to blockade, not Carthage only, but all Africa with your army, allowed
to slip out of your hands into Italy. You will say that he was conquered
by you. For that very reason I should be less willing, not on account of
the commonwealth only, but of yourself, that, after having been defeated,
he should be allowed to march into Italy. Suffer us to ascribe to your
prudence all the successful events which have happened to you and the empire
of the Roman people, and to impute all those of an adverse nature to the
uncertain chances of war and to fortune. The more meritorious and brave
you are, so much the more do your country and all Italy desire to retain
you as their protector. You cannot even yourself pretend to deny, that
where Hannibal is, there is the head and principal stress of the war, for
you profess, that your motive in crossing over into Africa is to draw Hannibal
thither. Whether, therefore, here or there, it is with Hannibal that you
will have to contend. Will you then, I pray, have more power in Africa
and alone, or here, with your own and your colleague's army united? Is
not the great difference which this makes proved to you even by the recent
precedent of Claudius and Livius, the consuls? What! will Hannibal, who
has now for a long time been unavailingly soliciting succors from home,
be rendered more powerful in men and arms when occupying the remotest corner
of the Bruttian territory, or when near to Carthage and supported by all
Africa? What sort of policy is that of yours, to prefer fighting where
your own forces will be diminished by one half, and the enemy's greatly
augmented, to encountering the enemy when you will have two armies against
one, and that wearied with so many battles, and so protracted and laborious
a service? Consider how far this policy of yours corresponds with that
of your parent. He, setting out in his consulship for Spain, returned from
his province into Italy, that he might meet Hannibal on his descent from
the Alps; while you are going to leave Italy when Hannibal is there, not
because you consider such a course beneficial to the state, but because
you think it will redound to your own honor and glory; acting in the same
manner as you did when leaving your province and your army without the
sanction of a law, without a decree of the senate, you, a general of the
Roman people, entrusted to two ships the fortune of the commonwealth and
the majesty of the empire, which were then hazarded in your person. In
my estimation, conscript fathers, Publius Cornelius was elected consul
for the service of the state and of us, and not to forward his own individual
interest; and the armies were enlisted for the protection of the city and
of Italy, and not for the consuls, like kings, to carry into whatever part
of the world they please from motives of vanity."
43. Fabius having made a strong impression on a large portion of the senate,
and especially those advanced in years, by this speech, which was adapted
to the occasion, and also by his authority and his long-established reputation
for prudence; and those who approved of the counsel of this old man being
more numerous than those who commended the hot spirit of the young one;
Scipio is reported thus to have spoken: "Even Quintus Fabius himself
has observed, conscript fathers, in the commencement of his speech, that
in the opinion he gave a feeling of jealousy might be suspected. And though
I dare not myself charge so great a man with harboring that feeling, yet,
whether it is owing to a defect in his language, or to the fact, that suspicion
has certainly not been removed. For he has so magnified his own honors
and the fame of his exploits, in order to do away with the imputation of
envy, that it would appear I am in danger of being rivalled by every obscure
person, but not by himself, because, as he enjoys an eminence above every
body else, an eminence to which I do not dissemble that I also aspire,
he is unwilling that I should be placed upon a level with him. He has represented
himself as an old man, and as one who has gone through every gradation
of honor, and me as below the age even of his son; as if he supposed that
the desire of glory did not exceed the limits of human life, and as if
its chief part had not respect to memory and future ages. I am confident,
that it is usual with all the most exalted minds, to compare themselves,
not only with the illustrious men of the present, but of every age. For
my own part, I do not dissemble that I am desirous, not only to attain
to the share of glory which you possess, Quintus Fabius, but, (and in saying
it I mean no offense,) if I can, even to exceed it. Let not such a feeling
exist in your mind towards me, nor in mine towards those who are my juniors,
as that we should be unwilling that any of our countrymen should attain
to the same celebrity with ourselves; for that would be a detriment, not
to those only who may be the objects of our envy, but to the state, and
almost to the whole human race. He mentioned what a great degree of danger
I should incur, should I cross over into Africa, so that he appeared solicitous
on my account, and not only for the state and the army. But whence has
this concern for me so suddenly sprung? When my father and uncle were slain;
when their two armies were cut up almost to a man; when Spain was lost;
when four armies of the Carthaginians and four generals kept possession
of every thing by terror and by arms; when a general was sought for to
take the command of that war, and no one came forward besides myself, no
one had the courage to declare himself a candidate; when the Roman people
had conferred the command upon me, though only twenty-four years of age;
why was it that no one at that time made any mention of my age, of the
strength of the enemy, of the difficulty of the war, and of the recent
destruction of my father and uncle? Has some greater disaster been suffered
in Africa now than had at that time befallen us in Spain? Are there now
larger armies in Africa, more and better generals, than were then in Spain?
Was my age then more mature for conducting a war than now? Can a war with
a Carthaginian enemy be carried on with greater convenience in Spain than
in Africa? After having routed and put to flight four Carthaginian armies;
after having captured by force, or reduced to submission by fear, so many
cities; after having entirely subdued every thing as far as the ocean,
so many petty princes, so many savage nations; after having regained possession
of the whole of Spain, so that no trace of war remains, it is an easy matter
to make light of my services; just as easy as it would be, should I return
victorious from Africa, to make light of those very circumstances which
are now magnified in order that they may appear formidable, for the purpose
of detaining me here. He says that there is no possibility of entering
Africa; that there are no ports open. He mentions that Marcus Atilius was
taken prisoner in Africa, as if Marcus Atilius had miscarried on his first
access to Africa. Nor does he recollect that the ports of Africa were open
to that very commander, unfortunate as he was; that he performed some brilliant
services during the first year, and continued undefeated to the last, so
far as related to the Carthaginian generals. You will not, therefore, in
the least deter me by that example of yours. If that disaster had been
sustained in the present, and not in the former war, if lately, and not
forty years ago, yet why would it be less advisable for me to cross over
into Africa after Regulus had been made prisoner there, than into Spain
after the Scipios had been slain there? I should be reluctant to admit
that the birth of Xanthippus the Lacedaemonian was more fortunate for Carthage
than mine for my country. My confidence would be increased by the very
circumstance, that such important consequences depended upon the valor
of one man. But further, we must take warning by the Athenians, who inconsiderately
crossed over into Sicily, leaving a war in their own country. Why, therefore,
since you have leisure to relate Grecian tales, do you not rather set before
us the instance of Agathocles, king of Syracuse, who, when Sicily was for
a long time wasted by a Punic war, by passing over into this same Africa,
removed the war to the country from whence it came.
44. "But what need is there of ancient and foreign examples to remind
us what sort of thing it is boldly to carry terror against an enemy, and,
removing the danger from oneself, to bring another into peril? Can there
be a stronger instance than Hannibal himself, or one more to the point?
It makes a great difference whether you devastate the territories of another,
or see your own destroyed by fire and sword. He who brings danger upon
another has more spirit than he who repels it. Add to this, that the terror
excited by unknown circumstances is increased on that account. When you
have entered the territory of an enemy, you may have a near view of his
advantages and disadvantages. Hannibal did not expect that it would come
to pass that so many of the states in Italy would come over to him as did
so after the defeat at Cannae. How much less would any firmness or constancy
be experienced in Africa by the Carthaginians, who are themselves faithless
allies, oppressive and haughty masters! Besides, we, even when deserted
by our allies, stood firm in our own strength, the Roman soldiery. The
Carthaginians possess no native strength. The soldiers they have are obtained
by hire;--Africans and Numidians--people remarkable above all others for
the inconstancy of their attachments. Provided no impediment arises here,
you will hear at once that I have landed, and that Africa is blazing with
war; that Hannibal is preparing for his departure from this country, and
that Carthage is besieged. Expect more frequent and more joyful dispatches
from Africa than you received from Spain. The considerations on which I
ground my anticipations are the good fortune of the Roman people, the gods,
the witnesses of the treaty violated by the enemy, the kings Syphax and
Masinissa; on whose fidelity I will rely in such a manner as that I may
be secure from danger should they prove perfidious. Many things which are
not now apparent, at this distance, the war will develop; and it is the
part of a man, and a general, not to be wanting when fortune presents itself,
and to bend its events to his designs. I shall, Quintus Fabius, have the
opponent you assign me, Hannibal; but I shall rather draw him after me
than be kept here by him. I will compel him to fight in his own country,
and Carthage shall be the prize of victory rather than the half-ruined
forts of the Bruttians. With regard to providing that the state sustain
no injury in the mean time, while I am crossing over, while I am landing
my troops in Africa, while I am advancing my camp to the walls of Carthage;
be not too sure that it is not an insult to Publius Licinius, the consul,
a man of consummate valor, who did not draw lots for so distant a province
merely that, as he was chief pontiff, he might not be absent from religious
affairs, to say that he is unable to do that, now that the power of Hannibal
is shaken, and in a manner shattered, which you Quintus Fabius, were able
to effect when he was flying victorious throughout all Italy. By Hercules,
even if the war would not be more speedily terminated by adopting the plan
I propose, yet it were consistent with the dignity of the Roman people,
and the high character they enjoy with foreign kings and nations, to appear
to have had spirit not only to defend Italy, but also to carry hostilities
into Africa; and that it should not be supposed and spread abroad that
no Roman general dared what Hannibal had dared; that in the former Punic
war, when the contest was about Sicily, Africa should have been so often
attacked by our fleets and armies, and that now, when the contest is about
Italy, Africa should be left undisturbed. Let Italy, which has so long
been harassed, at length enjoy some repose; let Africa, in her turn, be
fired and devastated. Let the Roman camp overhang the gates of Carthage
rather than that we should again behold the rampart of the enemy from our
walls. Let Africa be the seat of the remainder of the war. Let terror and
flight, the devastation of lands, the defection of allies, and all the
other calamities of war which have fallen upon us, through a period of
fourteen years, be turned upon her. It is sufficient for me to have spoken
on those matters which relate to the state, the war before us, and the
provinces which form the subject of deliberation. My discourse would be
tedious and uninteresting to you if, as Fabius has depreciated my services
in Spain, I should also in like manner endeavor, on the other hand, to
turn his glory into ridicule, and make the most of my own. I will do neither,
conscript fathers; and if in nothing else, though a young man, I shall
certainly have shown my superiority over this old man, in modesty and the
government of my tongue. Such has been my life, and such the services I
have performed, that I can gladly rest contented in silence with that opinion
which you have spontaneously conceived of me."
45. Scipio was heard less favorably, because, a report had been spread that, if he did not prevail with the senate to have Africa decreed to him as his province, he would immediately lay the matter before the people. Therefore, Quintus Fulvius, who had been consul four times, and censor, requested of the consul that he would openly declare in the senate whether "he submitted to the fathers to decide respecting the provinces; and whether he intended to abide by their determination, or to put it to the people." Scipio having replied that he would act as he thought for the interest of the state, Fulvius then rejoined: "When I asked you the question I was not ignorant of what answer you would give, or how you would act; for you plainly show that you are rather sounding than consulting the senate; and, unless we immediately decree to you the province you wish, have a bill ready (to lay before the people). Therefore," said he, "I require of you, tribunes of the people, to support me in refusing to give my opinion, because, though my recommendation should be adopted, the consul is not disposed to abide by it." An altercation then arose, the consul asserting that it was unfair for the tribunes to interpose so as to prevent any senator from living his opinion in his place on being asked it. The tribunes came to the determination, "that if the consul submit to the senate the question relating to the provinces, whatever the senate decree we shall consider as final, nor will we allow a bill to be proposed to the people on the subject. If he does not submit it to them, we will support any one who shall refuse to deliver his sentiments upon the matter." The consul requested the delay of a day to confer with his colleague. The next day the decision was submitted to the senate. The provinces were assigned in this manner: to one of the consuls Sicily and thirty ships of war, which Caius Servilius had commanded the former year; he was also permitted to cross over into Africa if he conceived it to be for the advantage of the state. To the other consul Bruttium and the war with Hannibal were assigned; with either that army which Lucius Veturius or that which Quintus Caecilius commanded. The two latter were to draw lots, and settle between themselves which should act in Bruttium with the two legions which the consul gave up; and he to whose lot that province fell, was to be continued in command for a year. The other persons also, besides the consuls and praetors, who were to take the command of armies and provinces, were continued in command. It fell to the lot of Quintus Caecilius to carry on the war against Hannibal in Bruttium, together with the consul. The games of Scipio were then celebrated in the presence of a great number of persons, and with the approbation of the spectators. The deputies, Marcus Pomponius Matho and Quintus Catius, sent to Delphi to convey a present out of the spoils taken from Hasdrubal, carried with them a golden crown of two hundred pounds' weight, and representations of the spoils made out of a thousand pounds' weight of silver. Scipio, though he could not obtain leave to levy troops, a point which he did not urge with great eagerness, obtained leave to take with him such as volunteered their services; and also, as he declared that the fleet would not be the occasion of expense to the state, to receive what was furnished by the allies for building fresh ships. First, the states of Etruria engaged to assist the consuls to the utmost of their respective abilities. The people of Caere furnished corn, and provisions of every description, for the crews; the people of Populoni furnished iron; of Tarquinii, cloth for sails; those of Volaterrae, planks for ships, and corn; those of Arretium, thirty thousand shields, as many helmets; and of javelins, Gallic darts, and long spears, they undertook to make up to the amount of fifty thousand, an equal number of each description, together with as many axes, mattocks, bills, buckets, and mills, as should be sufficient for fifty men of war, with a hundred and twenty thousand pecks of wheat; and to contribute to the support of the decurios and rowers on the voyage. The people of Perusia, Clusium, and Rusella furnished firs for building ships, and a great quantity of corn. Scipio had firs out of the public woods. The states of Umbria, and, besides them, the people of Nursia, Reate, and Amiternum, and all those of the Sabine territory, promised soldiers. Many of the Marsians, Pelignians, and Marrucinians volunteered to serve in the fleet. The Cameritans, as they were joined with the Romans in league on equal terms, sent an armed cohort of six hundred men. Having laid the keels of thirty ships, twenty of which were quinqueremes, and ten quadriremes, he prosecuted the work with such diligence, that, on the forty-fifth day after the materials were taken from the woods, the ships, being fully equipped and armed, were launched.
46. He set out into Sicily with thirty ships of war, with about seven thousand
volunteers on board. Publius Licinius came into Bruttium to the two consular
armies, of which he selected for himself that which Lucius Veturius, the
consul, had commanded. He allowed Metellus to continue in the command of
those legions which were before under him, concluding that he could act
more easily with the troops accustomed to his command. The praetors also
went to their different provinces. As there was a scarcity of money to
carry on the war, the quaestors were ordered to sell a district of the
Campanian territory extending from the Grecian trench to the sea, with
permission to receive information as to what land belonged to a native
Campanian, in order that it might be put into the possession of the Roman
people. The reward fixed upon for the informer was a tenth part of the
value of the lands so discovered. Cneius Servilius, the city praetor, was
also charged with seeing that the Campanians dwelt where they were allowed,
according to the decree of the senate, and to punish such as dwelt anywhere
else. The same summer, Mago, son of Amilcar, setting out from the lesser
of the Balearian islands, where he had wintered, having put on board his
fleet a chosen body of young men, conveyed over into Italy twelve thousand
foot, and about two thousand horse, with about thirty ships of war, and
a great number of transports. By the suddenness of his arrival he took
Genoa, as there were no troops employed in protecting the sea-coast. Thence
he brought his fleet to shore, on the coast of the Alpine Ligurians, to
see if he could create any commotion there. The Ingaunians, a tribe of
the Ligurians, were at that juncture engaged in war with the Epanterians,
a people inhabiting the mountains. The Carthaginian, therefore, having
deposited his plunder at Savo, an Alpine town, left ten ships of war for
its protection. He sent the rest to Carthage to guard the sea-coast, as
it was reported that Scipio intended to pass over thither; formed an alliance
with the Ingaunians, whose friendship he preferred; and commenced an attack
upon the mountaineers. His army increased daily, the Gauls flocking to
his standard from all sides, from the splendor of his fame. When the senate
received information of these things, by a letter from Spurius Lucretius,
they were filled with the most intense anxiety, lest the joy they had experienced
on the destruction of Hasdrubal and his army, two years before, should
be rendered vain by another war's springing up in the same quarter, equal
in magnitude, but under a new leader. They therefore ordered Marcus Livius,
proconsul, to march his army of volunteer slaves out of Etruria to Ariminum,
and gave in charge to Cneius Servilius to issue orders, if he thought it
necessary for the safety of the state, that the city legions should be
marched out under the command of any person he thought proper. Marcus Valerius
Laevinus led those legions to Arretium. About the same time, as many as
eighty transports of the Carthaginians were captured, near Sardinia, by
Cneius Octavius, who had the government of that province. Caelius states
that they were laden with corn and provisions, sent for Hannibal; Valerius,
that they were conveying the plunder of Etruria, and the Ligurian mountaineers
who had been captured, to Carthage.
In Bruttium scarcely any thing was done this year worth recording. A pestilence
had attacked both Romans and Carthaginians with equal violence; but the
Carthaginian army, in addition to sickness, was distressed by famine. Hannibal
passed the summer near the temple of Juno Lacinia, where he erected and
dedicated an altar with an inscription engraved in Punic and Greek characters,
setting forth, in pompous terms, the achievements he had performed.
|